TLDR
The episode explains why multi-stage rockets leave spent stages as space junk, focusing on the Saturn V's third stage that follows Apollo spacecraft to the Moon. Apollo missions deliberately crashed these stages into the Moon for seismic science, a practice continuing today with modern rockets like SpaceX's. With a permanent lunar presence looming, engineers must solve the accumulating debris problem — either by targeted disposal on the far side or orbital refueling to eliminate stages entirely. The Moon's lack of atmosphere means impacts occur at 5,300+ mph, and spent stages have even been mistaken for asteroids.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Apollo missions deliberately crashed rocket stages into the Moon for science, not by accident.
A spent rocket stage and a Tesla Roadster have both been independently discovered and cataloged as asteroids by astronomers.
The Moon's escape velocity (5,300 mph) is the minimum impact speed for any object falling onto its surface — there is no 'gentle' landing without active braking.
Key takeaways
Multi-stage rockets discard empty fuel tanks to shed dead weight; each spent stage retains the same velocity as the spacecraft, so it follows the same trajectory unless actively diverted.
The Saturn V's third stage (S-IVB) performed the translunar injection burn, giving the spacecraft enough speed to coast to the Moon — but the stage itself also had that speed, so it trailed along unless crashed intentionally.
Apollo missions 13 through 17 deliberately steered their third stages into the Moon to generate seismic waves measured by surface detectors, revealing the Moon's internal structure.
A SpaceX Falcon 9 upper stage impacted the Moon in 2022, sparking criticism, yet Apollo did the same half a dozen times on purpose for science.
Rick Binzel once spectroscopically identified Apollo 12's third stage as a 'highly reflective asteroid with titanium oxides' before realizing it was a rocket body; Elon Musk's Tesla Roadster has similarly been cataloged as an asteroid multiple times.
Without an atmosphere, the Moon receives impacts at its escape velocity (5,300 mph) or higher — explaining its cratered surface versus Earth's protected one.
Future lunar traffic will create swarms of derelict stages; proposed solutions include a designated 'dumpster crater' on the far side with targeted deorbit burns, or orbital propellant depots that make stages reusable and eliminate the problem.
The fundamental orbital dynamic: whatever imparts your velocity shares that velocity, so it stays with you unless you add more energy to leave it behind.
Notable quotes
“The reason why modern rockets don't look like that is because it's very costly to go anywhere in space. And I don't just mean money, I just mean efficiency.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:51“So, what do you do? You detach the fully used fuel tank and drop it off wherever it lands. That way, the remaining thrust is sending into space only that which is absolutely necessary.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:20“Together. So, if you don't want the second stage following after you, you got to like shove it or give it a rocket to slow it down to have it reenter the”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:58“there's a point where the gravity that wants you to fall to Earth exactly equals the gravity that wants you to fall to the moon.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:40“If the stage crashes into the moon and we have little moonquake detectors, we might be able to get seismic information about the moon.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:26“Excuse me. This is happening all the time, and Apollo did it a half a dozen times like on purpose.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:16Chapters
0:11 — V2 Rocket Origins: The V2, designed by Wernher von Braun for Nazi Germany, was the first object built to leave Earth's atmosphere and became the template for 1950s sci-fi rockets.
0:51 — Multi-Stage Rocket Principle: Discarding empty fuel tanks is essential for efficiency; each spent stage is dead weight that compromises range, so multi-stage designs shed mass incrementally.
1:43 — Saturn V Three Stages: The 35-story Saturn V used three stages: first stage to lift off and gain speed, second to reach 17,500 mph orbital velocity, third for translunar injection toward the Moon.
4:38 — Third Stage Fate & Lunar Gravity: The third stage shares the spacecraft's translunar velocity and follows it to the Moon; at the Earth-Moon gravity balance point, the Moon's pull takes over and the stage either orbits, wanders, or impacts.
6:19 — Apollo Seismic Experiments: Apollo 13–17 deliberately crashed their third stages into the Moon to generate seismic waves measured by surface detectors, revealing internal layering and core structure.
8:05 — SpaceX Controversy & Space Junk Problem: A SpaceX upper stage hit the Moon in 2022, drawing criticism, yet Apollo did the same routinely; every lunar mission leaves a derelict stage that becomes uncontrolled debris.
9:02 — Future Solutions: Refueling & Dumpster Craters: Orbital propellant depots could eliminate stages entirely; alternatively, a designated far-side crater with targeted deorbit burns could serve as a disposal zone for spent stages.
10:33 — Asteroid Misidentifications & Moon Impacts: Apollo 12's third stage and Musk's Tesla Roadster were both mistaken for asteroids; the Moon's lack of atmosphere means all impacts occur at ≥5,300 mph, explaining its cratered surface.
Speakers
Speaker 1 — Host/Narrator