They Filmed Her, She Begged to Be Let Out & Then They Dumped Her on the Road | Madison Brooks

Original Media · 44m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

This episode reopens the case of LSU student Madison Brooks, who died in January 2023 after leaving a bar with four men. Two men allegedly had sex with her in a car while she was severely intoxicated (BAC over .28), then she was dropped on a dark road and struck by a rideshare vehicle. The case has sparked a media firestorm over whether she could consent, with DNA evidence inconclusive, a judge accused of bias, and one defendant's history of prior sexual assault allegations emerging.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The grand jury indicted Kason Carver for first-degree rape and video voyeurism even though prosecutors agreed he never had sex with Madison, because Louisiana law treats an aider as equally guilty.

•

The fourth man, Everett Lee, was never indicted — the grand jury "pre-terminated" his charges, leaving the door open for future prosecution but effectively clearing him for now.

•

A cell phone video played at a bond hearing captured one of the men saying "They're going to rape her" before Madison even got in the car, suggesting premeditation.

•

Judge Ray has a documented history of leniency toward sex offenders, including vacating a convicted man's conviction sua sponte and releasing a man accused of assaulting a preteen without notifying the victim or prosecutors.

•

The defense argued Madison's BAC of .319 was inaccurate because she could walk and talk on video, but experts note that at that level motor skills shut down and death is a risk.

Key takeaways

•

Madison Brooks, 19, left Reggie's bar with four strangers on January 14, 2023; two men, Desmond Carter (then 17) and Kavion Washington (18), had sex with her in the backseat while driver Kason Carver and passenger Everett Lee remained in front.

•

Kason Carver told police he heard Desmond ask Madison five times if she wanted sex and she verbally agreed, but when asked if she was too intoxicated to consent, he responded "I guess."

•

Madison's blood alcohol level was between .282 and .319 — over three times the legal limit — a level experts associate with alcohol poisoning, loss of consciousness, and inability to consent.

•

The autopsy found a bruise on Madison's backside the pathologist called "highly suspicious for assault," but no vaginal trauma and no DNA from any of the four men inside her; only Kavion's DNA was found on the outside of her pelvic area.

•

Kavion Washington had a prior arrest at age 15 for first-degree rape of a 12-year-old girl, and a second woman came forward alleging a nearly identical assault by Kavion and another man at Reggie's in October 2022.

•

Judge Gail Ray allowed the defense to introduce Madison's sexual history from the day before her death, violating Louisiana's rape shield law; the appeals court and Louisiana Supreme Court unanimously overturned her ruling.

•

Kason Carver waived his right to a jury trial, opting for a bench trial before Judge Ray; text messages later revealed he bragged to his father that "judge is on our side, she will rule in our favor" and claimed a friendly relationship with her.

•

Judge Ray was removed from the case but then reinstated by the Louisiana Supreme Court in May 2026; as of the episode's recording, no trial has occurred for any defendant, three and a half years after Madison's death.

Notable quotes

“Make it make sense. Where is the concern? Where does the concern really lie here?”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:08

“They're going to rape her.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:15

“judge is on our side, she will rule in our favor”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:22

“I was blown away by that comment. I mean, these men, these clients gave sworn statements that they had sex with this young girl who was overly intoxicated.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:16

“For me, no matter what her blood alcohol level actually was, I think it's pretty clear that Maddie was far too intoxicated to consent to anything that night.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:37

Chapters

•

0:35 — Introduction and Case Overview: Annie Elise introduces the reopened case of Madison Brooks, an LSU student whose death after a night at Reggie's bar sparked a media firestorm over whether she was assaulted or died in a tragic accident.

•

5:10 — Madison's Background and the Night at Reggie's: Details Madison's life as a high-achieving student and the events of January 14, 2023, when she arrived at Reggie's bar and met four men who later left with her.

•

9:01 — The Car Ride and Alleged Assaults: Describes the car seating arrangement, the alleged sexual acts in the backseat while Madison was severely intoxicated, and Kason Carver's admission that she may have been too impaired to consent.

•

11:24 — Death, Autopsy, and Initial Charges: Covers Madison being dropped off and struck by a rideshare vehicle, her BAC results, autopsy findings of injuries suspicious for assault, and the initial arrests and charges against the four men.

•

16:11 — Reggie's Bar History and Kavion Washington's Past: Details Reggie's bar's history of underage drinking and violence, and reveals Kavion Washington's prior arrest for raping a 12-year-old girl and a diss track mocking a rival player's death.

•

22:43 — Leaked Evidence, DNA Results, and a Second Victim: Covers leaked lab reports showing no DNA inside Madison, the defense's challenge to her BAC, and a second woman's nearly identical assault allegation against Kavion from October 2022.

•

27:24 — Grand Jury Indictments and Civil Lawsuit: Explains the grand jury's indictments — including charging Kason as a principal — the civil lawsuit filed by Madison's father, and the disturbing video evidence shown at Desmond's bond hearing.

•

30:58 — Judge Ray Controversy and Trial Delays: Details Judge Gail Ray's controversial rulings, Kason's text messages about their relationship, her removal and reinstatement, and the ongoing delays preventing any trial from occurring.

Speakers

•

Annie Elise — Host

⋮