TLDR
Progressive commentator analyzes the right-wing smear campaign against newly elected Michigan Senator Abdul El-Sayed, focusing on Dave Rubin's Islamophobic attacks accusing El-Sayed of being a Muslim Brotherhood terrorist. The host debunks false claims about El-Sayed failing security clearances, exposes Rubin's hypocrisy on free speech after he condemned Dave Chappelle's Charlie Kirk joke while previously championing 'edgy' comedy, and highlights how right-wing figures use anti-Muslim bigotry to avoid debating popular progressive policies like universal healthcare and higher wages.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Dave Rubin, who built his brand on 'free speech' and 'fuck your feelings,' went on Fox News to complain that a Dave Chappelle joke made him feel 'unsafe.'
The 'background check failure' story about El-Sayed was entirely fabricated — senators don't undergo background checks for classified access at all.
Rubin's 'Muslim Brotherhood' accusation relies on his audience not knowing what the Muslim Brotherhood actually is — a political organization spanning multiple countries, not a terrorist group like ISIS.
Key takeaways
Abdul El-Sayed won his Michigan Senate race by seven points despite a massive right-wing smear campaign that focused almost exclusively on his Muslim identity rather than policy positions.
Dave Rubin called El-Sayed a 'genuinely evil person sent by the Muslim Brotherhood to destroy America' while Rubin himself previously argued in favor of bombing schools and hospitals during his time at The Young Turks.
The claim that El-Sayed failed FBI background checks for classified briefings is false — a community note on X clarified that U.S. senators receive security access by virtue of their elected office and do not undergo formal background checks.
Rubin uses the term 'Gazin' instead of 'Palestinian' because he denies Palestinian identity exists, which the host identifies as Zionist propaganda designed to erase Palestinian nationhood.
Right-wing 'free speech absolutists' like Rubin abandoned their principles when Dave Chappelle made a joke about Charlie Kirk, with Rubin appearing on Hannity to claim he felt 'unsafe' — despite years of telling critics 'fuck your feelings.'
Chappelle's Charlie Kirk joke was deliberately structured as a mirror of Tony Hinchcliffe's George Floyd joke, exposing the right's selective outrage and proving their 'edgy comedy' defense was never a genuine principle.
The host argues Republicans attack El-Sayed's religion because they cannot win on substance — El-Sayed's platform of universal healthcare, higher wages, and anti-corruption is popular, so they resort to Islamophobia instead.
Notable quotes
“If I asked you to name one policy that Mike Rogers was running on, what would you say? My guess is you drew a blank. And you want to know why you drew a blank? Because he wasn't running on policy.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:28“He's a genuinely evil person who is sent here by the Muslim Brotherhood to destroy America.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:17“If Joe Biden survives his entire four-year term in office, then I will retire. I will step down. I'll resign. I won't do my show anymore.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:52“By your logic, when somebody swears in on the Bible, does that mean that the Bible is more important to them and the Bible is what they govern based on more than the Constitution?”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:15“Nobody has ever abided by the Constitution less than the president you support, you piece of shit.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:19“It's literally JUST I HATE MUSLIMS. LIKE, that's it. That's all this is.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:58Chapters
0:00 — El-Sayed's victory and right-wing smear campaign: The host describes how Abdul El-Sayed won his Michigan Senate race by seven points despite a relentless right-wing campaign that attacked his Muslim identity with accusations of terrorism and Muslim Brotherhood ties, while his opponent Mike Rogers ran on virtually no policy positions.
2:00 — Dave Rubin's Islamophobic attacks on El-Sayed: The host plays and dissects clips of Dave Rubin calling El-Sayed 'evil' and a Muslim Brotherhood operative sent to destroy America, while noting Rubin's own history of advocating for bombing schools and hospitals during his time at The Young Turks.
4:00 — Debunking the false background check claim: Rubin and his guest spread a false rumor that El-Sayed failed FBI background checks for classified briefings; a community note on X clarifies that senators receive security access by virtue of their elected office and do not undergo formal background checks.
6:40 — Rubin's 'Gazin' terminology and Palestinian erasure: The host explains that Rubin's use of 'Gazin' instead of 'Palestinian' reflects his denial of Palestinian identity — a Zionist talking point that Palestinians are a made-up people — and notes El-Sayed has actually called for cutting aid to both Israel and Egypt.
8:00 — Quran oath hypocrisy and Republican theocracy: Rubin suggests swearing on the Quran means El-Sayed will prioritize Islam over the Constitution; the host counters by pointing out Republican support for replacing the Constitution with biblical law, and Trump's record of ignoring court orders and the First Amendment.
10:40 — Right-wing free speech hypocrisy exposed by Chappelle joke: After years of championing 'edgy' comedy and telling critics 'fuck your feelings,' Rubin appears on Hannity claiming a Dave Chappelle joke about Charlie Kirk made him feel 'unsafe' — Chappelle's joke was a deliberate mirror of Tony Hinchcliffe's George Floyd joke, exposing the right's selective outrage.
Speakers
Host — Progressive political commentator
Dave Rubin — Right-wing political commentator
Sean Hannity — Fox News host
Abdul El-Sayed — Michigan State Senator