TLDR
Jackie and Paige react in real-time to the 2009 Friday the 13th remake, directed by Marcus Nispel and produced by Michael Bay. They praise the film's feral, tunnel-dwelling Jason as the scariest iteration yet, appreciate the grounded survivalist take over supernatural teleporting, and enjoy the practical gore and underground lair. After the movie, they discuss favorite kills, answer audience questions about the franchise's timeline, and express strong desire to cover Nightmare on Elm Street next. Paige reveals Scream traumatized her as a child and may have contributed to her parents' divorce. Both hosts rate the remake highly despite its low Rotten Tomatoes score, calling it a successful modern slasher that honors the original's core.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The hosts prefer the tunnel-system explanation for Jason's speed over supernatural teleportation, calling the latter 'lazy' despite the franchise's increasingly fantastical elements.
Paige attributes her parents' potential divorce to her childhood fear of Scream, a real-life consequence of horror movie trauma rarely discussed in fandom spaces.
The 2009 remake and Jason X share an identical 27% Rotten Tomatoes critics score, yet the hosts and audience view the remake far more favorably than its reputation suggests.
Jason's actor Derek Mears also played a role in the TV series 'Supernatural' and 'Gilmore Girls,' connecting the franchise to early-2000s WB/CW staple casting in an unexpected way.
Key takeaways
The 2009 remake reimagines Jason as a feral survivalist who uses an extensive tunnel system to move quickly, replacing the supernatural teleportation of later sequels with a practical, grounded explanation that the hosts find more believable and terrifying.
Whitney, the final girl, is held captive for six weeks in Jason's underground lair because she resembles his mother — a psychological twist that adds emotional weight and makes her eventual escape feel earned rather than lucky.
The hosts note this version of Jason displays childlike vulnerability — he reacts to his name, turns off lights when scared, and protects his mother's locket — making him more human and unsettling than the silent, unstoppable force of earlier films.
Practical effects and brutal, lingering kills (the bear trap, the wood chipper, the throat impalement) make this the goriest and most visceral entry they've watched, with the hosts physically reacting to several death scenes.
The film's script balances modern slasher tropes (sex, drugs, douchebag boyfriend) with genuine character moments, and the hosts appreciate that the humor doesn't undercut the tension the way later franchise entries often do.
Paige's childhood trauma from watching Scream — which she believes may have caused her parents' divorce after she slept in their room for three years — explains her reluctance to cover that franchise despite audience demand.
The hosts and their audience view the Friday the 13th timeline as loosely continuous until this remake, which serves as a 'back to basics' reboot that incorporates elements from the first four films while updating Jason for a 2000s audience.
Derek Mears' portrayal of Jason is singled out as a favorite for his physicality, intelligence (using surroundings, setting traps), and the tragic feral-child backstory conveyed through performance rather than exposition.
Notable quotes
“Jason is protecting the crops. I'm going to be so happy if that's what this movie is about.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:36“I like how childlike this Jason is.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:17“This is my favorite, Jason. I want more.”
▸ Notable quotes · 73:01“I don't like the teleporting. It feels lazy.”
▸ Notable quotes · 65:48“He's never going to die. And then you know what annoys me more than never killing him off cuz I kind of like an open-ended especially with the horror. What annoys me is when like they did this in Halloween I feel like No, they did it in this one too where they go like also they did it in H2O.”
▸ Notable quotes · 66:54“I would have been in the bed with Kevin Bacon getting some double penetration.”
▸ Notable quotes · 73:34Chapters
0:00 — Opening & Movie Start: Jackie and Paige introduce the episode on Friday the 13th, note the Michael Bay production logo, and react to the Paramount studio intro turning red and bloody.
1:04 — Original Timeline Recap: The hosts watch the opening flashback to 1980 showing Pamela Voorhees killing counselors and young Jason witnessing her beheading, comparing the gritty tone to Rob Zombie's Halloween remake.
3:04 — First Group & Jason's Lair: A group of campers searches for a weed crop, discovers Jason's underground tunnel system and shrine to his mother, and suffers the film's first brutal kills including a bear trap and sleeping bag roast.
14:06 — Six Weeks Later — Clay's Search: Clay Miller arrives looking for his missing sister Whitney, clashes with local police and a hostile store owner, and meets Jenna who helps him investigate the abandoned Camp Crystal Lake area.
30:00 — Cabin Group & Escalating Kills: Trent, Jenna, Chewie, and others party at a lakeside cabin; Jason picks them off one by one with practical, gruesome kills including a wood chipper foreshadowing and a throat impalement through a floorboard.
45:00 — Underground Lair & Whitney Revealed: Clay discovers the tunnel system, finds Whitney alive but traumatized after six weeks of captivity, and they attempt escape while Jason hunts them through his own lair.
52:00 — Final Confrontation & Wood Chipper: Clay, Whitney, and Jenna flee to the barn; Clay is seemingly killed but returns; Whitney lures Jason using his mother's locket and feeds him into the wood chipper before dumping his body and mask in the lake.
54:00 — Post-Movie Discussion & Q&A: The hosts praise the remake's grounded tone, feral Jason, and practical gore; answer audience questions about tunnel logic vs. teleporting, favorite Jason actors, horror franchise trauma, and confirm desire to cover Nightmare on Elm Street next.
Speakers
Jackie — Co-host
Paige — Co-host