TLDR
The Critical Role MTG Commander Showdown finale features four players (Alex Ward, Zach Ronaldo, Olivia Gobear Hicks, Elise Work) competing in a chaotic, humor-filled Commander game hosted by Irene the Alien and Bosco. Interspersed with live eBay auctions benefiting the Critical Role Foundation, the game includes deck-swap twists, missed triggers, and an illegal play that goes unnoticed. Elise Work ultimately wins after a 17/17 Multani tramples over the board, with the three-night event raising $6,000 for charity. The hosts provide running commentary mixing game analysis, pop-culture tangents, and absurdist banter. The real winner is the Critical Role Foundation, which has raised over $4 million since 2020.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The winning play (Avenger of Zendikar returned via Eternal Witness) was illegal — Avenger had been exiled by Path to Exile, not in the graveyard, but no one caught it.
Zach's Knight Exemplar gave all knights indestructibility, which survived Olivia's Organic Extinction board wipe, but he forgot to equip his Sword of Vengeance earlier, missing a free 2/2 knight token.
Alex hard-cast Mulldrifter for 6 mana instead of evoking it for 3, drawing praise from the hosts for the 'respect the hell out of a hard cast Mulldrifter.'
Olivia's Omenkeel milled a board wipe (Echoing Truth) from Elise's library that would have bounced all her plant tokens — effectively protecting Elise's board by accident.
The hosts reveal they've raised over $4 million for the Critical Role Foundation since 2020, with this three-night event adding $6,000.
Bosco shares he had top surgery (double mastectomy with nipple grafts), describing the 'keyhole' scars under his nipples as 'pierholes' and calling gender-affirming care 'for everyone.'
The final auction includes a 'shuffle simulator 3000' joke about Elise's deck (AC landfall) which involved constant shuffling, selling for $470.
Key takeaways
Elise Work wins the tournament with a landfall deck featuring Avenger of Zendikar and Multani, Yavimaya's Avatar, despite an illegal play where she returned Avenger from exile instead of the graveyard.
The event raises $6,000 across three nights for the Critical Role Foundation, supporting charities like 826LA, Outright International, Shanti Bhavan, First Nations Development Institute, and NCWIT.
Zach Ronaldo pilots a Sedgemoor Witch/Jabari deck with Knight synergies but misses key triggers (forgetting to equip Sword of Vengeance, missing Lightning Rager creation).
Olivia Gobear Hicks plays a vehicle deck centered on Omenkeel, which exiles a critical Echoing Truth that would have wiped Elise's plant tokens.
Alex Ward switches to a Grixis artifacts deck (Yellow the Painter) but hard-casts Mulldrifter instead of evoking it, and later vandalblasts his own board out of spite.
Live auctions feature signed playmats, booster packs, and player-used decks, with a gold-foil Mollymauk Tealeaf playmat selling for $555 and Olivia's Squirrel deck for $540.
The hosts (Irene and Bosco) provide comedic commentary ranging from Magic rules debates to personal anecdotes about soup, pillows, and bisexual visibility.
Multiple rules errors occur: missed triggers, incorrect retrace explanation, phased-out creatures incorrectly handled, and the game-winning Avenger of Zendikar returned from exile illegally.
Notable quotes
“Since 2020, thanks to this incredible community, the Critical Role Foundation has raised over $4 million to help people around the world.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:53“We're not all just dreaming of change. We're doing our best to leave the world better than we found it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:53“Life's a resource and I never have a lot of it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 26:15“The power of cheating.”
▸ Notable quotes · 206:19“Every single dollar of that matters. Thank you guys so much for watching. Thank you for bidding and thank you for hanging out with two fabulous idiots.”
▸ Notable quotes · 215:38“You have shown us what's possible when a community comes together.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:48Chapters
1:53 — Charity Introduction & Foundation Overview: The Critical Role Foundation's work since 2020 is highlighted: $4M+ raised, seven partner charities named (826LA, Red Nose Day, Outright International, Shanti Bhavan, First Nations Development Institute, Pablo Foundation, NCWIT).
21:10 — Hosts & Player Introductions: Irene the Alien and Bosco introduce the Spell Slayers show, the four finalists (Alex, Zach, Olivia, Elise), and the eBay Live sponsorship with live auctions benefiting CRF.
23:50 — Deck Selection & Swap Phase: Finalists choose to keep or swap decks in health order. Elise keeps Aesi, Olivia swaps to Esper artifacts, Zach keeps Jabari, Alex switches to Yellow the Painter (Grixis).
34:10 — Gameplay Begins — Early Turns: First turns: ramp, land drops, early commanders (Aesi, Sedgemoor, Yellow, Carmela). Banter about shuffling, coffee, Hugo (Scorsese), and protein shakes.
55:00 — Mid-Game Escalation & First Auction: Avenger of Zendikar enters, Windfall copied, board states develop. First auction: Hobbit booster + signed binder sells for $131.
85:00 — Combat Chaos & Second Auction: Flying vehicles attack, Omenkeel exiles cards, Elise swings with 7 plants for 30 damage. Second auction: Gold-foil Mollymauk playmat sells for $555.
130:00 — Board Wipes & Illegal Play: Organic Extinction wipes non-artifacts, Zach's knights survive via indestructibility. Elise illegally returns Avenger from exile via Eternal Witness (Path to Exile had exiled it).
175:00 — Finale & Winner Declared: Elise plays Multani, Yavimaya's Avatar (17/17 trample), gives it Swiftfoot Boots, attacks for lethal. Hosts declare Elise champion despite rules errors.
205:00 — Post-Game Analysis & Final Auctions: Hosts dissect missed triggers, illegal plays, and what-ifs. Final auctions: Zach's Sedgemoor deck ($420), Elise's AC deck ($470). Total raised: $6,000.
Speakers
Irene the Alien — Co-host / Commentator
Bosco — Co-host / Commentator
Alex Ward — Player / Finalist
Zach Ronaldo — Player / Finalist
Olivia Gobear Hicks — Player / Finalist
Elise Work — Player / Finalist / Winner