TLDR
Jon Stewart hosts Renée DiResta and Casey Newton to discuss the SAVE Act and the real threat to American democracy: algorithmic amplification of election misinformation on social media. They explore how false narratives about non-citizen voting spread through emotional resonance and platform design, the weaponization of research into election rumors, and the hypocrisy of free speech absolutism on platforms like X.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The top 10 viral election rumors in 2020 generated 22 million tweets, yet platforms acted on only 10% of the 3,000 URLs flagged by researchers.
Jim Jordan's committee used a post-election data summary (published March 2021) to falsely claim researchers censored 22 million tweets during the election.
Stephen Miller sued Renée DiResta in the same court that heard Missouri v. Biden, using a plaintiff they'd never heard of to establish venue.
Elon Musk argued his AI had a 'right' to nudify children, claiming moderation of such content was censorship.
The Supreme Court (Amy Coney Barrett) tossed Missouri v. Biden for standing, calling lower court findings 'clearly erroneous.'
Renée DiResta's 12-year-old son recognizes when she gives a 'distracted phone response' vs. genuine attention.
Key takeaways
The SAVE Act targets a virtually non-existent problem (non-citizen voting) while ignoring the documented threat of algorithmic misinformation.
Election rumors spread because they resonate emotionally, not because of evidence; facts cannot easily counter viral emotional stories.
The Election Integrity Partnership's work tracking 2020 election rumors was mischaracterized as censorship by the House Weaponization Committee.
Elon Musk's X algorithm actively promotes right-wing content and his own posts, creating a structural bias far more impactful than isolated voting fraud.
Platforms have First Amendment rights to curate content; users do not have a First Amendment right to reach on private platforms.
Government communication with platforms about content moderation is routine across administrations, but has been framed as coercion only when politically convenient.
The 'censorship' label is used as a mental stop-word to justify extreme content (e.g., AI-generated non-consensual nudity) while demanding platform liability protections.
Algorithmic speech is not free speech—it is ultra-processed, engagement-optimized content designed to hypnotize users through outrage and conflict.
Notable quotes
“A rumor is something where it sounds like it could be true. It resonates with people. They think, oh, this might be something that is happening.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:58“You can't fact check your way out of this stuff. When you try to do that, people just feel that their voices are being suppressed.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:51“The First Amendment right, on a private platform, belongs to the platform—that is, to the company that is making the editorial curation decision. It doesn't belong to the user.”
▸ Notable quotes · 57:04“He borrows the moral weight of the word 'censorship' while emptying it of moral content.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:25“Twitter speech is free speech in the way that Doritos are food. It's not really. It's processed.”
▸ Notable quotes · 56:04“When I see something online that makes me feel a very strong emotion, that is the moment that I'm trying to be the most skeptical.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:16Chapters
0:35 — Introduction and SAVE Act Overview: Jon Stewart introduces the episode on St. Patrick's Day, criticizing the Senate's push for the SAVE Act to prevent non-citizen voting despite no evidence of widespread fraud.
4:41 — Why Non-Citizen Voting Myths Persist: Renée DiResta explains how election rumors (tropes) spread through emotional resonance and social media, not evidence, and why facts fail to counter them.
7:00 — Algorithmic Amplification and Elite Exploitation: Casey Newton describes how algorithms and political elites work together to spread emotional rumors that serve their cause, driven by audience demand for confirming narratives.
9:03 — The Election Integrity Partnership and Weaponization: DiResta details the 2020 Election Integrity Partnership's rumor-tracking work, its mischaracterization by Jim Jordan's committee as a 'censorship regime,' and the resulting lawsuits.
35:18 — Missouri v. Biden and the Censorship Narrative: DiResta breaks down the Murthy v. Missouri case, the cherry-picked judge, the 'deep state' theory, and the Supreme Court's rejection of the censorship claims.
17:00 — Elon Musk, X, and Algorithmic Bias: Discussion of Musk's ownership of X, his algorithm changes to boost his own posts, the Nature study showing rightward shift, and the platform as a right-wing political project.
56:40 — Free Speech vs. Algorithmic Speech: DiResta clarifies that platforms have First Amendment rights to curate, not users; algorithmic curation is editorial, not free speech; the 'censorship' label is weaponized hypocritically.
71:40 — Regulation, Personal Reflections, and Conclusion: The panel discusses age-gating social media, warning labels, the slow food media analogy, personal parenting struggles with tech, and the need to fight misinformation with tenacious information.
Speakers
Jon Stewart — Host
Renée DiResta — Guest
Casey Newton — Guest