Vote Save America x Sister District State Power Series: The Insurrection will be Decentralized

Original Media · 1h 02m · English · YouTube · Pod Save America

TLDR

This panel discussion from the State Power Series examines how Republicans are weaponizing state legislatures to subvert elections through voter suppression, installing election deniers in key positions, and the independent state legislature theory (Moore v. Harper). Panelists emphasize that 2022 is a critical last chance to flip state legislative chambers before the 2024 election, highlighting Pennsylvania as a key battleground where gerrymandering and constitutional amendments threaten democracy. They call for progressives to embrace state power as a tool for democracy, not just react to Republican attacks.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Pennsylvania's constitutional amendment process allows the legislature alone to amend the constitution — the governor has no veto power, enabling GOP to enshrine voter ID and election audits despite court rulings.

•

The 'independent state legislature theory' originated from a concurring opinion by Rehnquist in Bush v. Gore that was never adopted by a majority — yet now has 4+ Supreme Court votes.

•

In 2021, while red states passed suppression laws, blue states passed *more* voter expansion laws (mail voting, drop boxes, felon re-enfranchisement) — but this 'good news' is largely ignored.

•

Arizona's auditor general Tim DeFoor refuses to say Biden's 2020 win was fair while accepting his own statewide win on the same ballot — and Republicans want him to audit future elections.

Key takeaways

•

Republicans are pursuing a three-pronged election subversion strategy: voter suppression laws, electing election deniers to certification roles, and the independent state legislature theory via Moore v. Harper.

•

Pennsylvania exemplifies the threat: 30 years of GOP legislative control, a gubernatorial candidate (Mastriano) who would appoint a partisan secretary of state, and a constitutional amendment process that bypasses the governor.

•

The independent state legislature theory, once fringe, now has at least four Supreme Court justices sympathetic — it would give state legislatures unchecked power over federal elections, including the ability to ignore state constitutions and courts.

•

Progressives have historically underinvested in state power due to an ideological aversion to federalism, while conservatives have built a decades-long infrastructure around it.

•

2022 is the last chance to change state legislative composition before the post-2024 election period; flipping just 12 seats in Pennsylvania would give Democrats control.

•

Pro-democracy states are expanding access: 15+ states enacted vote-by-mail expansions, drop boxes, and felon re-enfranchisement in 2021 — but these successes get less attention than suppression efforts.

•

Accountability for January 6th architects (lawyers, legislators) remains lacking, enabling continued spread of anti-democratic theories.

•

Running for local and state office is a concrete action: many qualified people self-disqualify while unqualified extremists run unopposed.

Notable quotes

“The independent state legislature doctrine... literally confers upon state legislatures uncheckable power to do whatever they want in election administration.”

▸ Notable quotes · 51:46

“They're not trying to throw out everybody's votes... they're trying to throw out votes of very specific folks — votes from people from communities like mine in North Philly.”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:40

“We have a unique constitutional amendment process... the legislature alone is involved in that. The governor cannot veto it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 76:48

“The true story of the 2020 election is that the country did a lot of really great things... to make the 2020 election possible and secure given that there was a pandemic. And these reforms... were all really popular and they worked well.”

▸ Notable quotes · 91:58

“When you go to karaoke... people with no business singing are the first to run up to the book... that is elected office. There are a lot of people who have no business being near the mechanics of governmental power or authority who run every single time.”

▸ Notable quotes · 97:02

Chapters

•

0:15 — Introduction and Series Framing: Gabby Goldstein and Shaniqua McClendon introduce the State Power Series, Sister District, and Vote Save America, framing the urgency of state legislative power in the 2022 midterms and post-2024 period.

•

5:07 — Panelist Introductions: Shaniqua introduces the three panelists: Brian Beutler (Crooked Media), Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta (PA State Rep), and Dahlia Lithwick (Slate/Amicus).

•

15:38 — Three Categories of Election Subversion: Brian Beutler outlines the GOP's three-pronged strategy: voter suppression laws, electing election deniers to certification roles, and the independent state legislature theory (Moore v. Harper).

•

25:38 — Pennsylvania Case Study: Rep. Kenyatta details PA's 30-year GOP legislative control, the 'election integrity committee' sham, artisanal voter suppression, constitutional amendments bypassing the governor, and the Mastriano threat.

•

42:07 — Independent State Legislature Theory & Moore v. Harper: Dahlia Lithwick explains the theory's fringe origins, the North Carolina case, the four+ justice interest, and the existential implications for state court review and election certification.

•

53:24 — How We Got Here: Historical Analysis: Brian traces the path from Bush v. Gore through 2010/2014 midterms, RBG's retirement timing, Trump's acceleration, and the need for structural reforms (court reform, filibuster, statehood).

•

65:04 — Progressive Federalism & Imagination Gap: Gabby and Dahlia discuss the ideological gap: progressives lack a positive vision of state power, while conservatives have weaponized federalism. Call for imagination and proactive state-level democracy building.

•

68:31 — Certification Crises & Local Power: Kenyatta highlights county-level certification refusals, the 'karaoke metaphor' for unqualified candidates running, and the need for competent, diverse people to run for office.

•

82:01 — Structural Solutions & Positive Models: Dahlia calls for Supreme Court accountability, state supreme court/secretary of state focus, and imagination. Brian and Dahlia cite pro-democracy state laws (mail voting, drop boxes, felon re-enfranchisement) as models.

•

99:10 — Call to Action: Moderators announce national phone bank partnership for competitive state legislative races, direct viewers to sign up via Vote Save America and Sister District.

Speakers

•

Gabby Goldstein — Co-moderator, Co-founder of Sister District

•

Shaniqua McClendon — Co-moderator, VP of Politics at Crooked Media

•

Brian Beutler — Panelist, Editor-in-Chief at Crooked Media

•

Malcolm Kenyatta — Panelist, Pennsylvania State Representative (181st District)

•

Dahlia Lithwick — Panelist, Senior Editor at Slate

⋮