TLDR
Wade hosts a choose-your-own-adventure game where Mark and Bob play cousins caught in a mysterious town cult worshipping 'the Shepherd.' After multiple deaths and rewinds, they escape with a bittersweet ending where Bob's mother is killed and his father destroys the cult's glowing relic. Wade reveals better endings they missed, including saving both parents and learning the Shepherd's true nature from a conspiracy theorist named Crazy Walter.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Shepherd was implied to be an alien or spacecraft that crashed decades ago, and the 'blessing' returned only after outsiders' blood spilled in the hollow.
Bob's parents participated in the sacrifices solely to protect him, despite him being less pious than other townspeople.
The glowing relic the father smashed was suggested to be pure radiation, and the hollow was the spaceship's landing site.
Wade wrote the second half of the adventure in a fugue state at 2 AM, which may explain why the best decisions were front-loaded.
Key takeaways
Wade created and ran his first choose-your-own-adventure game for the podcast, spending 3-4 hours writing it the night before recording.
The story centered on a town that prospered under a mysterious entity called the Shepherd, which eventually demanded blood sacrifices to maintain bountiful harvests.
Mark and Bob's characters were cousins who converged at a church, discovered the cult's symbolism, and barely escaped after Bob's father killed the pastor and seized a glowing relic.
Multiple decision points led to different outcomes: waiting in the car vs. walking the highway, investigating the church vs. leaving, searching abandoned cars vs. fleeing, and confronting the cult at the right moment to save Bob's mother.
The 'best ending' required Mark to walk the highway and meet Crazy Walter (who knew the cult's safe word), Bob to investigate the church thoroughly, and the pair to find weapons in the abandoned cars before the final confrontation.
Wade awarded points for humor and roleplay: Bob won with 7 points, Mark got 6, Wade got 2. The wheel spin resulted in a tie, sending them to a tie-breaker wheel for the first time.
The episode ran nearly twice the normal length due to the game's complexity, forcing Wade to cut planned content where the characters would separate and reunite multiple times.
Notable quotes
“It won't be in vain.”
▸ Notable quotes · 24:19“The shepherd left us this one blessing.”
▸ Notable quotes · 55:13“I shouldn't have done that. I know I shouldn't have done that.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:12“There is no escape except for me, right?”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:31“Never visit your cousin, even if they're in hardship, especially if they're in hardship.”
▸ Notable quotes · 69:50“The hollow, the reason the thing grew, that was where the spaceship landed.”
▸ Notable quotes · 70:07Chapters
0:00 — Intro and Small Talk: Wade hosts, Mark and Bob banter about golf rules scoring, Mark's broken foot and shower, Wade's upcoming ILS procedure and Cybertruck test drive shame.
13:05 — Game Setup and Mark's Path: Wade introduces his choose-your-own-adventure game. Mark drives to visit his cousin, gets two flat tires, waits in car, gets picked up by stranger, stays at motel, dies when opening door to masked figures, then rewinds.
17:23 — Bob's Path and Convergence: Bob works grocery closing shift, power goes out, finds flyer for midnight farm meeting, investigates farm, sees unconscious person dragged, gets caught and dies, then rewinds and chooses to flee to church.
31:43 — Church Investigation: Mark escapes motel window, finds Bob at church. They discover strange symbol (eyeball with rays, three V's with dots) carved on altar and door. Mark investigates parsonage, finds documents about the Shepherd and sacrifices.
39:01 — Escape Attempt and Car Graveyard: They sneak toward Bob's house, encounter barricades and patrols, find a clearing full of abandoned cars including Mark's, all sabotaged. They choose to leave without searching thoroughly.
48:51 — The Hollow Ritual and Climax: They go to the hollow at dawn, witness ceremony. Pastor confronts Bob's parents, kills mother. Mark distracts pastor, Bob's father kills pastor and takes glowing relic. They escape town with relic, but father smashes it at town edge.
57:51 — Epilogue and Reveals: Father reveals Shepherd was alien/craft from sky, blood sacrifice restored blessings. Parents participated to protect Bob. Wade explains missed paths: Crazy Walter, weapons in cars, better ending saving both parents.
65:01 — Scoring and Wheel Spin: Points awarded: Bob 7, Mark 6, Wade 2. Wheel spin ties, tie-breaker wheel used for first time. Winner speech by Bob, loser speech by Mark. Wade promotes socials and merch.
Speakers
Wade — Host / Game Master
Mark — Co-host / Player
Bob — Co-host / Player