TLDR
Democrat Scott Colombe won a historic upset in Mississippi, becoming the first Black man elected by voters to the U.S. Senate from that state since Reconstruction. His victory in a state Trump won by 22 points, along with Democratic gains nationwide, has energized the party as they gather in Denver to chart their future, though strategists debate whether the wins reflect Democratic strength or an anti-Trump referendum.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A Democrat won a Senate race in Mississippi, a state Trump carried by over 22 points in 2024, making it one of the most stunning upsets in recent memory — surpassing even Doug Jones's 2017 Alabama victory.
Cindy Hyde-Smith, one of the few Senate Republicans who voted against certifying the 2020 election after January 6, lost re-election in a deep-red state, suggesting that vote became a liability even in Republican strongholds.
Democrats' post-midterm mood is described as genuinely happy and relieved for the first time in the Trump era — not just strategically optimistic — because they finally won a cycle without simultaneous losses elsewhere.
Key takeaways
Scott Colombe, a 43-year-old local prosecutor, defeated incumbent Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith by energizing Black voters, capitalizing on economic discontent, and highlighting Hyde-Smith's vote against certifying the 2020 election results and her block of his federal judgeship nomination.
Colombe's campaign centered on a message of faith — he persisted despite early town halls with fewer than 10 attendees and donors who refused to take his calls, a narrative that became the emotional core of his victory speech.
The "pick another protein" ad, which urged voters to choose a different senator the way they'd pick a different meat at the grocery store, resonated widely and became one of the strongest Senate campaign ads in recent cycles.
Democrats are debating whether their midterm sweep — winning the House, a comfortable Senate majority, and over a dozen legislative chambers — reflects genuine brand rehabilitation or merely a referendum on Republican governance, with some warning that favorable conditions may mask deeper structural weaknesses.
The Alaska Senate race remains undecided as Democrat Mary Peltola leads incumbent Dan Sullivan by under 4,000 votes; ranked-choice voting may determine the outcome, and the Trump administration is appealing a dismissed lawsuit seeking to block results over voter confusion from a similarly named candidate.
At the "What's Next" conference in Denver, potential 2028 presidential contenders including Pete Buttigieg, Cory Booker, and Josh Shapiro are appearing alongside newly elected officials, signaling a large primary field and a party mood described as the most hopeful since the Trump era began.
Hunter Woodall notes this is the first time Democrats have felt genuine relief in the Trump era — unlike 2018 when they won the House but lost Senate ground, this cycle delivered wins across the board, creating an opening for an optimism-based message that was absent in 2020.
Strategists emphasize Democrats must invest in states like Florida and Texas beyond presidential battlegrounds to build lasting infrastructure, as the political environment will not always be as favorable as the 2026 midterms.
Notable quotes
“And I'll tell you, throughout this campaign, there were many times where I had to have faith. There were times that I couldn't get donors to answer the phone. They did not believe a moment like this was possible. But I kept the faith.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:51“I want to have a final word to every Mississippian, the ones that voted for me, the ones that didn't vote for me, and the ones that didn't vote. My commitment to you, each and every one of you, is that first, I'm going to treat your children like I want my children to be treated.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:32“This is probably one of the most stunning upsets for a Democrat that I can ever remember. I mean, this this supersedes Doug Jones. I did not surprise winning that Alabama Senate race back in 2017.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:55“This is really these victories last week. This was really the first time Democrats, I think, have been able to breathe a sigh of relief in the Donald Trump era in a major way.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:46“Was this an election that Democrats really won by their own candidates or was this an election where voters delivered a referendum on Donald Trump? And there's probably some truth to it being a little bit of both of those things.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:03“They also still have those longer term issues about investing in states around the country, not just the presidential battlegrounds, to have longer term success.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:28Chapters
0:00 — Colombe's Historic Mississippi Win: Scott Colombe becomes the first Black man elected by voters to the U.S. Senate from Mississippi since Reconstruction, defeating incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in a state Trump won by 22 points.
0:47 — Victory Speech: Faith and Inclusion: Colombe's speech emphasizes perseverance through donor skepticism and sparse early crowds, pledging to represent all Mississippians regardless of their vote.
2:04 — Analysis: How a Red State Flipped Blue: Hunter Woodall explains Colombe's win as a combination of a strong candidate, Hyde-Smith's vulnerabilities (Jan 6 vote, blocking his judgeship), a resonant 'pick another protein' ad, and a favorable national environment.
4:48 — Lessons for Democratic Investment: Discussion of whether Democrats should invest in traditionally red states like Florida and Texas, with DNC Chair Ken Martin's 'no perpetual red state' philosophy validated by the results.
6:07 — Alaska Senate Race Undecided: Mary Peltola leads Dan Sullivan by under 4,000 votes; ranked-choice voting may decide the outcome, and the Trump administration is appealing a lawsuit over ballot confusion from a similarly named candidate.
7:15 — Democrats Convene in Denver: The 'What's Next' conference brings potential 2028 contenders and new officeholders to Denver, which is bidding for the 2028 convention as a purple-state-turned-blue showcase.
8:28 — Democratic Mood and the Hope Message: Woodall describes unprecedented Democratic relief and happiness after the midterms — the first cycle in the Trump era without offsetting losses — creating an opening for an optimism-based 2028 message.
10:18 — Tension: Win vs. Referendum: Strategists debate whether the sweep reflects Democratic brand strength or an anti-Trump referendum, warning that structural weaknesses remain and require investment beyond battleground states.
Speakers
Ali — Host
Hunter Woodall — Political Reporter
Scott Colombe — Senator-elect
Rachel — Host