TLDR
This episode investigates the 2022 murder of Michael Harding, a California HVAC technician who disappeared after responding to a fake service call in Kentucky. His wife, Julie Harding — a California Highway Patrol captain — became the prime suspect after investigators uncovered a burner phone trail linking her to Thomas O'Donnell, a man she met on a millionaire dating site. O'Donnell was convicted of murder, while Julie died by suicide before charges could be filed, leaving their children convinced she orchestrated the killing.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The burner phone's locational data and O'Donnell's personal phone traveled in 'lockstep' across the South in the weeks before the murder, providing a digital trail of the conspiracy.
Julie Harding, a high-ranking law enforcement officer, allegedly used her knowledge of police procedures to avoid cooperation — referring all questions to a lawyer immediately after her husband's body was found.
The house in Celina, Tennessee, had a local reputation for being 'cursed,' with a history of violence and even a prior exorcism attempt by a realtor.
Mike Harding had chained and padlocked his doors from the inside, fearing Julie would enter while he slept — and told friends to investigate her if anything happened to him.
Despite being a captain in the California Highway Patrol, Julie Harding never reported her husband's alleged 'ghost gun' and drug dealing to authorities, instead telling colleagues a 'friend' in Tennessee law enforcement was looking into it — a claim investigators could not verify.
Key takeaways
Michael Harding was lured to a vacant Kentucky property via texts from a fake realtor named 'James Fraser' and shot four times.
The burner phone used to arrange the murder was first activated in Houston, Texas — the hometown of Thomas O'Donnell, a man Julie Harding had called 194 times in two months.
Julie Harding withdrew approximately $360,000 from joint accounts shortly before the murder, which prosecutors believe funded the hit.
DNA from Mike's stolen gun and Hornady Critical Defense bullets (matching the murder casing) were found in O'Donnell's truck upon his arrest.
Julie Harding was arrested for criminal trespass after taking Mike's dog from a friend's house via Ring camera footage, but never charged with murder.
Julie died by suicide on December 10, 2022, leaving a blood-stained note blaming Mike: 'You win! You got what you wanted. Me in a coffin.'
At trial, O'Donnell's defense admitted he was at the crime scene and opened the door for the killer, but claimed someone else pulled the trigger.
The jury convicted O'Donnell of murder in two hours; Mike's children believe Julie was the mastermind, while her friend insists she was innocent.
Notable quotes
“Brian, they found him! They found him! They found him!”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:40“He told his friends that if he ever was murdered or disappeared or something nefarious happened to him, that they needed to make sure somebody looked at Julie Harding.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:05“I've lived a good life until a year ago. Mike, you win! You got what you wanted. Me in a coffin.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:38“She was the true monster of all of this. She was the one that executed every move other than physically pulling the trigger on my father.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:19“My dad was the victim in this case, not Julie.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:28Chapters
0:09 — Disappearance and Discovery: Mike Harding vanishes after a service call in Kentucky; his body is found days later in a vacant garage by a house-hunting family.
9:58 — The Burner Phone and a Fake Realtor: Investigators trace texts to a burner phone activated in Houston, linked to a fictitious 'James Fraser' who lured Mike to the property.
12:58 — Marriage, Money, and Motive: Julie and Mike's long-distance marriage unravels amid divorce, large cash withdrawals, infidelity suspicions, and mutual fear.
25:47 — The O'Donnell Connection: Julie's 194 calls to Thomas O'Donnell, a man with a stalking past and financial desperation, align with the burner phone's movements.
31:28 — Arrests and a Stolen Dog: O'Donnell is arrested with Mike's stolen gun and matching ammunition; Julie is charged with trespass after taking Mike's dog on camera.
34:02 — Julie Harding's Suicide: Julie dies by suicide at the lake house, leaving a note blaming Mike; investigators believe she saw the case closing in.
36:40 — Trial and Conviction: O'Donnell's defense admits presence at the scene but denies pulling the trigger; jury convicts him of murder in two hours.
39:58 — Aftermath and Competing Narratives: Mike's children and Julie's friend offer starkly different portraits of her role; the family mourns a father they say was the true victim.
Speakers
Peter Van Sant — Narrator / Correspondent
Preston Cleary — Mike Harding's Friend
Brandon Boone — Sheriff, Clay County, Tennessee
BJ Burton — Detective, Kentucky State Police
Ann Marie Gordon Anderson — Prosecutor
Jesse Stockton — Prosecutor
Steven Harding — Mike Harding's Son
Heather Cavalieri — Mike Harding's Daughter
Brian Wittmer — Sergeant, California Highway Patrol
Kathy Rourke — Julie Harding's Close Friend
David Hammersley — Witness / Home Buyer
David Ogletree — Mail Carrier
Thomas O'Donnell — Defendant / Convicted Murderer
Sara Zeurcher — Defense Attorney
David Williams — Judge, Cumberland County