TLDR
Mythical Kitchen host Josh and guest Tom Scott blindly taste-test 12 Erewhon products — from $12 Sacred Water to $65 liposomal magnesium packets — guessing each item's name, ingredients, health claims, and price. The game exposes how Erewhon markets ordinary ingredients with vague wellness language and extreme markups, while Tom's British perspective highlights cultural disconnects around American health food trends. Josh wins 22.5 to 20, earning a $26 bottle of hyper-oxygenated water vortexed over rose quartz.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Erewhon is named after an 1872 satirical novel where illness is treated as criminal and doctors are illegal — the store's entire brand originates from a dystopian parody of personal health responsibility.
The $12 'Sacred Water' contains organic grape juice, coconut milk, coconut water, jasmine tea, holy basil, anise, cardamom, and raw honey — essentially a fancy juice blend marketed as a 'deeply hydrating elixir' with 'antioxidants and soothing properties.'
Kelp noodles are 99% water and sodium alginate (a thickener), contain only 6 calories per half cup, and the 'heavy metal detox' claim comes from alginate's industrial use in nuclear waste cleanup, not human nutrition.
The parasite supplement's first ingredient is grain alcohol — making it essentially a tincture — and the 'parasite cleanse' trend coincides with an actual diarrhea-causing parasite outbreak in LA, turning a public health issue into a $25 supplement sale.
The hyper-oxygenated water prize ($25.99) is vortexed over rose quartz crystals and infused with 'harmonic sound frequencies' — the hosts joke one of Willie Nelson's kids played harmonica at it.
The Liquid Steel smoothie's gray color comes from blue spirulina mixed with brown fruit juices, not the trash can sponsorship; the 'steel' branding is purely a marketing collab with a company that makes automatic soap dispensers.
Bee pollen at $33/jar carries a warning: 'Not for individuals with allergies to pollen or bee products' — the very people most likely to buy it for 'allergy relief' are explicitly told not to consume it.
Tom Scott has never heard of Tom's Shoes (the one-for-one business model), Nando's peri-peri chicken, or Erewhon — three cultural touchstones Josh assumes are globally ubiquitous — highlighting how insular LA's wellness bubble is.
Key takeaways
Erewhon's business model relies on selling ordinary ingredients — sea moss, kelp, honey, pollen — at 10-50x markup by attaching vague wellness claims like 'gut health,' 'immunity,' and 'longevity' without scientific specificity.
The 'Price is Right' guessing game reveals how completely detached Erewhon's pricing is from production costs: a $12 cup of grape juice and coconut water, $65 for 30 magnesium packets, $33 for bee pollen, and $26 for hyper-oxygenated water.
Many products use scientific-sounding terms — 'liposomal,' 'sacha inchi,' 'alginate,' 'A2 protein' — that most consumers (and even the hosts) cannot define, creating an illusion of sophistication that justifies price.
Raw milk is sold legally at Erewhon for $13 with a warning label about disease-causing microorganisms, illustrating how regulatory loopholes allow risky products to be marketed as 'nutrient intact' wellness items.
The kelp noodles — marketed as mineral-rich, heavy-metal-detoxifying pasta — are revealed to be mostly water and sodium alginate with only 6 calories per serving, exposing how functional food claims often describe the base ingredient, not the final product.
The Liquid Steel smoothie collaboration with Simple Human (a $400 trash can company) demonstrates how Erewhon's ecosystem extends beyond food into lifestyle branding, where a gray smoothie gets marketed for 'muscle function' and 'post-workout recovery' because a trash can sponsor paid for it.
Tom Scott's British perspective — never having heard of Tom's Shoes, Nando's, or Erewhon — acts as a control variable, showing how normalized American wellness extravagance has become to locals who no longer question $12 peanut butter bars or $25 sea moss gel.
Even food professionals cannot identify products blind: Josh (a chef) mistakes prairie honey for manuka, Tom mistakes Sacha Inchi for Korean grain powder, and both fail to recognize the parasite supplement's grain alcohol base, proving heavy processing and flavor masking erase ingredient identity.
Notable quotes
“In a world where illness is treated as criminal and criminals are treated as if they're ill.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:00“It's not backwards but scrambled. The scramble, it's an anagram.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:14“The smaller the bottle the more expensive it is.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:56“This is only 2 bucks a pack? We can't afford not to.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:33“You can go to Chili's and get a steak for 12 bucks, you know?”
▸ Notable quotes · 19:36“To mimic the ribbons of nature the water is vortexed over rose quartz crystals and infused with harmonic sound frequencies.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:10Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Sacred Water: Josh introduces Tom Scott and the Erewhon tasting game. They taste Sacred Water by Jolie Tonics ($12), a blend of grape juice, coconut milk, coconut water, jasmine tea, holy basil, anise, cardamom, and raw honey marketed as a hydrating elixir. Tom guesses aqua kefir; Josh guesses clarified yogurt. Tom wins the round.
7:37 — Sea Moss Gel & Liposomal Magnesium: They taste Blue Pearl Sea Moss Gel ($25) with Irish sea moss, spirulina, and pearl powder — Tom correctly identifies sea moss. Next, liposomal magnesium almond cacao ($65/30 packs) — Josh recognizes the gel texture from glycerin and avocado oil; both miss the chocolate extract. Health claims: muscle function, nervous system relaxation, stress reduction.
15:44 — Peanut Butter Jelly Bar & Reishi Brownie: Giselle's raw vegan peanut butter jelly bar ($12) with pea protein, oat flour, coconut butter, strawberry, maple syrup — Josh guesses 'Bliss Cubes'; Tom gets ingredients right. Reishi chaga brownie ($5.50) with coconut sugar, almond flour, walnuts, tapioca — Tom nails the mushroom health claims (nervous system, immunity, blood sugar); Josh gets ingredients.
23:37 — Raw Milk & Sacha Inchi Protein: Raw milk ($13) — Tom backs off raw milk guess due to liability; Josh guesses A2 half-and-half. Both miss digestive health claim. Sacha Inchi protein powder ($30) — Josh identifies sesame/toasted notes; Tom guesses Korean grain powder. Brand describes itself as 'guided by a team of funky inspired super food revolutionaries.'
31:07 — Bee Pollen & Kelp Noodles: Beekeepers Naturals bee pollen ($33) — Josh guesses correctly; health claims: immune support, allergy relief, enhanced energy. Kelp noodles ($5) — both identify as noodles/seaweed; ingredients: water, kelp, sodium alginate. Only 6 calories per serving; claims include vitamin K, calcium, and heavy metal reduction via alginate.
39:03 — Liquid Steel Smoothie & Parasite Supplement: Liquid Steel smoothie ($12) — collab with Simple Human trash cans; ingredients: watermelon, coconut water, lime, strawberry, pineapple, blue spirulina, vanilla collagen, creatine, magnesium, sea salt. Tom names it 'The Gray Bastard.' Parasite supplement ($25) — grain alcohol base with quassia wood, black walnut hulls, garrya leaf, clove, bayberry root; claims full parasite detox.
50:04 — Prairie Honey & Hyper-Oxygenated Water Prize: Creamed raw prairie honey ($33) — Josh identifies manuka/honey correctly; health claims: gut health, immunity, antibacterial, anti-inflammatory. Josh wins 22.5 to 20. Prize: Nanopure hyper-oxygenated water ($26) vortexed over rose quartz with harmonic sound frequencies. Tom plugs 'Tom Scott England,' 'Lateral' podcast, and 'Jet Lag' season.
Speakers
Josh — Host
Tom Scott — Guest
Annaliese — Co-host/Judge
Jake — Crew member