TLDR
In September 2015, 21-year-old Ryan Zimmerman vanished from a Columbus, Ohio apartment he shared with Sarah Buzzard, Jen Whitaker, and Corey Buzzard. His spinal column was found in Mercer County in January 2016, but he wasn't identified until 2020 via DNA. In 2021, police confronted Sarah and Jen; Sarah confessed to strangling Ryan and dismembering him in the bathtub with a handsaw, then disposing of body parts in Ryan's car — which broke down, requiring a tow truck with remains still in the trunk. Jen died by suicide during interrogation. Months later, Sarah recanted, claiming Jen planned the murder, used bleach and vinegar to create poison gas, decapitated Ryan, and kept his head in a freezer hidden behind vegetables for years before boiling it down to a skull. Sarah pled guilty to tampering with evidence, grand theft, and abuse of a corpse, receiving life with parole eligibility after 30 years. Corey, away at a hotel during the killing, never cooperated.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Ryan's decapitated head was kept in a household freezer hidden behind frozen vegetables for years while the perpetrators continued living in the same home.
Jen Whitaker committed suicide by shooting herself in the head during police interrogation rather than face arrest, after hours of denying involvement.
Sarah created artwork depicting dismembered and decapitated figures — titled 'sacrificial lamb' and 'till death do us part' — months before the murder, which she later dismissed as coping mechanisms.
The perpetrators used Ryan's own car to transport his dismembered body parts, but it broke down at a gas station; a tow truck hauled it away with the remains still in the trunk, and police later found presumptive blood evidence in the trunk liner.
Sarah and Jen made a suicide pact that Jen would shoot Sarah first if they were caught, but Jen killed herself instead during the interrogation.
Key takeaways
Ryan Zimmerman was murdered and dismembered in September 2015 by his roommates Sarah Buzzard and Jen Whitaker in their Columbus, Ohio apartment while Corey Buzzard was away at a hotel.
Sarah initially confessed to killing Ryan in a fit of anger — choking him until he stopped moving — then dismembering his body in the bathtub with a handsaw found in the shed, with Jen's assistance.
The perpetrators loaded Ryan's dismembered remains into a Tupperware bin placed in Ryan's own car, intending to abandon it in Illinois, but the car broke down at a gas station; a tow truck removed it with body parts still in the trunk, forcing Sarah and Jen to transfer the remains to Sarah's vehicle in broad daylight.
Ryan's severed head was stored in a freezer behind frozen vegetables for years, moved with them to multiple residences, and eventually boiled in a pot with lye to reduce it to a skull, which police found in the garage at Sarah's mother's house.
Jen Whitaker died by suicide during police interrogation, shooting herself in the head with a handgun from her purse after being confronted with Sarah's confession and physical evidence.
Sarah's second confession, months later, shifted blame to Jen, claiming Jen planned the murder due to transphobic hatred toward Ryan's transition ('the world would be better off without him'), used bleach and vinegar to create poison gas, and forced Sarah to participate under threat.
Sarah created disturbing artwork months before the murder — a painting titled 'sacrificial lamb' depicting a dismembered, decapitated lamb, and a drawing titled 'till death do us part' of a mermaid holding a human head — which she later called coping mechanisms.
Sarah Buzzard pled guilty in January 2022 to tampering with evidence, grand theft of a motor vehicle, abuse of a corpse, and gross abuse of a corpse, receiving life in prison with parole eligibility after 30 years; Corey Buzzard never spoke to police without an attorney.
Notable quotes
“it was an accident okay it was an accident accidents happen every day”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:45“I knocked him down when he came out of the bathroom and I choked him”
▸ Notable quotes · 24:00“he passed out okay and I didn't let go mhm and then it was too late he stopped moving he started turning white”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:43“she had a rag uh that she dipped in bleach and she had a bottle of vinegar next to her to add to it when the time came because I guess they had some kind of chemical reaction and released some kind of poisonous gas”
▸ Notable quotes · 44:42“she put a trash bag over his head and severed it and then put that into the freezer so that she could deal with it later”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:42“the head in the freezer didn't draw any attention because she had packed like vegetables and stuff in front of it so it didn't look like it was anything”
▸ Notable quotes · 50:06Chapters
0:00 — Discovery and Identification: A dog walker finds a human spine in Mercer County in January 2016. Despite DNA entry into NamUs, the victim remains unidentified until 2020, when a cold case agent links the profile to Ryan Zimmerman, reported missing from Columbus in November 2015. DNA confirms the remains are Ryan's; his father Warren is told Ryan was dismembered and his skull, lower limbs, and arms are missing.
3:30 — Police Contact Roommates: In August 2021, police locate Sarah Buzzard and Jen Whitaker (now married) at Sarah's mother's house. They arrest Sarah on an Ohio theft warrant and begin questioning both women about Ryan, who lived with them, Corey Buzzard, and another roommate for two months in 2015 before being asked to leave.
8:00 — Interrogations and Discrepancies: Sarah and Jen give conflicting accounts of Ryan's departure. Sarah claims she drove Corey to a hotel the weekend Ryan left; Jen admits driving Ryan's car after he left and having it towed. Detectives reveal they found Ryan's abandoned car with his belongings, keys, and a full gas tank — and a neighbor saw it dropped off by a tow truck.
15:00 — Confrontation with Evidence: Detectives confront Sarah with DNA evidence from her old car (blood in the trunk) and luminol hits in the apartment bathroom. Sarah asks for a lawyer but then confesses: she choked Ryan after he left the bathroom, didn't let go, and he died. She and Jen dismembered him in the bathtub with a handsaw.
22:00 — Jen's Interrogation and Suicide: While Sarah confesses, Jen denies everything. Detectives reveal Sarah's full confession and physical evidence. An officer notices Jen's purse; moments later, as they move to arrest her, Jen pulls a handgun and shoots herself in the head. She is pronounced dead at the scene.
43:00 — Sarah's Second Confession: Months later, Sarah gives a new statement blaming Jen: Jen planned the murder, used bleach and vinegar to create poison gas, held a rag over Ryan's mouth, decapitated him, and kept the head in the freezer. Sarah claims she participated under duress because Jen threatened to kill her if she didn't help.
52:00 — Motive and Artwork: Sarah explains Jen's motive: transphobic rage at Ryan's transition ('the world would be better off without him'). Sarah also discusses her pre-murder artwork — a dismembered lamb titled 'sacrificial lamb' and a mermaid holding a human head titled 'till death do us part' — calling them coping mechanisms for her abusive relationship with Corey.
55:00 — Sentencing: In January 2022, Sarah Buzzard pleads guilty to tampering with evidence, grand theft of a motor vehicle, abuse of a corpse, and gross abuse of a corpse. She is sentenced to life in prison with parole eligibility after 30 years. Ryan's father Warren gives a final statement: 'no one can hurt him anymore.'
Speakers
Narrator — Voiceover narrator
Sarah Buzzard — Perpetrator / Ryan's roommate
Jen Whitaker / Naira — Perpetrator / Sarah's partner
Corey Buzzard — Sarah's ex-husband / Ryan's roommate
Warren Zimmerman — Ryan's father
Detective Megan Baker — Ohio sheriff's office detective
Detective Rick Ward — Ohio sheriff's office detective
Maran Police Detectives — Local detectives