TLDR
Two 12-year-old girls in Waukesha, Wisconsin, stabbed their friend Payton Leutner 19 times in 2014 to become 'proxies' of the fictional internet character Slender Man. Morgan Geyser, who had undiagnosed schizophrenia, and Anissa Weier, who had a learning disability and came from a divorced family, planned the murder for months. Payton survived by crawling out of the woods and was rescued by a passing cyclist. Both girls were tried as adults, found guilty but not guilty by reason of mental disease, and sentenced to 25 and 40 years in mental institutions. Morgan later escaped a group home in 2025 but was recaptured. Payton recovered, graduated high school, and developed a remarkably forgiving perspective on her attackers.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The girls' primary motivation wasn't just delusion but also a desire for internet notoriety — they wanted to prove Slender Man was real to skeptics on creepypasta forums and gain fame in the online community.
Anissa Weier, not Morgan, was the one who physically restrained Payton and urged Morgan to 'go ballistic' during the attack, despite later claiming she was squeamish and non-violent during interrogation.
Morgan's father posted a Slender Man drawing by his daughter on Instagram a month before the murder, yet both parents claimed they had no idea she believed the character was real.
Payton's first words upon waking from surgery were not about her own pain but asking if her attackers had been caught — showing her immediate concern was for others' safety, not herself.
The judge who initially approved Morgan's transfer to a group home stated 'I don't see the risk to the public' — one month later, Morgan escaped and fled across state lines.
When police confronted Morgan after her 2025 escape, she refused to identify herself and said 'Just Google me' — treating her infamy as a calling card rather than a source of shame.
Key takeaways
Morgan Geyser showed signs of schizophrenia from toddlerhood — seeing ghosts, feeling heartbeats of imaginary figures, and experiencing visual hallucinations — but her father (who had the same condition) and school counselors dismissed or ignored the red flags, allowing her condition to worsen unchecked.
Anissa Weier, a lonely girl with a learning disability whose parents were divorcing, latched onto Morgan as her only friend and adopted Morgan's delusions as a form of escapism, eventually believing she too had seen Slender Man despite having no hallucinations of her own.
The girls' plan to kill Payton was not impulsive but meticulously plotted over months: they used code words ('crackers' for knife, 'itch' for killing), created proxy personas ('Kitty' and 'Scorpio'), packed survival bags for a 200-mile trek to a national forest, and attempted multiple methods before succeeding in the woods.
Payton Leutner survived 19 stab wounds — including one that missed a major artery by less than a millimeter — and crawled out of the woods with punctured diaphragm, liver, and stomach, demonstrating extraordinary physical resilience and will to live at age 12.
Both girls were tried as adults despite being 12 at the time of the crime; the judge ruled that juvenile court offered no long-term oversight for Morgan's schizophrenia, and Anissa received 25 years at Winnebago Mental Health Institute while Morgan received the maximum 40 years.
Morgan's mental state deteriorated further in jail — she talked to Slender Man, Voldemort, Snape, and Ninja Turtles, claimed she could use Vulcan mind control to avoid prison, and resisted medication because it would make her 'lifelong friends' disappear, mirroring her father's refusal of treatment.
Payton Leutner developed a strikingly forgiving perspective: she thanked Morgan for giving her a life plan and medical career inspiration, urged parents to monitor children's online content, and advised other kids to leave toxic friendships 'before something bad happens to you, even if you're guilted into it.'
Morgan was released to a group home in 2025 but cut her ankle monitor and fled 170 miles with a 43-year-old man she met there within four weeks, leading to her return to maximum-security psychiatric care — validating public fears about her release.
Notable quotes
“I was forced to stab my best friend to death.”
▸ Notable quotes · 78:09“Don't be afraid. I'm only a little kitty cat.”
▸ Notable quotes · 63:29“I felt no remorse. I actually felt nothing.”
▸ Notable quotes · 87:50“Beforehand, I believe, but now I know that it's just teenagers who really like scaring people and making them believe false things.”
▸ Notable quotes · 90:14“Just Google me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 125:52“I would say just because of what she did, I had the life I have now and I really really like it and I have a plan.”
▸ Notable quotes · 128:16Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Case Overview: Hosts introduce the Slender Man stabbing case on its 12-year anniversary, framing it as a real-life horror story connected to creepypasta culture they've previously covered.
5:30 — Morgan's Childhood & Schizophrenia: Details Morgan Geyser's early hallucinations — ghosts, imaginary friend Sev with a heartbeat, visual distortions — and her father's untreated schizophrenia, which he passed on genetically and behaviorally by dismissing her symptoms.
21:40 — Anissa's Background & Friendship Formation: Anissa Weier's learning disability, parental divorce, and social isolation made her vulnerable; she clung to Morgan as her only friend and adopted Morgan's delusions to maintain the connection.
23:00 — Creepypasta Discovery & Slender Man Obsession: The girls found creepypasta.com and fixated on Slender Man, consuming lore about proxies and the Slender Mansion, blurring fiction and reality as Morgan's hallucinations incorporated the character.
38:20 — Escalation: Diaries, Dolls & Delusions: Morgan's diary revealed disturbing drawings and blood writing; she mutilated dolls with occult symbols. Anissa validated Morgan's visions by calling her a 'medium,' reinforcing the delusion that Slender Man was real.
53:20 — Murder Planning & Failed Attempts: Months of planning included code words, proxy personas, survival bags, and multiple aborted attempts (neck stabbing at 2 AM, bathroom stall drowning) before settling on the woods hide-and-seek ruse.
63:00 — The Attack & Payton's Survival: Morgan stabbed Payton 19 times while Anissa restrained her; Payton crawled out of the woods with punctured organs, was found by a cyclist, and survived emergency surgery where a blade missed her aortic artery by a hair's breadth.
72:00 — Arrest, Trials, Aftermath & Morgan's Escape: Girls caught walking on I-94; interrogations revealed Morgan's flat affect and Anissa's delayed realization Slender Man wasn't real. Both sentenced as adults to mental institutions. Morgan escaped a group home in 2025 but was recaptured. Payton recovered, forgave her attackers, and advocates for leaving toxic friendships.
Speakers
Hunter — Co-host
Isaiah — Co-host