TLDR
Attorney Peter Traos analyzes post-verdict developments in the Matthew Farwell case, including Farwell's routine post-conviction motions for judgment of acquittal and new trial, the Birchmore family's push for broader accountability beyond Farwell, and an interview with Stoughton Police Chief McNamara — on paid administrative leave — who details her internal affairs investigation that uncovered three officers' inappropriate relationships with Birchmore, her frustration with the Norfolk County DA's refusal to prosecute, and how her department's findings triggered the FBI investigation that ultimately secured Farwell's conviction.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Norfolk County DA's office claimed it would be 'prosecutorial misconduct' to charge Farwell with statutory rape because the victim was dead, despite routine prosecution of homicide cases without living victims.
Chief McNamara learned of Birchmore's death when her department was sent to the wrong address for a well-being check, and only learned the correct location hours later through station gossip.
The two other officers implicated in the internal affairs investigation resigned in August 2022, months after Farwell's April 2022 resignation, but only after McNamara's public press conference and referral to the POST commission for decertification.
McNamara states she lobbied the DA's office in summer 2021 to create case law to prosecute Farwell for statutory rape using the text message evidence, and the DA refused.
The officer who took the 2019 call from Birchmore's friend reporting the inappropriate relationship did not escalate it to McNamara; that officer remains on the job according to the interview.
Key takeaways
Farwell's renewed motion for judgment of acquittal and motion for new trial are standard post-conviction procedural steps that nearly all defense attorneys file to preserve appellate rights, not indicators of a strong legal challenge or likely reversal.
The Birchmore family and their supporters are demanding accountability beyond Farwell's conviction, targeting the Norfolk County DA's office, the medical examiner's initial suicide ruling, and other officers who may have known about or participated in the misconduct.
Chief McNamara launched an internal affairs investigation after Sergeant Fanning reported Farwell's admission of a sexual relationship with Birchmore and his status as the last person to see her alive; the investigation uncovered two additional officers involved with Birchmore.
The Norfolk County DA's office declined to pursue criminal charges — including statutory rape — despite text evidence, telling McNamara it would be 'prosecutorial misconduct' to charge without a living victim, a rationale the host calls legally baseless.
McNamara's internal affairs findings and public press conference in 2022 directly triggered FBI involvement, which led to the federal prosecution and conviction; she believes the department has since implemented significant reforms including hiring 15 new officers and adding supervisory checks.
McNamara acknowledges she did not know about the officers' misconduct while it was occurring, citing the inherent limitations of supervising plainclothes detectives with autonomy, but emphasizes that when the information reached her, she acted decisively.
The host argues systemic issues in Norfolk County law enforcement — including the Karen Read case — demonstrate a pattern of protecting officers rather than pursuing accountability, and that continued state-level investigations are necessary regardless of the federal case's conclusion.
Notable quotes
“It's the absolute normal thing every defense lawyer does. Uh it doesn't mean there's a big problem in this case. Doesn't mean it's likely to get overturned.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:39“Justice requires persistence, not deference, not convenience, and certainly not the protection of those who wear the badge and misuse their authority.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:32“I was in absolute disgust that someone in uniform with that authority would take advantage of. She was she was a a a vulnerable person in my eyes.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:17“They told us it would be prosecutorial misconduct if we charge him. We didn't have a victim is what was told to us.”
▸ Notable quotes · 26:13“Just because a defendant kills somebody to remove them from the situation doesn't mean all crimes go away that they may have committed against that person.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:03“To cover this up and say Stoughton PD doesn't do things like this, we don't have bad cops like that. We do the right thing. Make it disappear. Make it go away would have been easier for her and would have looked better for her.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:58Chapters
2:03 — Farwell's post-conviction motions: Farwell's team filed a consented motion for extended time and pages to file a renewed motion for judgment of acquittal and motion for new trial; the host explains this is routine procedural practice, not a sign of case weakness, and predicts both will be denied by Judge Casper.
9:13 — Birchmore family demands broader accountability: News segment and family statements reveal the Birchmore family views Farwell's conviction as incomplete justice, calling for accountability for the Norfolk County DA's office, the medical examiner, and other officers who enabled the cover-up.
16:47 — Chief McNamara interview — internal affairs investigation: McNamara details learning of Birchmore's death, launching an internal affairs investigation after Sergeant Fanning reported Farwell's admission, and discovering three officers had inappropriate relationships with Birchmore through the Explorer program.
24:50 — Norfolk County DA's refusal to prosecute: McNamara describes the DA's office declining criminal charges despite text evidence, claiming it would be prosecutorial misconduct without a living victim; she lobbied for statutory rape charges to no avail.
28:50 — FBI involvement triggered by internal affairs findings: McNamara's public release of internal affairs findings in 2022 prompted FBI contact; she believes her department's transparency triggered the federal investigation that led to Farwell's conviction.
39:00 — McNamara's administrative leave and department reforms: McNamara addresses her paid administrative leave, asserts the department has implemented reforms including hiring 15 new officers and adding supervisory checks, and welcomes the incoming DA's investigation into the Explorer program.
50:00 — Systemic issues and need for continued investigation: The host argues that Norfolk County law enforcement has a systemic pattern of protecting officers, cites the Karen Read case as parallel, and urges continued state-level investigations regardless of the federal case outcome.
Speakers
Peter Traos — Host/Attorney
Chief McNamara — Stoughton Police Chief
Interviewer — Journalist
News anchors/reporters — Media
Birchmore family members — Victim's family