The Wildest True Crime Updates: Casey Anthony, Menendez Brothers & MORE

Original Media · 53m · English · YouTube · Bailey Sarian

TLDR

Bailey Sarian provides updates on three true crime cases while doing a coffin girl-inspired makeup look. Rocky Myers had his Alabama death sentence commuted to life without parole by Governor Kay Ivey in February 2025, becoming only the second person removed from the state's death row since 1976, though the governor stated she wasn't convinced of his innocence. Casey Anthony launched TikTok and Substack in 2025 branding herself as a "legal advocate," sparking massive backlash after her 2022 docuseries contradicted her original defense. The Menendez brothers were denied parole in August 2025, and a leaked audio recording from Erik's hearing sabotaged Lyle's hearing the next day; their habeas petition based on new abuse evidence was denied in September 2025. Their only remaining paths to release are future parole hearings or a gubernatorial pardon.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Governor Kay Ivey commuted Rocky Myers' sentence while explicitly stating she 'still believes in capital punishment' and is 'not convinced that Rocky is innocent' — she commuted him because she couldn't in good conscience execute him given the case's flaws, yet left him with no parole eligibility.

•

Casey Anthony's parents Cindy and George Anthony are still married despite George being accused of molesting Casey and possibly Caylee during the trial, and George attempting suicide; George passed a lie detector test and 100% believes Casey killed Caylee, while Cindy remains 'unsure.'

•

The Department of Corrections 'mistakenly' handed over audio recordings from Erik Menendez's parole hearing to the press the day before Lyle's hearing — a violation of standard practice that Bailey and Lyle's attorneys believe was intentional sabotage.

•

Roy Rosselló, a former Menudo band member, came forward in 2023 alleging José Menendez abused him as a teenager while managing the band, providing independent corroboration of the brothers' abuse claims decades later.

•

Erik Menendez wrote a letter to his cousin in 1988 detailing his fear of his father and the abuse he was experiencing — a year before the murders — which was only discovered decades later by a family member.

Key takeaways

•

Rocky Myers' death sentence was commuted to life without parole in February 2025 after 30 years on death row, making him only the second person removed from Alabama's death row since 1976, though Governor Kay Ivey stated she wasn't convinced of his innocence but cited too many unanswered questions to allow execution.

•

The Rocky Myers case revealed systemic failures: an all-white jury with one juror using racial slurs, a judge who overrode the jury's life recommendation to impose death penalty during his re-election campaign on a 'tough on crime' platform, and lawyers who abandoned Myers without informing him of lost appeals.

•

Casey Anthony rebranded as a 'legal advocate' on TikTok and Substack in 2025, claiming her platform was 'thrust upon her' and now views it as a 'blessing,' but faced immediate backlash with commenters comparing taking legal advice from her to 'asking Hannibal Lecter how to make vegan meals.'

•

Casey Anthony's 2022 docuseries 'Where the Truth Lies' contradicted her original defense by claiming Caylee couldn't have drowned in the above-ground pool without a ladder, prompting a juror from her trial to state the entire defense was a lie.

•

The Menendez brothers were denied parole in August 2025: Erik was denied due to past burglaries, prison rule violations including a cell phone, and lack of empathy; Lyle was denied the next day for similar violations, antisocial traits, deception, and minimizing his actions.

•

A Department of Corrections 'mistake' leaked audio from Erik's parole hearing to the press before Lyle's hearing, causing family witnesses to back out and creating a media circus that Lyle's attorneys argued was intentional sabotage.

•

The Menendez brothers' habeas petition based on new evidence (Erik's 1988 letter to his cousin and Roy Rosselló's 2023 abuse allegations against José Menendez) was denied in September 2025; the judge acknowledged the evidence somewhat supported abuse claims but didn't change the premeditated nature of the murders.

•

The Menendez brothers' only remaining paths to release are future parole hearings in approximately 3 years (potentially moved up to 1 year with good behavior) or a gubernatorial pardon from California's governor, which Bailey considers unlikely given current priorities.

Notable quotes

“She's like, he's guilty, but like I'm not fully convinced that he's guilty. She said it was actually one of the hardest decisions of her career and that she had to respect the decision of the jury by sticking to the recommendation of life without parole.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:26

“Taking legal advice from you would be like asking Hannibal Lecter how to make vegan meals.”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:23

“I feel that it's important that I use this platform that was thrust upon me and now look at it as a a blessing as opposed to the curse that it's been since 2008.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:04

“The entire defense was that Kaye drowned in the pool, but now she's saying that she didn't drown in the pool. So the entire defense was a lie.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:44

“This was no abuse excuse. Like this was real.”

▸ Notable quotes · 44:53

“It kind of feels like it was done on purpose. Okay, let's be real.”

▸ Notable quotes · 47:16

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro and Sponsor: Bailey introduces the Monday murder mystery and makeup episode, promotes Midas Merge game sponsor with Halloween Haunted Gardens event, and explains the update episode format prompted by viewer requests.

•

5:37 — Rocky Myers Case Recap: Bailey recaps the 1991 Alabama case: Ludy May attacked by a man asking to use her phone, VCR stolen, Rocky Myers arrested based on witness Marzelle's testimony, unrecorded interrogation, no physical evidence linking Rocky to the scene, victims knew Rocky and said it wasn't him, all-white jury with racial bias, judge overrode life recommendation for death penalty during re-election campaign.

•

13:42 — Rocky Myers Update: Governor Kay Ivey commuted Rocky's death sentence to life without parole on February 28, 2025, citing too many unanswered questions. She stated she's not convinced of his innocence but couldn't allow execution. Rocky, now 63, is the second person removed from Alabama's death row since 1976. Bailey expresses frustration that he remains imprisoned despite likely innocence.

•

17:52 — Casey Anthony Case Recap: Bailey recaps the 2008 case: 2-year-old Caylee missing, Casey's odd behavior, fake nanny Zanny, car smelled of decomposition, remains found near grandparents' home, trial with Jose Baez's chaos strategy, abuse allegations against father George, chloroform theories, not guilty of murder but guilty of lesser charges, released with time served.

•

25:07 — Casey Anthony Update: Casey launched TikTok and Substack in 2025 as a 'legal advocate,' claiming her platform is now a 'blessing.' Her 2022 docuseries contradicted her drowning defense. She doubled down on abuse allegations adding brother Lee. She claims to work as a research assistant for a PI firm. Massive backlash in comments, she threatened commenters with IP tracking. Parents still married but estranged from Casey.

•

39:03 — Menendez Brothers Case Recap: Bailey recaps the 1989 Beverly Hills murders: Kitty and Jose Menendez shot by sons Erik and Lyle. Initial mob theory, Erik confessed to therapist, therapist's mistress went to police. First trial televised with abuse testimony, deadlocked juries. Second trial excluded abuse evidence, brothers convicted of first-degree murder, life without parole. Brothers improved themselves in prison.

•

43:57 — Menendez Brothers Update: New evidence emerged: Erik's 1988 letter to cousin detailing abuse, Roy Rosselló's 2023 allegations against Jose. Habeas petition filed. Judge resentenced to 50 years to life allowing parole eligibility. August 2025 parole hearings: Erik denied, then audio leaked to press before Lyle's hearing. Lyle denied next day. Habeas petition denied September 2025. Only paths: future parole hearings or gubernatorial pardon.

Speakers

•

Bailey Sarian — Host

⋮