They found something bizarre in her bathtub

Original Media · 32m · English · YouTube · MrBallen

TLDR

In 1999, 66-year-old Angela Spence-Shaw was brutally murdered in her Rhode Island home. The killer entered through an unfinished construction doorway from a sunroom renovation, beat and sexually assaulted her, then staged the scene with a hairdryer in the bathtub to look like an accident. Construction worker Jeremy Motyka was convicted after his girlfriend turned in his hidden work shoes and DNA matched semen from the crime scene.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The killer was not the paroled murderer living across the street or the registered sex offender, but a seemingly cooperative construction worker with no prior violent record.

•

The victim's front door being unlocked was a red herring; the killer actually entered through an unfinished construction window and doorway that only the crew knew about.

•

The killer's eagerness to provide blood samples and take a polygraph was a sign of guilt, not innocence, which contradicts common assumptions about cooperative suspects.

•

The hairdryer in the bathtub was a deliberate staging attempt to disguise murder as an accident, not an actual accident or suicide as it initially appeared.

Key takeaways

•

The killer exploited an unfinished construction entry point — a tarp-covered doorway from a sunroom renovation — to enter the victim's home without forced entry.

•

Lieutenant Lynch initially suspected a personal connection due to the extreme violence and lack of forced entry, but the evidence pointed to a stranger who knew the house's vulnerability.

•

Two known violent offenders lived nearby — a paroled murderer across the street and a registered sex offender — creating strong alternative suspects that delayed focusing on the construction crew.

•

The killer staged the scene to look like an accident/suicide by placing a running hairdryer in the bathtub with the body, but the extensive beating and stripped bedsheets contradicted this staging.

•

Jeremy Motyka's attempt to hide his work shoes by having his girlfriend move them to Cape Cod backfired when she became suspicious and turned them over to police.

•

Motyka's willing cooperation with police — eagerly providing blood samples and alibis — was itself a red flag that Lynch recognized as characteristic of guilty suspects.

•

DNA from semen recovered during the autopsy provided the definitive match to Motyka, leading to his conviction for first-degree murder and sexual assault with life without parole.

•

The victim's routine of leaving her front door unlocked occasionally was known to friends but not to strangers, making the construction access point the more likely entry for someone unfamiliar with her habits.

Notable quotes

“she was basically unrecognizable”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:09

“there was no way she could have done all that to herself”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:32

“I learned my lesson in prison. I didn't do this. I had nothing to do with this.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:42

“His DNA completely matched the DNA in the semen that was recovered from Angela's body.”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:47

“the killer hopped in their car and they drove to their girlfriend's parents' house out in Cape Cod”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:13

“it was because he tried to get rid of the evidence that he made his girlfriend so suspicious that she turned him in”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:34

Chapters

•

3:27 — Discovery of the Body: Sally Craig finds Angela's body after hearing a hairdryer running in the bathroom, leading to police involvement.

•

5:48 — Crime Scene Investigation: Lieutenant Lynch examines the scene, noting extreme violence, staged electrocution, and lack of forced entry.

•

10:31 — Initial Suspects: Police focus on a paroled murderer across the street and a registered sex offender, both with violent histories against women.

•

16:24 — Construction Access Point: Lynch discovers an unfinished doorway from the sunroom renovation that provided hidden access to the home.

•

20:29 — Construction Worker Interviews: Police interview 23 construction workers; Jeremy Motyka provides a partial alibi but seems eager to cooperate.

•

25:09 — Stanley Gendron Interrogation: The paroled murderer is brought in, claims innocence, agrees to testing, but is ultimately cleared.

•

27:43 — Breakthrough and Confession: Motyka's girlfriend turns in his shoes after he asks her to hide them; DNA matches semen from the crime scene.

•

27:48 — Reconstruction and Conviction: Police reconstruct the crime; Motyka is convicted of first-degree murder and sexual assault, sentenced to life without parole.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Host

⋮