“YOU’D JUST BE COMMITTING A WAR CRIME” - Malcolm Nance

Original Media · 9m · English · YouTube · Mario Nawfal

TLDR

Two defense analysts dissect the military infeasibility of a US ground invasion of Iran from Iraq, detailing how a month-long armor airlift would be shredded by Iranian missiles, fuel depots in Kuwait would be destroyed, Saudi Arabia would refuse basing, and Iraqi Shia militias would attack from the rear. They argue that even reaching the Iranian coast at Bandar Khamir would lead to a grinding asymmetric war against 93 million people with no strategic objective, while Iraq would instantly become an Iranian satellite state. They also analyze a recent Iranian salvo of 10 missiles toward a US destroyer 200 km away, assessing it as likely targeting a merchant convoy with the warship as a distant anti-missile screen, possibly to probe US radar and missile defenses. The conversation also covers the war-crime nature of bombing border truck parks to starve Iran, and the extreme vulnerability of Iraq's prime minister caught between militias, Israeli overflights, and Iranian influence. The GCC's move of its military HQ to Kuwait City is framed as fear of an Iranian counter-invasion through the historic Basra-Kuwait corridor. Throughout, the veteran analyst draws on direct Gulf War experience and CENTCOM planning simulations to dismiss invasion scenarios as "fantasy baseball."

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The US cannot starve Iran by hitting border trucks because food transport in the region easily reverts to donkey carts and decentralized methods.

•

A US invasion of Iran would likely result in Iraq immediately becoming an Iranian satellite state, not a stable US ally.

•

The Iranian missile launch at a distant US destroyer was probably not an attack on the ship but a probe of US defenses or a strike on a nearby merchant convoy.

•

The Gulf Cooperation Council moved its military HQ to Kuwait specifically because they fear an Iranian counter-invasion through the same route the US would use.

Key takeaways

•

A US ground invasion of Iran from Iraq is logistically impossible because armor would take a month to airlift under Iranian missile fire, fuel depots in Kuwait would be destroyed, Saudi Arabia would refuse basing, and Iraqi Shia militias would attack US forces from the rear.

•

Even if US forces reached the Iranian coast at Bandar Khamir, advancing into the uplands would face 93 million hostile Iranians using asymmetric tactics including suicide bombers on donkeys, with no clear strategic objective.

•

An invasion would cause Iraq to instantly become an Iranian-aligned Shia state, handing over all US-supplied equipment to Tehran and creating a contiguous Iranian sphere from Yemen to the Mediterranean.

•

The recent Iranian launch of 10 missiles toward a US destroyer 200 km away was likely not targeting the warship but rather a merchant convoy passing nearby, with the destroyer serving as an anti-missile screen hundreds of kilometers from the actual ships.

•

Iran may have fired the missiles to probe US radar and missile defense responses — lighting up SPY-1 radars and forcing SM-6 expenditures — though the expert considers this a waste of Iranian resources at that range.

•

Bombing truck assembly points at Iran's borders to starve the country would constitute a war crime, killing drivers from Turkey, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Russia, Central Asia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Iraq, and would fail because food transport would simply revert to donkey carts and diversified methods.

•

Iraqi Prime Minister Al-Sudani is politically vulnerable, caught between Iranian-backed Shia militias, Sunni factions with ISIS ties, and Israeli overflights; a single suicide bomber or Israeli strike on Iraqi F-16s could collapse his government and hand Iraq to Iran.

•

The GCC's sudden decision to place its military headquarters in Kuwait City reflects fear that an Iranian counter-invasion through the same historic Basra-Kuwait corridor could topple Gulf monarchies if the US attacks Iran.

Notable quotes

“You're going to kill Turkish, Azerbaijani, Armenian, Russian, Turk men, uh, you know, Tajik, not Tajik, Turk Menistan, Turkmen, Afghan, Pakistanis, and Iraqis. You're going to kill them at the truck parks because they've crossed the border into Iran. That's madness.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:10

“First off, you and what army?”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:40

“I have fought that war, okay? I helped liberate Kuwait. We had all of Saudi Arabia to hide in. That isn't going to happen if if you know US Army forward central command forward headquarters, you know, in in Camp Arifjan or up at Camp Buehring is getting blitzed with drones and ballistic missiles every day.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:14

“So that's why we have to get these scenarios out of our head because Iraq overnight will become a Iranian Shia nation alongside of Yemen fully government run by them, all the US equipment given to them. That's a bad scenario.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:56

“I believe that likely they didn't actually attack that ship specifically. I think there's a convoy running through and that ship was the was the anti-missile screen, right? not even escorting because he's hundreds of kilometers away from the actual ships that would be running”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:26

“What is 200 kilometers, man? It's like a 100 nautical miles. Sit there for an hour waiting for those damn missiles to come.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:35

Chapters

•

0:00 — Bombing Border Trucks to Starve Iran: The hosts discuss a reported US plan to bomb truck assembly points at Iranian border checkpoints, noting it would kill civilian drivers from multiple nations, constitute a war crime, and fail to stop food flow which would revert to donkey carts and diversified transport.

•

1:42 — Iraqi PM's Precarious Position: Analysis of Iraqi Prime Minister Al-Sudani's vulnerability between Shia militias, Sunni factions, and Israeli overflights, with a single suicide bomber or Israeli strike on Iraqi F-16s potentially collapsing his government and handing Iraq to Iran.

•

2:49 — US Invasion Plans via Boubyan Island: Discussion of reported US contingency plans to invade Iran through Boubyan Island in Kuwait, a historic invasion corridor from the Iran-Iraq War, prompting the GCC to move its military headquarters to Kuwait City in anticipation of Iranian counter-invasion.

•

4:19 — Logistical Impossibility of Ground Invasion: Detailed breakdown of why a US ground invasion from Iraq is fantasy: month-long armor airlift under missile fire, vulnerable fuel depots, Saudi refusal to participate, Iraqi militia attacks, and no viable basing.

•

6:30 — The Bandar Khamir Cul-de-Sac: Even if US forces reached the Iranian coast at Bandar Khamir, advancing into the uplands would face 93 million hostile Iranians using asymmetric warfare, with no achievable strategic objective.

•

7:14 — Iranian Missile Launch Analysis: Assessment that Iran's launch of 10 missiles toward a US destroyer 200 km away likely targeted a merchant convoy, with the destroyer as a distant anti-missile screen, and may have been a probe of US radar and missile defenses.

•

8:10 — Mosaic Doctrine and Engagement Range: Discussion of the Mosaic combat doctrine, noting that at 200 km the engagement is a waste of resources, while at 50 km reaction time would be minimal, and US E-2C Hawkeye and SPY-1 radars provide ample early warning.

Speakers

•

Speaker 1 — Defense analyst / Gulf War veteran

•

Speaker 2 — Interviewer / Podcast host

⋮