Three Days Left. How Bad Could It Get for Republicans? (w/ Sarah Longwell) | Bulwark on Sunday

Original Media · 54m · English · YouTube · The Bulwark

TLDR

Bill Kristol and Sarah Longwell analyze the 2026 midterm landscape, arguing Trump has squandered every advantage through self-inflicted errors — tariffs, war, broken promises on prices — driving his approval to Bush-in-2006 levels. Focus groups reveal a depressed Republican base moving from 'give him time' to 'I'm done,' with rural turnout likely to collapse. Democrats could see a wave larger than 2006, flipping Senate seats in Texas, Florida, Ohio, and Kansas, and winning governorships that would hinder 2028 election subversion. The movement is voter-driven, not elite-led, fueled by negative personal consequences (gas, groceries, data centers) rather than abstract principle. They also discuss the Michigan Senate race where Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers over Democrat Abdul El-Sayed, and the generational shift toward younger, tech-native politicians.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

South Carolina (R+18) and Kansas (R+16) are genuinely competitive, requiring massive electorate movement that defies conventional assumptions about Republican floor support.

•

Corruption ranks as a top issue in polls, but Longwell cautions it's partly a discourse artifact: partisan Republicans answer 'corruption' by citing Democratic scandals, inflating the issue's salience without consensus on meaning.

•

Trump's first-term guardrails prevented voters from seeing the full consequences; Longwell argues it would have been better if they had, so the country could have had a thorough repudiation earlier.

•

Data centers in rural areas are a sleeper political issue: they drive up energy prices, create local blight, and fuel job-displacement anxiety among Trump's base.

•

Haley Stevens, a Democratic incumbent, endorsed Republican Mike Rogers (election denier, anti-abortion) over the Democratic nominee — a rare cross-party endorsement driven by primary bitterness.

Key takeaways

•

Trump's approval has dropped to the low 30s — comparable to Bush in 2006 — due entirely to his own choices (tariffs, war, broken price promises), not external events, and voters explicitly blame him.

•

Focus groups show a rapid shift from 'give him time' to 'he lied to us' among Trump voters, who cite corruption and personal economic pain (gas, groceries, diesel, data-center energy costs) as reasons they're disengaging.

•

Republican rural turnout is likely to collapse because those voters are most hurt by prices and energy costs, while Democratic turnout surges among Black voters in the South and Latinos in Texas/Florida driven by both economics and rights concerns.

•

The 2026 wave could exceed 2006, flipping Senate seats in deep-red states (Texas, Florida, Ohio, Kansas, South Carolina) and winning governorships that would create a structural bulwark against 2028 election subversion.

•

Elite signaling has lost its power; the movement is bottom-up, with elites as lagging indicators. This reflects a transformed media environment and a populist era where elites follow rather than lead.

•

A generational transition is underway: politicians in their late 30s/early 40s (Ossoff, Buttigieg, AOC, Vance, Talarico) are rising because they are native to the new information environment, while Gen X candidates are caught in a 'sour spot' of outdated communication styles.

•

The Michigan Senate race illustrates Democratic tensions: Haley Stevens endorsed election-denier Mike Rogers over Abdul El-Sayed, but Longwell and Kristol argue the priority must be a thorough repudiation of Trumpism, even with imperfect candidates.

Notable quotes

“the biggest takeaway just from the whole year is to think about how Trump squandered every piece of advantage he had. And the reason that we're sitting on the precipice of I think a pretty big election night for Democrats are because of choices Trump made, not things that happened to him.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:00

“they're forced to say things are going really poorly and it is primarily because of tariffs and the war. And they hear Trump saying affordability crisis is a hoax. They hear Trump saying like everything is great. And they're like, "No, it's not. You're lying to us."”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:30

“I think if people were doing fine, and if the economy was doing well, I'm not sure that they would be penalizing Trump for corruption. I think his voters would be totally ignoring it. But because their lives are materially worse, they notice it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:00

“the elites just do not have the signaling power that they once did. They mostly have it among other elites. Um, I also think we are in an age of deeply broken and cowardly elites. Um, and part of the populist movement means that elites no longer lead, they follow the waves of the population.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:54

“my prediction of what is about to happen is going to 100% be due to yes, high turnout from Democrats and Democrat breaking independents or independents casting a protest vote. But I think when we look back... those Republican rural voters don't show up.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:53

“this time might be that thorough repudiation. Uh it won't be for all the reasons we want it to be, but it will be because of bad governance. And so that may that may cause uh the kind of soul-searching, rethinking the party uh exercise that does pull us back from the brink.”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:43

Chapters

•

0:00 — Opening and Halloween chat: Bill Kristol and Sarah Longwell open with light conversation about Halloween and parenting before turning to the 2026 midterm outlook.

•

2:01 — Trump's squandered advantages and voter shift: Longwell argues Trump lost the midterms through self-inflicted errors (tariffs, war, broken promises) and focus groups show his voters moving from patience to anger, explicitly blaming him for higher costs.

•

9:10 — Corruption, elite signaling, and personal consequences: Corruption resonates only because voters' material lives are worse; elites have lost signaling power and now follow public opinion rather than lead it, making this a bottom-up wave.

•

20:00 — Turnout dynamics and state-by-state map: Depressed Republican rural turnout combined with surging Democratic turnout among Black and Latino voters could produce a wave exceeding 2006, putting Texas, Florida, Ohio, Kansas, and South Carolina in play.

•

27:00 — Generational shift in political leadership: A new generation of late-30s/early-40s politicians native to the current information environment is rising, while Gen X candidates are stranded in a communication 'sour spot.'

•

40:40 — Michigan Senate race and Democratic tensions: Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers over Democrat Abdul El-Sayed; Longwell and Kristol argue the priority must be a thorough repudiation of Trumpism despite candidate imperfections.

•

39:00 — Election subversion stakes and closing: Winning governorships in key states would create a structural barrier against 2028 election subversion; both hosts express cautious optimism but acknowledge PTSD from past cycles.

Speakers

•

Bill Kristol — Host

•

Sarah Longwell — Co-host / Guest

⋮