TLDR
The January 6 Committee's third hearing detailed former President Trump's multi-week pressure campaign to convince Vice President Pence to unilaterally reject electoral votes or send them back to states on January 6, 2021. Witnesses Greg Jacob (Pence's counsel) and Judge J. Michael Luttig testified that Pence had no constitutional authority to do so, that Trump was told repeatedly the theory was illegal, and that John Eastman admitted his own plan would lose 9-0 at the Supreme Court. Despite this, Trump publicly and privately pressured Pence, culminating in a heated January 6 phone call where Trump called Pence a "wimp," then tweeted criticism of Pence at 2:24 p.m. while a violent mob — chanting "hang Mike Pence" — breached the Capitol. Pence refused to flee, completed the certification, and Eastman emailed afterward still urging him to delay. Luttig warned Trump and allies remain a "clear and present danger" for 2024. A federal judge has since found it "more likely than not" that Trump and Eastman dishonestly conspired to obstruct the joint session.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
John Eastman had written a memo in October 2020 — before the election — that eviscerated the very theory he later pushed, writing in his own comments that "nowhere does it suggest that the president of the senate gets to make the determination on his own."
Eastman conceded to Jacob that Al Gore did not have the authority to declare himself president in 2000 and Kamala Harris should not have that power in 2024 — but insisted Pence should use it in 2021.
After the Capitol attack, Eastman's first written response to Jacob's email ("thanks to your we are now under siege") was: "the siege is because you and your boss did not do what was necessary," blaming Pence for the violence.
Eastman requested a presidential pardon for himself days after January 6, and when deposed by the Committee, invoked the Fifth Amendment over 100 times.
Jared Kushner dismissed White House Counsel Pat Cipollone's threats to resign over the pressure campaign as "whining," showing senior aides treated the constitutional crisis as a personnel annoyance.
Key takeaways
Vice President Pence's legal team — including his counsel Greg Jacob and conservative Judge J. Michael Luttig — concluded after thorough research that the Constitution gives the vice president no authority to reject electoral votes or send them back to states, a view shared by White House Counsel Pat Cipollone, Chief of Staff Mark Meadows, and even Rudy Giuliani.
John Eastman, the architect of the theory, admitted to Greg Jacob on January 5 that his proposal would violate the Electoral Count Act, and during a two-hour debate acknowledged his argument would lose 9-0 in the Supreme Court — yet he still urged Pence to adopt it the next day.
Trump was told directly and repeatedly by Pence, Jacob, Meadows, Cipollone, and others that Pence lacked the power to overturn the election, but Trump continued a public and private pressure campaign, including a heated January 6 phone call where he called Pence a "wimp" and said "I don't want to be your friend anymore" if Pence didn't comply.
At 2:24 p.m. on January 6, after being informed by Chief of Staff Mark Meadows that the Capitol had been breached and violence was underway, Trump tweeted that Pence "didn't have the courage to do what should have been done," which witnesses said poured "gasoline on the fire" and caused rioters to surge toward Pence's location.
Pence came within approximately 40 feet of the mob while being evacuated; his Secret Service detail could not guarantee his safety if he left the Capitol complex. Pence refused to get in the car, saying he did not want the world to see the vice president fleeing the Capitol, and insisted on completing the certification.
Even after the attack, at 11:44 p.m. on January 6, Eastman emailed Jacob imploring Pence to "adjourn for 10 days to allow the legislatures to finish their investigations," acknowledging the Electoral Count Act had been violated by the riot but arguing that set a precedent for further violations.
Judge Luttig testified that had Pence obeyed Trump, it would have plunged the nation into a constitutional crisis "tantamount to a revolution" — the first since the founding — and warned that Trump and his allies are executing a "blueprint" to attempt the same in 2024, succeeding where they failed in 2020.
A federal district judge (David Carter) ruled in a related civil case that "based on the evidence the court finds that it is more likely than not that president trump and dr eastman dishonestly conspired to obstruct the joint session of congress on january 6 2021."
Notable quotes
“there is almost no idea more un-american than the notion that any one person could choose the american president”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:14“had the vice president of the united states obeyed the president of the united states america would immediately have been plunged into what would have been tantamount to a revolution within a paralyzing constitutional crisis”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:15“the single sentence in the 12th amendment was he thought inartfully written that single sentence is not inartfully written it was pristine clear”
▸ Notable quotes · 48:24“i said are you out of your f in mind right and i said you're completely crazy i said you're going to turn around and tell 78 plus million people in this country that your theory is this is how you're going to invalidate their votes because you think the election was stolen and they're not going to tolerate that said you're going to cause riots in the streets”
▸ Notable quotes · 62:50“he initially started it well i think maybe you would lose only seven to two and after some further discussion acknowledged well yeah you're right we would lose nine nothing”
▸ Notable quotes · 68:58“the siege is because you and your boss presumably referring to the vice president of the united states did not do what was necessary to allow this to be errored in a public way so the american people can see for themselves what happened”
▸ Notable quotes · 147:16Chapters
11:43 — Opening Statements: Chairman Thompson and Vice Chair Cheney frame the hearing around Trump's pressure campaign on Pence, citing a federal court finding that Trump and Eastman likely conspired to obstruct the joint session. Rep. Aguilar outlines the "legal scheme and deception" culminating in January 6.
23:57 — Witness Introductions and Legal Analysis: Greg Jacob and Judge Luttig are sworn in. Jacob details his December 2020 research concluding Pence had no authority to reject electors, based on text, structure, history, and the fact that no vice president in 230 years claimed such power. Luttig calls Eastman's theory "incorrect at every turn."
38:57 — The Fake Electors and Eastman's Memos: Cheney details the Kenneth Chesebro and John Eastman memos promoting fake electors. Jacob confirms no dual slates existed. Luttig states there was no constitutional or legal basis for counting uncertified slates, and no historical precedent from 1789 onward.
50:37 — January 4 Oval Office Meeting: Jacob describes the January 4 meeting with Trump, Pence, Eastman, and Meadows. Eastman presented two options: reject electors outright or suspend the session and send to states. Eastman acknowledged both violated the Electoral Count Act but argued the Act was unconstitutional and courts would invoke political question doctrine.
56:07 — January 5 Meetings and Escalation: Jacob details his extended January 5 debate with Eastman, who reversed course and explicitly requested Pence reject electors. Eastman conceded the underlying legal theory was the same for both options ("just between us Chicago chickens"). Trump issued a false statement claiming Pence agreed he had the power to act.
75:37 — January 6: Pressure, Riot, and Evacuation: Trump's heated morning call with Pence (calling him a "wimp"), ellipse speech attacking Pence, and 2:24 p.m. tweet during the breach. Pence evacuated, came within 40 feet of rioters, refused to leave the Capitol, and continued working from a secure location. Trump never called to check on Pence's safety.
89:37 — Eastman's Post-Attack Emails and Closing: Eastman emailed Jacob at 11:44 p.m. January 6 still urging Pence to adjourn for 10 days. Pence called it "rubber room stuff." Luttig warns Trump and allies are a "clear and present danger" for 2024, executing the same blueprint openly. Committee plays deposition clips of Eastman pleading the Fifth 100+ times.
Speakers
Bennie Thompson — Chairman, January 6 Select Committee
Liz Cheney — Vice Chair, January 6 Select Committee
Pete Aguilar — Committee Member, Questioning Lead
John Wood — Senior Investigative Counsel
Greg Jacob — Witness — Counsel to Vice President Pence
J. Michael Luttig — Witness — Retired Federal Judge