TLDR
Attorney General Todd Blanche initially echoed President Trump's calls to criminally investigate Democratic lawmakers for planning congressional oversight, labeling them 'extortionists' and the 'seditious six,' but then walked back those threats on television, admitting no criminal investigations exist. Legal experts Joyce Vance and Lisa Rubin explain that Blanche's reversal likely stems from the Speech or Debate Clause protecting legislative acts, the impossibility of proving criminal threats from oversight promises, and a string of grand jury rejections in Trump's 'revenge docket' cases that Blanche falsely claimed were normal.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A sitting Attorney General publicly threatened to criminalize congressional oversight, then admitted on television that 'her comments alone are absolutely not a crime' within the same interview.
The Attorney General used the president's political nickname 'seditious six' for members of Congress, violating the longstanding norm that prosecutors do not prejudge guilt or adopt partisan rhetoric.
Joyce Vance states she never had a grand jury refuse to indict in her 25-year career, contradicting Blanche's claim that such rejections are routine.
Key takeaways
Trump demanded criminal probes into Democrats merely for announcing they would exercise constitutional oversight powers when taking the majority in January, calling them extortionists who should be imprisoned.
Attorney General Todd Blanche initially supported this rhetoric on Sunday shows but reversed course days later, stating there are no criminal investigations and that lawmakers' comments alone are not a crime.
The panel notes this criminalization of routine oversight is unprecedented; both parties have promised aggressive investigations when gaining power, but never treated it as criminal conduct.
Joyce Vance, a 25-year DOJ veteran, says the number of grand jury 'no true bills' in DC for Trump's political cases in recent months exceeds what she saw in her entire career, indicating prosecutors are presenting weak cases.
Prosecutors control the grand jury process and can ensure sufficient evidence before presenting; repeated refusals to indict suggest the cases lack legal merit and are politically motivated.
Blanche's use of Trump's 'seditious six' label for members of Congress violates prosecutorial norms against prejudging guilt and ignores Speech or Debate Clause immunity for legislative acts.
Preet Bharara, Blanche's former boss at SDNY, now represents Senator Slotkin and publicly challenged Blanche, signaling that career prosecutors recognize the departure from legal standards.
The reversal suggests DOJ leadership realized they would lose a constitutional showdown with Congress and that Trump, who hates losing, was persuaded to back down.
Notable quotes
“He said that the Democratic lawmakers are extortionists and they should be imprisoned. Is that a possibility? Well, it depends on what the what the crime is and what they've done.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:44“There can come a point when when a criticism becomes a threat and then when a threat becomes something criminal. There's no ongoing investigations, criminal investigations into words that that incoming senators or congressmen have said.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:37“We've seen more no true bills. That's a grand jury that fails to indict in the District of Columbia alone in the last few months than I saw in my entire career, 25 years at the Justice Department.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:34“Prosecutors control the process. And when you see these sort of repeat refusals by grand juries in cases that are part of Donald Trump's revenge docket, you know that something there ain't right, as we say in the South.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:32“Attorneys generals, like every other federal prosecutor, don't prejudge guilt or innocence. So picking up the president's moniker there is highly inappropriate.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:43“This is the way autocrats behave.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:02Chapters
0:00 — Trump demands criminal probes of Democrats: After midterm losses, Trump ordered criminal investigations into Democratic lawmakers who pledged to exercise oversight, calling them extortionists who should be imprisoned.
0:44 — Blanche backpedals on television: Attorney General Todd Blanche initially left the door open for prosecutions but then stated there are no criminal investigations and lawmakers' comments alone are not a crime.
2:03 — Panel analyzes the unprecedented threat: Peter Baker, Joyce Vance, and Lisa Rubin discuss how criminalizing routine congressional oversight is unprecedented and likely unconstitutional under the Speech or Debate Clause.
7:00 — Grand jury rejections in Trump's revenge docket: Joyce Vance details the unusual number of grand jury 'no true bills' in DC for politically motivated cases, explaining prosecutors control the process and repeated refusals indicate legally insufficient cases.
8:47 — Blanche adopts Trump's 'seditious six' rhetoric: Blanche used Trump's partisan label for members of Congress, violating prosecutorial norms; Preet Bharara, Blanche's former boss, now represents a targeted senator and condemns the behavior as autocratic.
Speakers
Host — Anchor
Peter Baker — Guest
Joyce Vance — Guest
Lisa Rubin — Guest
Rachel Maddow — Host