Influencer Hunts For Twin Lookalike On Instagram & Brutally Kills Her - But She Won't Say Why

Original Media · 1h 05m · English · YouTube · Rotten Mango

TLDR

This episode covers the 'doppelganger murder' case in Germany, where Sherry (Sher Ben K) allegedly recruited a lookalike woman named Cada through fake Instagram offers, then conspired with an acquaintance Shakir to brutally murder her and place her body in Sherry's car to fake Sherry's own death and escape her controlling Yazidi family. Both Sherry and Shakir were convicted, though the exact motive remains debated between a doppelganger scheme, black magic ritual, or jealousy. Sherry received a life sentence with 25-year parole eligibility; Shakir got 15 years. The case captivated Germany with its bizarre twists, including a fake hitman charged with fraud, an illiterate religious leader's 'magical' papers, and Sherry's chilling courtroom demeanor.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The fake hitman Vulcan was charged with fraud and tax evasion for taking €5,000 but not committing the murder — German law treated the unfulfilled murder-for-hire as fraud.

•

The 'black magic' papers were written by an illiterate Yazidi religious leader who claimed the text came to him in a dream; judges rejected the human sacrifice theory.

•

Sherry's parents threatened Rowan that leaving Sherry would 'cost three human lives' — a chilling detail that foreshadowed the violence.

•

Sherry went back to hanging out at gas stations with her 'groupie' friends after the murder, casually telling them 'I'm in some trouble, people are after me' when they asked why she wasn't dead.

•

Shakir told a friend at a gas station, 'I killed an innocent girl for this whore,' yet continued hanging out publicly instead of fleeing.

•

The defense's 'too dumb to plan it' argument centered on Sherry's IQ of 86 — just above Germany's threshold for learning disability (85).

Key takeaways

•

Sherry messaged 26 women with similar features on Instagram, luring them with fake job offers (music video, laser treatment) to find a lookalike to kill and use as a body double.

•

Cada agreed to a 'free laser treatment' at Rowan's barbershop; Sherry and Shakir picked her up, drove her to a forest, and murdered her with brass knuckles and 56 stab wounds.

•

After the murder, Sherry did not flee — she drove around town leisurely, returned to her 'gas station groupie' hangouts, and was arrested days later.

•

Sherry had a documented history of violence: tasing her brother-in-law, attempting to run Rowan over, assaulting him with a soap bar, and trying to hire a hitman (Vulcan) to kill Rowan's brother.

•

The 'black magic' theory emerged from folded foil-wrapped papers with undecipherable writing and a photo of Sherry and Rowan; they turned out to be religious talismans from an illiterate Yazidi leader (a 'shake').

•

Sherry's IQ was assessed at 86; her defense argued she was 'too dumb' to plan such a crime, but prosecutors countered that the plan's incompetence proved she wasn't smart enough to realize it would fail.

•

Shakir's motive remains unclear — prosecutors suggested sex, money, or manipulation; he gave a cellmate a list of 13 witnesses with plus/minus signs, interpreted as a hit list.

•

A rapper named Furcon testified he dated Cada and rejected Sherry's sexual advances, raising a jealousy motive; he disposed of his phone before police interviewed him.

Notable quotes

“Are you dead?”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:08

“She's alive.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:51

“I feel an absolute emptiness and utter chaos inside.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:00

“If you abandon my daughter, it will cost three human lives.”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:23

“No mercy. No mercy. Make sure you shove the pills deep in his throat.”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:28

“I want to eat him alive. I want to devour him whole.”

▸ Notable quotes · 55:38

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro & Hook: Opens with a humorous UFO analogy about aliens avoiding expensive cities, then transitions to Matteo discovering a 'dead' woman at a pizza shop who claims she doesn't know if she's dead — setting up the doppelganger theme.

•

3:33 — Discovery of the Body & Rowan's Interrogation: Sherry's parents find a woman's body in Sherry's Mercedes on a residential street; police interrogate ex-husband Rowan for 4.5 hours as the prime suspect, during which he describes their volatile 7-year marriage.

•

10:51 — The Twist: Sherry Is Alive: During a break, an officer informs Rowan: 'She's alive.' Sherry has been spotted on CCTV. The body in the car is identified as Cada, a 23-year-old who responded to Sherry's fake Instagram offer.

•

15:02 — Backstory: Sherry, Rowan & the Yazidi Community: Details Sherry and Rowan's meet-cute, strict Yazidi families, caste marriage rules, Sherry's pregnancy with another man's child, Rowan's decision to leave, and her parents' death threat. Covers Sherry's escalating violence and gas station lifestyle.

•

22:30 — The Murder Plot & Cada's Death: Sherry messages 26 lookalikes; Cada agrees to a 'laser treatment' at Rowan's shop. Sherry and Shakir pick her up, murder her in a forest with brass knuckles and a knife, place her body in Sherry's car, and park it where her parents would find it.

•

30:30 — Trial, Theories & Witnesses: Covers the 100+ witness trial. Prosecutors push the doppelganger theory; defense argues Sherry's low IQ (86) makes planning impossible. 'Black magic' theory emerges from talismans but is rejected. Vulcan testifies about the hitman plot. Furcon introduces jealousy motive.

•

54:30 — Verdict & Aftermath: Both defendants convicted. Sherry gets life with 25-year parole eligibility; Shakir gets 15 years. Cada's father is devastated by the leniency. The case goes viral globally as the 'doppelganger murder,' though the true motive remains ambiguous.

Speakers

•

Host 1 (Narrator) — Main host

•

Host 2 (Co-host) — Co-host

⋮