TLDR
In a 'Buy or Sell' segment, analysts debate four NFL topics: whether the Browns are the AFC North's best team (consensus no, Ravens with healthy Lamar Jackson are), if Giants rookie JJ McCarthy should start over James Winston now (split: Winston leads locker room but McCarthy is the future), whether Cam Skattebo's zero-carry game was punishment for a fumble (analysts say it's production, not discipline), and if Caleb Williams is the best 2024 rookie QB (unanimous yes, citing arm talent and Ben Johnson's scheme).
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The 'punishment' narrative for Skattebo's benching is likely a cover for performance issues; analysts argue NFL teams don't bench productive players for fumbles, citing James Cook and D'Andre Swift as examples.
Charlie Batch, a Steelers legend, 'buys' the Browns as AFC North's best team based on head-to-head results, going against the conventional wisdom that the Ravens are superior.
Despite Caleb Williams' early-season struggles, the panel unanimously ranks him above Jayden Daniels and Drake Maye purely on talent and scheme fit, contradicting the rookie-year accolades Daniels and Maye earned.
Key takeaways
The Ravens with a healthy Lamar Jackson are considered the clear best team in the AFC North despite the Browns' division wins, because Baltimore's ceiling is higher and their loss to Cleveland came on a missed field goal by a backup quarterback.
The Giants' quarterback debate centers on timing: James Winston currently commands the locker room and should start now, but JJ McCarthy is the inevitable future and may need to play soon given the NFC East's competitiveness.
Cam Skattebo's benching is framed by analysts as a production issue, not discipline — he doesn't maximize the offense the way other backs do, and the 'punishment' narrative is dismissed as childish.
Caleb Williams' performance against Atlanta (30/35, 300+ yards) solidified his status as the most talented 2024 rookie quarterback, with Ben Johnson's scheme and Antwaan Randle El's receiver development unlocking his play-extending, downfield ability.
The 2024 rookie QB class is historically strong: Jayden Daniels won Offensive Rookie of the Year, Drake Maye was MVP runner-up, but Williams' arm talent and scheme fit give him the highest ceiling.
Notable quotes
“Man, sell on discount. Aren't the Ravens in the AFC North as well? The Browns, I love the story, Todd trying to bring the team back and all. They're in the lower tier points per game, they're in the lower tier points given up per game. Like they're not they can't hang their hat on offense or defense. So I would say the Ravens, let's be honest, Lamar Jackson plays yesterday, the Ravens win that game. So I can't say the Browns are top team.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:32“I'm buying at this particular point. The reason being they beat two of the three AFC North teams right now. The only team they have not played is the Bengals. So right now I believe in Todd Todd Monken.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:55“Man, I'm buying. Now, you know, CB, this is a short season. You lose another two, three games, you're out of it at that point. We know that NFC East is close right now. Man, put J.J. in there. The offense isn't that in-depth. You got to throw to Likely, get the ball to Neighbors every now and again. Don't give it to Saquon Barkley no more. He He's fine. Don't don't give him the ball. But, no, I think J.J. should start, and that's the future. We know Winston's not the future.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:11“I think J.J. McCarthy will be the starter. I'm selling that he should be the starter right now. If you If you watch the game, they're already using him in certain packages, whether it's zone read packages, getting him on the move, trying to be a little bit creative. And he was able to get into the game and give them a spark late. But, James Winston right now is the leader of that locker room. He's galvanized many of those players. Now, he can't turn the football over and play you out of games. I do feel like eventually you want to know who J.J. McCarthy is to pair with Jackson Dart. But, at this point, I think James Winston should remain the starter.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:26“Sell, sell, sell. Punishment sounds like my six-year-old that wants a Popsicle, and it's too late at night. You already brushed your teeth. He's not that great. I'm sorry for the Instagram people that love Cam Skattebo backflips. James Cook fumbled twice. And then when he got one Fiji yesterday, you're not being punished cuz you fumbled. You're being punished because you don't maximize the Giants offense running that ball. That's what it is, man. Stop being childish. I know he's young. Tighten up. He's selling on punishment. I don't know what that means.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:34“Ooh, I think I'mma buy that. I think I'mma buy that even if they put the price up. Caleb is special. Arm talent for sure. Uh but he has Ben Johnson now. We saw the jump go when he has Ben Johnson. And you got to bring up Drake May with Josh McDaniels. They have people around them. I can't forget about my man Jayden. LSU boy. Can't forget about Jayden. He hasn't been maximized, I believe. The injuries with his elbows, you know, I think slowing him down. But when you just talk about ability, I think Jayden's up there with a Drake May and Caleb all together.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:07Chapters
0:16 — Cleveland Browns vs AFC North: The panel debates whether the Browns are the AFC North's best team; Chain and the host sell, citing the Ravens' superiority with a healthy Lamar Jackson and a missed field goal as the only reason Cleveland won, while Charlie buys based on head-to-head division wins and offensive coordinator Todd Monken's impact.
1:46 — Giants QB: JJ McCarthy vs James Winston: Analysts split on whether rookie JJ McCarthy should start immediately over James Winston; Chain argues McCarthy needs more preparation time, CB insists the short season demands playing the future now, and Charlie sells an immediate switch but acknowledges McCarthy's inevitable takeover, noting Winston's locker-room leadership.
3:07 — Cam Skattebo's benching and 'punishment': After Skattebo receives zero carries following a game-ending fumble, CB dismisses the 'punishment' narrative as childish, arguing it's a production issue — Skattebo doesn't maximize the offense like other backs — while Charlie suspects an undisclosed behavioral component and the host notes other fumble-prone backs weren't benched.
4:51 — Caleb Williams as top 2024 rookie QB: All three analysts buy Caleb Williams as the best quarterback in the 2024 class after his 30-for-35, 300-yard performance against Atlanta; they credit Ben Johnson's scheme, Antwaan Randle El's receiver coaching, and Williams' play-extending arm talent, while acknowledging Jayden Daniels' and Drake Maye's accolades but viewing Williams' ceiling as highest.
Speakers
Host — Host
Chain — Analyst
Charlie — Analyst
CB — Analyst