UK Woman Traveled to Florida to Be Tortured to Death: Sheriff

Original Media · 30m · English · YouTube · Law&Crime Network

TLDR

This episode details the investigation and upcoming trial of Dwayne Hall, a Florida man charged with kidnapping and murdering Sonia Exelby, a UK woman who traveled to the US in October 2025 intending to be tortured and killed. Hall met Exelby on a fetish website, picked her up from the airport, and took her to an Airbnb where forensic evidence places them together. While Hall claims he refused to harm her and she left with someone else, detectives found a disturbing video on his phone showing Exelby beaten and terrified, a message from her phone describing being trapped with a gun, and her buried body in a wooded area where Hall parked after buying a shovel.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A woman explicitly planned and funded international travel to be murdered, yet the man she met claims he resisted her request and she left alive — but forensic and digital evidence contradicts his account.

•

Hall's screen name 'alpha satist' and the extreme bondage images on his phone were deemed admissible to prove his motive was sexual gratification, not mercy, reframing a 'consensual' suicide arrangement as a sadistic homicide.

•

Exelby's final message from her own phone was sent while she was allegedly locked in a room with no signal, yet it was transmitted — suggesting she had brief access or the message was sent earlier and delayed.

Key takeaways

•

Sonia Exelby, a UK woman with severe mental health struggles, deliberately traveled to Florida in October 2025 to meet a man from a fetish site who would torture and kill her, arranging an Airbnb and communicating her suicidal intent in a letter to herself on the plane.

•

Dwayne Hall, a self-proclaimed sadist who used the screen name 'alpha satist' on Motherless, picked Exelby up from the airport and took her to the Airbnb, where phone data and neighbor witnesses place them together for an extended period.

•

Hall initially claimed he only drove Exelby to the Airbnb and she left with a 'Middle Eastern man,' but later admitted to 'vanilla' sex and acknowledged being the last person to see her alive, while insisting he wanted no part in her death wish.

•

A message sent from Exelby's phone on October 11 describes being locked in a remote location with no signal, her captor having a gun and telling her the only way out was to shoot him, and being forced to record disclaimer videos and write a letter to her family.

•

Detectives found a video on Hall's phone where Exelby appears beaten and tearful; Hall asks how she wants to die, she says 'to be stabbed,' he notes 'you've beaten me,' and when asked if she's being forced, she only shakes her head no.

•

Hall purchased a shovel at Walmart and parked in a wooded area for an hour on the morning of October 12, 2025; Exelby's body was later found buried there, leading to kidnapping and murder charges.

•

The judge ruled prosecutors can use 17 extreme bondage images from Hall's phone at trial to demonstrate his motive was fulfilling his own sexual sadism rather than assisting Exelby's suicide request.

•

Exelby's family, devastated by her death, raised funds for nine members to travel from the UK for the trial; her sister described her as a compassionate musician who wanted to help others struggling with mental health.

Notable quotes

“I'm hard bondage. I like hard bondage.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:07

“Usually something something Satist probably alpha alpha satist or something like that probably more likely.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:14

“I know that she is not alive anymore. I know that. You know that. And I want to find her.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:44

“He made it clear there was no way out unless I shoot him. I was questioning it last night. I can't kill anyone.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:08

“She goes on to speak about other reasons she believes she is an awful person and is visibly upset with tears in her eyes. As she is talking about this, Hall asks her how she would want to die and to describe it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:35

“Hall asks Exelby about her face. She responds, 'You've beaten me.' He asks her if that is what she asked for. She does not immediately respond, but then says, 'I guess literally speaking.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:59

Chapters

•

0:00 — Case Introduction: Host Yanette Levy introduces the case of Sonia Exelby, a UK woman who traveled to Florida in October 2025 intending to be tortured and killed, and Dwayne Hall, the self-proclaimed sadist charged with her murder.

•

0:36 — Sonia's Background and Disappearance: Exelby struggled with mental health; her boyfriend Stevie Hunt reported her missing from the UK, believing she flew to Tallahassee to meet someone from a fetish site for a planned death.

•

2:24 — Investigation Leads to Dwayne Hall: Bank records show a $1,200 charge to Exelby's card at Hall's roadside assistance business; deputies contact Hall, execute a vehicle search warrant, and bring him in for questioning.

•

4:18 — Hall's Interview and Airport Story: Hall claims a client named Harold paid him $1,200 to pick up a woman at Gainesville airport and drop her with a Middle Eastern man; he identifies Exelby's photo but denies harming her.

•

10:18 — Confronting Hall with Forensic Evidence: Detectives reveal phone data places Hall and Exelby at the Airbnb simultaneously, the house is being forensically processed, and they know Exelby documented her intent to die.

•

16:32 — Online Communications and Screen Names: Hall admits communicating with Exelby on Motherless (screen name 'already yours') and Sessions (she used 'Sonia Blake'); he is evasive about his own screen name.

•

19:40 — Hall's Reluctance and Exelby's Suicidal Intent: Hall says Exelby discussed past failed suicide attempts and called death a 'beautiful state'; he claims he refused to participate due to his wife's recent health crisis and his own reluctance.

•

24:58 — Damning Evidence: Phone Message and Video: A message from Exelby's phone describes captivity, a gun, forced videos, and terror; a video on Hall's phone shows her beaten, tearful, saying 'You've beaten me,' and shaking her head when asked if she's forced.

Speakers

•

Yanette Levy — Host/Narrator

•

Dwayne Hall — Suspect/Defendant

•

Detectives (Calvin and others) — Investigators

•

Stevie Hunt — Victim's Boyfriend

⋮