Vance, Rubio and Hegseth Spin Their Own Versions of the Reason We Went to War with Iran

Original Media · 7m · English · YouTube · Megyn Kelly

TLDR

The discussion analyzes the political fallout from the Iran war, focusing on defenses by Pete Hegseth and Marco Rubio, who frame the conflict as necessary to prevent a nuclear Iran. The hosts argue the war was actually fought for Israel, contradicting Trump's anti-war mandate, and predict catastrophic electoral consequences for the GOP, with a clear 2028 divide emerging between JD Vance's isolationist wing and the national security establishment represented by Hegseth and Rubio. Trump's 2024 victory was driven by anti-war sentiment, making the war a betrayal of his base.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Rubio's CPAC defense references the June 2025 initial strikes, not the February 2026 escalation, suggesting a shifting justification for the war.

•

Veterans in desert fatigues appearing at Trump rallies in 2016 were a visible sign of a pro-military but anti-war constituency that Trump successfully mobilized.

•

The midterm loss (November 2026) is attributed to the war, yet the war began in June 2025, indicating a delayed but severe political reckoning.

Key takeaways

•

Pete Hegseth refuses to criticize the Iran war or JD Vance's midterm loss assessment, stating the war was 'done for the right reasons' to stop Iran's nuclear program.

•

Marco Rubio defends the war at CPAC as a moral duty to confront a radical regime, echoing Trump's 'hard things' rhetoric.

•

The hosts contend the war was fought for Israel, not US security, and that its electoral consequences are only beginning to be felt.

•

A 2028 fracture is visible: JD Vance represents the anti-war/isolationist wing, while Hegseth and Rubio represent the national security/hawkish wing.

•

Trump's 2016 and 2024 coalitions included veterans and anti-war voters; the Iran war undermines that core support.

•

The VP selection of Vance over Rubio was a deliberate signal toward an isolationist foreign policy, which the Iran war contradicts.

Notable quotes

“I respect the vice president greatly and I'm certainly not going to uh exchange in any fingerpointing and thankfully politics is not really my thing. Uh I do the department of war and making sure we're prepared and ready.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:24

“If I had to do this all over again, would we do it again? Absolutely. It was done for the right reasons to ensure Iran never gets a nuclear weapon.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:55

“He was elected to do the hard things. The hard things. It would have been very easy to do what multiple presidents before him would have done, which just ignore the Iran thing. Leave it for the next guy.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:20

“He did it for Israel. Well, that's so obvious. We all know that. Marco Rubio is the one who told us that the day after we launched the Iran war.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:01

“Trump was elected to not go to war. That was the primary reason for the amount of support that he got in 2024.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:53

“The decision to make JD Vance the nominee over Rubio was because of a decision within Trump's team to send a signal in a more anti-war direction.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:12

Chapters

•

0:00 — Hegseth Defends Iran War, Avoids Blame: Pete Hegseth responds to JD Vance's claim that the GOP lost the midterms due to the Iran war, refusing to criticize Vance or Trump, and asserts the war was necessary to prevent a nuclear Iran.

•

1:14 — Rubio's CPAC Speech: War as Necessary Duty: Marco Rubio argues at CPAC that Trump was elected to do 'hard things' like confronting Iran, framing the war as a moral imperative to protect the US way of life from a radical regime.

•

3:07 — Electoral Fallout and 2028 Fractures: The hosts argue the war was fought for Israel, not US security, and that its catastrophic electoral consequences are just beginning, with clear lines drawn between Vance (anti-war) and Hegseth/Rubio (pro-war) for 2028.

•

3:53 — Trump's Anti-War Mandate vs. Neocon Wing: Matt explains Trump's 2024 victory was driven by anti-war sentiment, evidenced by the VP pick of Vance over Rubio, and that the Iran war betrays the veteran and isolationist base that powered Trump's rise.

Speakers

•

Megan — Host

•

Matt — Co-host/Guest

⋮