MTG Commander Showdown Sponsored by eBay Live | Championship

Original Media · 3h 37m · English · YouTube · Critical Role

TLDR

The Critical Role MTG Commander Showdown finale features four players (Alex Ward, Zach Ronaldo, Olivia Gobear Hicks, Elise Work) competing in a chaotic, humor-filled Commander game hosted by Irene the Alien and Bosco. Interspersed with live eBay auctions benefiting the Critical Role Foundation, the game includes deck-swap twists, missed triggers, and an illegal play that goes unnoticed. Elise Work ultimately wins after a 17/17 Multani tramples over the board, with the three-night event raising $6,000 for charity. The hosts provide running commentary mixing game analysis, pop-culture tangents, and absurdist banter. The real winner is the Critical Role Foundation, which has raised over $4 million since 2020.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The winning play (Avenger of Zendikar returned via Eternal Witness) was illegal — Avenger had been exiled by Path to Exile, not in the graveyard, but no one caught it.

•

Zach's Knight Exemplar gave all knights indestructibility, which survived Olivia's Organic Extinction board wipe, but he forgot to equip his Sword of Vengeance earlier, missing a free 2/2 knight token.

•

Alex hard-cast Mulldrifter for 6 mana instead of evoking it for 3, drawing praise from the hosts for the 'respect the hell out of a hard cast Mulldrifter.'

•

Olivia's Omenkeel milled a board wipe (Echoing Truth) from Elise's library that would have bounced all her plant tokens — effectively protecting Elise's board by accident.

•

The hosts reveal they've raised over $4 million for the Critical Role Foundation since 2020, with this three-night event adding $6,000.

•

Bosco shares he had top surgery (double mastectomy with nipple grafts), describing the 'keyhole' scars under his nipples as 'pierholes' and calling gender-affirming care 'for everyone.'

•

The final auction includes a 'shuffle simulator 3000' joke about Elise's deck (AC landfall) which involved constant shuffling, selling for $470.

Key takeaways

•

Elise Work wins the tournament with a landfall deck featuring Avenger of Zendikar and Multani, Yavimaya's Avatar, despite an illegal play where she returned Avenger from exile instead of the graveyard.

•

The event raises $6,000 across three nights for the Critical Role Foundation, supporting charities like 826LA, Outright International, Shanti Bhavan, First Nations Development Institute, and NCWIT.

•

Zach Ronaldo pilots a Sedgemoor Witch/Jabari deck with Knight synergies but misses key triggers (forgetting to equip Sword of Vengeance, missing Lightning Rager creation).

•

Olivia Gobear Hicks plays a vehicle deck centered on Omenkeel, which exiles a critical Echoing Truth that would have wiped Elise's plant tokens.

•

Alex Ward switches to a Grixis artifacts deck (Yellow the Painter) but hard-casts Mulldrifter instead of evoking it, and later vandalblasts his own board out of spite.

•

Live auctions feature signed playmats, booster packs, and player-used decks, with a gold-foil Mollymauk Tealeaf playmat selling for $555 and Olivia's Squirrel deck for $540.

•

The hosts (Irene and Bosco) provide comedic commentary ranging from Magic rules debates to personal anecdotes about soup, pillows, and bisexual visibility.

•

Multiple rules errors occur: missed triggers, incorrect retrace explanation, phased-out creatures incorrectly handled, and the game-winning Avenger of Zendikar returned from exile illegally.

Notable quotes

“Since 2020, thanks to this incredible community, the Critical Role Foundation has raised over $4 million to help people around the world.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:53

“We're not all just dreaming of change. We're doing our best to leave the world better than we found it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:53

“Life's a resource and I never have a lot of it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:15

“The power of cheating.”

▸ Notable quotes · 206:19

“Every single dollar of that matters. Thank you guys so much for watching. Thank you for bidding and thank you for hanging out with two fabulous idiots.”

▸ Notable quotes · 215:38

“You have shown us what's possible when a community comes together.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:48

Chapters

•

1:53 — Charity Introduction & Foundation Overview: The Critical Role Foundation's work since 2020 is highlighted: $4M+ raised, seven partner charities named (826LA, Red Nose Day, Outright International, Shanti Bhavan, First Nations Development Institute, Pablo Foundation, NCWIT).

•

21:10 — Hosts & Player Introductions: Irene the Alien and Bosco introduce the Spell Slayers show, the four finalists (Alex, Zach, Olivia, Elise), and the eBay Live sponsorship with live auctions benefiting CRF.

•

23:50 — Deck Selection & Swap Phase: Finalists choose to keep or swap decks in health order. Elise keeps Aesi, Olivia swaps to Esper artifacts, Zach keeps Jabari, Alex switches to Yellow the Painter (Grixis).

•

34:10 — Gameplay Begins — Early Turns: First turns: ramp, land drops, early commanders (Aesi, Sedgemoor, Yellow, Carmela). Banter about shuffling, coffee, Hugo (Scorsese), and protein shakes.

•

55:00 — Mid-Game Escalation & First Auction: Avenger of Zendikar enters, Windfall copied, board states develop. First auction: Hobbit booster + signed binder sells for $131.

•

85:00 — Combat Chaos & Second Auction: Flying vehicles attack, Omenkeel exiles cards, Elise swings with 7 plants for 30 damage. Second auction: Gold-foil Mollymauk playmat sells for $555.

•

130:00 — Board Wipes & Illegal Play: Organic Extinction wipes non-artifacts, Zach's knights survive via indestructibility. Elise illegally returns Avenger from exile via Eternal Witness (Path to Exile had exiled it).

•

175:00 — Finale & Winner Declared: Elise plays Multani, Yavimaya's Avatar (17/17 trample), gives it Swiftfoot Boots, attacks for lethal. Hosts declare Elise champion despite rules errors.

•

205:00 — Post-Game Analysis & Final Auctions: Hosts dissect missed triggers, illegal plays, and what-ifs. Final auctions: Zach's Sedgemoor deck ($420), Elise's AC deck ($470). Total raised: $6,000.

Speakers

•

Irene the Alien — Co-host / Commentator

•

Bosco — Co-host / Commentator

•

Alex Ward — Player / Finalist

•

Zach Ronaldo — Player / Finalist

•

Olivia Gobear Hicks — Player / Finalist

•

Elise Work — Player / Finalist / Winner

⋮