TLDR
Ethan Klein and co-hosts analyze the ongoing "Colergate" controversy where streamer Hasan Piker is accused of repeatedly shocking his dog Kaia with an e-collar on stream. They dissect defenses from Hasan's orbiters — including Taylor Loren, Denims, Cutie Cinderella, and Vanilla Mace — who claim the collar is vibration-only, the tape is photoshopped, and critics are conspiracy theorists. Hasan's own friend Cutie Cinderella confirms the prongs were removed and taped over, while Ethan demonstrates the collar still delivers shock through the metal screws. Hasan shifts explanations daily, and his defenders knowingly lie to protect him, revealing a coordinated disinformation effort.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Hasan's best friend and co-host Cutie Cinderella inadvertently confirmed the collar had been modified (prongs removed, taped over) — the very detail defenders called a conspiracy theory.
The e-collar still delivers shock through the metal contact screws even with prongs removed, meaning Hasan's "vibration only" claim is technically false regardless of prong status.
Taylor Loren explicitly told her audience "don't believe your eyes" regarding video evidence, then cited her own firing from the Washington Post for lying as a credential for "real journalism."
Hasan admitted on stream to tying Kaia to his bed for "hours and hours on end" during streams, framing it as equivalent to crating a dog while at work.
Key takeaways
Taylor Loren, presenting herself as a journalist, tells viewers not to believe video evidence of Hasan shocking his dog and to trust "real journalism" instead, comparing the clear footage to conspiracy theories about body doubles.
Hasan's close friend Cutie Cinderella visited his house, examined the collar, and confirmed on stream that the prongs were removed and the back was covered in black tape — directly contradicting Taylor Loren's claim that the tape was photoshopped.
Ethan bought the exact same e-collar model and demonstrates that removing the prongs does not disable the shock function; the metal screws that hold the prongs still conduct electricity to the dog's neck.
Hasan has changed his story multiple times: first claiming it was a vibration-only collar, then that Kaia wasn't wearing a collar at all, then that the tape covers his phone number, and finally that e-collars are legal and standard training tools.
Denims and other defenders pivot to sexualized thirst-posting about Hasan and attack critics' credibility rather than address the evidence, with Denims suggesting critics need to meet the dog to judge abuse.
Vanilla Mace argues people shouldn't care about dog abuse when worse things happen in the world, echoing Hasan's frequent "but Palestine" deflection tactic to dismiss criticism.
Hasan's own past streams show him laughing while Kaia yelps in fear, tying her to a bed for hours, and putting her in a confined space with another dog that snaps at her, saying "it's so funny when she's scared."
The defenders' coordinated lying — despite clear video evidence — demonstrates how Hasan's community prioritizes loyalty over truth, with Ethan noting these are the same people who have attacked him for two years.
Notable quotes
“Video evidence is very convincing. Yes. That's why everybody's mad.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:38“Don't believe your eyes. Believe actual journalism because the the arguments that”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:00“There seems to be something on the back of the collar that we photoshopped in to look like a piece of tape.”
▸ Notable quotes · 34:39“He literally said on camera, I tie her to the bed for hours and hours on end.”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:57“It's so funny when she's scared. Why would you say that? It's so funny when she's scared.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:59“This drama would have stopped on day one if Assan would have been like this is a shot caller but I use it as a vibration collar because I have this taped over and the prongs are off.”
▸ Notable quotes · 58:16Chapters
0:54 — Taylor Loren's defense: Ethan plays clips of Taylor Loren's TikTok live where she claims the shock collar allegations are a politically motivated conspiracy, tells viewers not to believe video evidence, and compares believing the footage to believing Trump body double theories.
22:54 — Cutie Cinderella confirms tape: Hasan's close friend Cutie Cinderella states on stream she visited his house, saw the collar, and confirms the prongs were removed and the back taped over — contradicting defenders who called the tape photoshopped.
20:59 — E-collar demonstration: Ethan shows the exact same e-collar model, demonstrating that removing prongs doesn't disable shock because the metal screws still conduct electricity; the prongs are only removable for size adjustment.
27:27 — Denims' sexualized deflection: Denims responds to abuse allegations by thirst-posting about Hasan, suggesting critics need hand/foot/crotch cams, and arguing people shouldn't judge without meeting the dog personally.
41:57 — Vanilla Mace's whataboutism: Vanilla Mace defends Hasan by claiming critics are MAGA, lying about the collar, and shouldn't care about dog abuse when worse things exist — mirroring Hasan's "but Palestine" deflection tactic.
52:04 — Hasan's shifting explanations: Hasan cycles through contradictory claims: vibration-only collar, dog wasn't wearing collar, tape covers phone number, e-collars are legal and good training tools, and critics are conspiracy theorists.
47:46 — Additional abusive behavior: New clips show Hasan laughing while Kaia yelps in fear, tying her to bed for hours, and confining her with another dog that snaps at her, saying "it's the funniest thing" when she runs away terrified.
58:28 — Conclusion and pattern: Ethan summarizes that the controversy persists because Hasan and his orbiters lie instead of admitting the obvious; the same defender network has attacked critics for years across multiple controversies.
Speakers
Ethan Klein — Host
Dan — Co-host/Producer
Ian — Co-host/Producer
AB — Producer
Taylor Loren — Defender/Commentator
Cutie Cinderella — Hasan's friend/co-host
Denims — Defender/Fan account
Vanilla Mace — Defender/TikToker
Hasan Piker — Subject of controversy
Ninja (Tyler Blevins) — Friend of show