STAR WARS: A New Hope (1977) Reaction– Why Don’t Movies Look Like This Anymore?! FIRST TIME WATCHING

Original Media · 1h 30m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

Jackie and Paige watch Star Wars: A New Hope for the first time as part of their reaction series, providing real-time commentary throughout the 1977 film. They are consistently impressed by the practical effects, world-building, and Princess Leia's agency, while expressing surprise that Darth Vader answers to Grand Moff Tarkin and that the "I am your father" reveal occurs in a later film. Their post-viewing discussion covers the film's enduring influence, character dynamics, and viewer questions about age-appropriateness and behind-the-scenes trivia. They conclude eager to continue the franchise.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts assumed Darth Vader was the emperor/king of the Empire, not a powerful enforcer who answers to a bureaucratic council and Grand Moff Tarkin.

•

They expected the "I am your father" twist to happen in this film and were genuinely confused when it didn't, revealing how pop culture condenses the trilogy's narrative arc.

•

Despite modern fears of AI, the film's robots are entirely non-threatening servants — a 1970s optimism about technology that feels alien to contemporary viewers.

•

The cantina band continues playing nonchalantly after a patron loses an arm in a blaster fight, a tonal dissonance the hosts found darkly comedic and unexpected for a 'family movie.'

•

Princess Leia kisses Luke twice on the cheek — a moment the hosts read as romantic tension, unaware the characters are siblings, creating dramatic irony only possible for first-time viewers.

Key takeaways

•

The practical effects — miniatures, puppetry, and creature design — hold up remarkably well after nearly 50 years, making the world feel tactile and immersive in a way modern CGI-heavy films often do not.

•

Princess Leia drives the plot far more than the hosts expected: she devises the escape via the garbage chute, commands the rescue operation, and remains composed after her home planet's destruction, subverting the damsel-in-distress trope they anticipated.

•

Darth Vader is not the supreme authority but a subordinate to Grand Moff Tarkin and the Emperor, a hierarchy the hosts found surprising given his cultural status as the franchise's primary villain.

•

The droids are portrayed as docile, compliant tools — C-3PO as a protocol interpreter, R2-D2 as an astromech — reflecting a 1970s vision of robotics as helpful appliances rather than the autonomous, potentially threatening AI common in modern sci-fi.

•

Han Solo's charismatic, self-interested rogue steals every scene he's in, while Luke Skywalker feels underdeveloped in this first film, functioning mainly as an archetypal farm boy answering the call to adventure.

•

The hosts did not realize the iconic "I am your father" revelation occurs in The Empire Strikes Back, not A New Hope, highlighting how cultural osmosis compresses the saga's major beats into a single mental image.

•

The film's violence — severed arms, burning skeletons, the trash compactor monster — caught them off guard for a movie they considered family-friendly, though they noted the absence of gore makes it more suitable for children than modern equivalents.

•

The opening crawl's exposition dump initially overwhelmed them, but the film's pacing never lagged; they remained fully engaged throughout, crediting the immersive world-building — costumes, sound design, alien languages — for sustaining investment.

Notable quotes

“All my exes have tried to get me to watch it and I said that's the one thing I'm saving for marriage.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:32

“It's all miniatures, right? Is it? That's really freaking cool.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:28

“Help me, Obi-Wan Kenobi. You're my only hope.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:01

“The ability to destroy a planet is insignificant next to the power of the force.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:54

“Get in the garbage shoot, fly boy.”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:33

“Use the force, Luke. Let go.”

▸ Notable quotes · 58:18

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & First Impressions: Jackie and Paige introduce their virgin watch of Star Wars: A New Hope, share their limited prior knowledge (mostly from That '70s Show and Disneyland), and react to the opening crawl with nervous excitement.

•

1:58 — Opening Sequence & Droids: They react to the Star Destroyer chase, the Tantive IV boarding, and meet C-3PO and R2-D2 on Tatooine, noting the practical effects, the droids' bickering dynamic, and their surprise that the robots are compliant tools rather than autonomous agents.

•

10:50 — Luke & Obi-Wan: Luke Skywalker is introduced as a whiny farm boy; the hosts meet Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ben), learn of the Clone Wars, the Jedi, and the Force, and watch Luke receive his father's lightsaber and the full Leia hologram message.

•

22:50 — Aunt & Uncle's Death / Commitment: Luke returns to find his aunt and uncle murdered by stormtroopers, prompting him to join Obi-Wan; the hosts note the brutality of the skeleton reveal and Luke's sudden lack of ties to Tatooine.

•

24:00 — Mos Eisley Cantina & Han Solo: They arrive at Mos Eisley, witness the cantina's creature diversity and violence (arm severing), meet Han Solo and Chewbacca, negotiate passage on the Millennium Falcon, and see Han shoot Greedo first.

•

34:00 — Death Star Capture & Rescue: The Falcon is tractor-beamed into the Death Star; the group hides in smuggling compartments, Obi-Wan disables the tractor beam, and Luke, Han, and Chewie rescue Leia from detention — including the garbage compactor sequence — while Obi-Wan duels Vader and vanishes.

•

52:00 — Trench Run & Victory: The Rebel briefing reveals the Death Star's thermal exhaust port weakness; the X-wing assault begins, Vader joins the fight, Han returns to save Luke, and Luke uses the Force to destroy the station without his targeting computer.

•

60:00 — Post-Movie Discussion & Q&A: The hosts debrief: praise Leia's agency, practical effects, world-building, and Han's charisma; discuss Luke's thin characterization; answer viewer questions on age-appropriateness, Harrison Ford's casting, the Han/Greedo debate, and the Empire's political legitimacy; express eagerness for the next films.

Speakers

•

Jackie — Co-host

•

Paige — Co-host

⋮