TLDR
In the final episode of 'The Scream Murder,' Tori Adamcik publicly admits for the first time that he stabbed Cassie Jo Stoddard, detailing the 2006 murder he committed with Brian Draper at age 16. Both men, now 35 and serving life without parole, reflect on their crime, their teenage motivations — including Tori's struggle with his sexuality and Brian's obsession with violence — and the infamous planning tape they made. Experts debate juvenile sentencing, while Cassie's mother Anna Stoddard's impact statement underscores the irreversible loss.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Tori Adamcik's sexuality and the role his internalized shame played in his psychological state at 16 was never publicly discussed before this interview.
Both killers claim they were 'playing characters' on the planning tape, performing exaggerated versions of themselves, yet still carried out the murder in reality.
Lawrence Steinberg notes the killers' startle response — or lack thereof — as a potential marker of psychopathy, a trait rarely discussed in juvenile cases.
Tori explicitly states he would prefer execution ('go full force') over life without parole if no path to redemption exists.
The killers are housed in the same prison but kept separate; when they occasionally see each other, they no longer recognize a bond.
Key takeaways
Tori Adamcik admits on record for the first time that he personally stabbed Cassie Jo Stoddard, ending 20 years of denial.
Both killers describe the murder as a crime of opportunity — Cassie was targeted simply because she was alone house-sitting, not due to personal animus.
Tori reveals his teenage crisis stemmed largely from the shame and isolation of being gay in a conservative, heterosexual environment.
The killers' homemade planning tape shows callousness and a desire for infamy, which experts say reflects a mutual reinforcement dynamic rather than a single leader.
Brian Draper now separates his 16-year-old self from his current identity, arguing he is being punished for a person who no longer exists.
The Supreme Court's 2012 Miller v. Alabama ruling against mandatory juvenile life without parole is not retroactive in Idaho, leaving Brian and Tori with no parole eligibility.
Tori describes prison as a series of confined spaces where every day is a reminder of his crime, and suggests execution would be preferable to life without redemption.
Brian's father Carrie Draper accepts blame for failing to prevent the crime and says he would trade his freedom for his son's.
Cassie's mother Anna Stoddard (d. 2022) emphasizes that while the killers' parents can visit them in prison, she can only visit her daughter's grave.
Notable quotes
“the only shameful thing that I've really done with my life is stab Cassie”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:41“I admitted to everything I'd done except stabbing Cassie because that was the one thing I couldn't admit to”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:51“I followed Brian up the stairs and I could feel my heart start to race... I stabbed her twice”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:59“the one thought was, I guess this is what we came to do, and I forced myself to do it”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:07“the older I get, like the younger she gets... she was just a little kid... that pain doesn't go away”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:53“if Cassie wouldn't have been babysitting that night, it definitely wouldn't have happened... she just was the unlucky one to be alone when me and Brian knew she was alone”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:30“these anxieties were compounded by the shame and loneliness of being gay and lost in a heterosexual world”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:21“The most striking thing in their conversations is the callousness and the lack of emotionality... their desire to be famous for this”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:52“I feel like there's two people... the kid I was that brought me here... and who I am now. I feel like I'm serving a punishment that belongs to him, not me”
▸ Notable quotes · 26:45“If you believe my life is worth redeeming, give me a pathway to redeem myself. If you don't think my life is worth redeeming, then just go the other route and go full force with it”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:39“If anybody could have prevented it, it would have been me. And I didn't. I'm to blame as much as he is”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:12“You may have killed my daughter, but you will never take away from me and my family the memories and the time that we had together with Cassie. She will live in our hearts forever”
▸ Notable quotes · 43:04Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Tori's First Public Admission: Host Connor McCarthy introduces the finale. Tori Adamcik, for the first time publicly, admits he stabbed Cassie Jo Stoddard, ending two decades of denial.
4:12 — Tori's Detailed Account of the Murder Night: Tori describes the sequence of events: following Brian upstairs, the moment the plan became real, his refusal to enter Cassie's room initially, and ultimately stabbing her twice after Brian attacked her.
6:39 — Brian's Remorse and Perspective on Cassie: Brian Draper speaks about Cassie as a 'little kid' whose death causes enduring pain. He expresses remorse, though Connor notes it's unclear if it's for the victim or himself.
9:33 — Why Cassie? Tori's Explanation of Opportunity: Tori explains Cassie was targeted purely by circumstance — she was alone house-sitting. He and Brian had discussed killing someone a week prior; Cassie was the unlucky opportunity.
13:06 — Tori's Background: Sexuality, Shame, and Isolation: Tori reveals his teenage crisis was fueled by being gay in a heterosexual world with no openly gay role models. His mother Shannon confirms she learned of his sexuality only after his incarceration.
18:18 — The Murder Tape Analysis and Expert Commentary: Both killers claim they were 'playing characters' on their planning tape. Professor Lawrence Steinberg analyzes the tape, noting callousness, desire for infamy, and a mutually reinforcing dynamic.
26:33 — Juvenile Life Without Parole Debate: Discussion of Miller v. Alabama (2012) and the national split on retroactivity. Idaho has not applied it retroactively, leaving Brian and Tori with no parole review. Experts argue juveniles lack adult moral responsibility due to brain development.
33:03 — Prison Life and Current Perspectives: Tori describes prison as confined hallways and cells the size of bathrooms. He challenges the system: offer a redemption path or execute him. Brian says he feels no bond with Tori anymore; the kids they were are gone.
37:41 — Parents' Perspectives: Carrie Draper and Anna Stoddard: Brian's father Carrie accepts blame and would trade places with his son. Cassie's mother Anna Stoddard (d. 2022) delivers a powerful impact statement: the killers' parents can visit them; she visits a grave.
Speakers
Connor McCarthy — Host/Narrator
Tori Adamcik — Convicted Killer
Brian Draper — Convicted Killer
Shannon Adamcik — Tori's Mother
Carrie Draper — Brian's Father
Lawrence Steinberg — Expert Commentator
James Fox — Expert Commentator
Anna Stoddard — Victim's Mother