TLDR
Federal Judge Anna Reyes issued a preliminary injunction blocking Donald Trump's order to close the East Potomac Golf Course in DC on November 15th for a private renovation by his associate Tom Fazio. In an extraordinary all-day hearing, Reyes publicly challenged DOJ attorneys' credibility, polling the courtroom audience to demonstrate widespread public opposition the government denied existed. She ruled the administration's claimed safety concerns were pretextual and that the closure likely violates the National Environmental Policy Act and Administrative Procedure Act, which require public notice and comment before closing national parkland.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A federal judge polled a courtroom audience of over 100 people by show of hands to fact-check a DOJ attorney's sworn statement that no public concern existed beyond the plaintiffs.
The judge used a physics concept — the zeptosecond, defined as the time for a photon to cross a hydrogen molecule — as a courtroom metaphor for how swiftly she would impose contempt sanctions.
DOJ attorney Adam Gustafson claimed under oath he was unaware of any public opposition to closing a beloved DC public park, despite extensive media coverage and community organizing.
The judge explicitly accused government lawyers of lying to the court, using the phrase 'officer of the court' as a euphemism for 'I think you're lying to me.'
Key takeaways
Judge Reyes took the unprecedented step of polling the courtroom audience — over 100 people — to prove public concern about the golf course closure after a DOJ attorney claimed under oath that only the plaintiffs objected.
The judge introduced the concept of a zeptosecond (a trillionth of a billionth of a second) to warn DOJ attorneys she would initiate contempt proceedings 'in a zeptosecond' if she found evidence of document destruction related to the golf course or other Trump vanity projects.
Reyes explicitly found the Interior Department's stated safety rationale — seawall repairs — to be pretextual, concluding the real driver was Trump's Truth Social post ordering the November 15th closure for a private redesign by golf architect Tom Fazio.
The ruling cites likely violations of two federal statutes: the National Environmental Policy Act and the Administrative Procedure Act, both requiring extensive public notice, comment periods, and agency consideration before closing national parkland — none of which occurred.
Glenn Kirschner, a 30-year veteran prosecutor, described the hearing as unlike anything he had ever witnessed, particularly the judge's direct engagement with the audience to expose government lawyers' lack of candor.
The East Potomac Golf Course is a public facility where residents play nine holes for $20; Trump's plan would convert it into an exclusive, high-end course most current users could not afford.
Kirschner notes the legal remedy for defiance is enforcement by the U.S. Marshals Service, which has statutory authority to deploy all necessary resources to enforce federal court orders, but practically questions whether Trump will comply given his history of defying court orders on vanity projects like the White House ballroom.
The discussion frames this case as emblematic of Trump's governing priorities: marshalling federal resources for personal vanity projects (golf course, ballroom, triumphal arch, helipad) while neglecting public needs like aviation infrastructure, healthcare, and foreign policy.
Notable quotes
“I have seen the reporting of whistleblowers coming forward and telling members of Congress that people in the Trump administration at the Department of the Interior are destroying documents about the golf course and about Trump's other vanity projects.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:22“If I find any evidence that documents are being destroyed, I will start contempt proceedings against you all in a zeptosecond. Is that clear?”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:17“Sir, do you realize you're an officer of the court? That's a euphemism, Brian. When a judge says that to an attorney, it means the judge believes the attorney is not being honest, not being straight, not being candid with the court.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:06“The Department of the Interior has progressed from removing trees to removing the people from East Potomac Park. President Trump directed the government to close East Potomac as of November 15th. And two days later, the Department of the Interior announced it would follow that directive.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:49“I don't believe that's why you're closing it. I believe it's because Donald Trump posted that he wants it closed on November 15th.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:04“What's to stop him legally is an order, a lawful binding order issued by a co-equal branch of government, the judiciary, directing the executive branch, that you may not act lawlessly. And if he defies that, what's to stop him legally? The United States Marshals Service.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:44Chapters
0:08 — Judge Reyes issues injunction against golf course closure: Federal Judge Anna Reyes orders a preliminary injunction blocking Trump's November 15th closure of the East Potomac Golf Course for a private renovation by Tom Fazio, finding the move violates multiple federal laws.
1:35 — Extraordinary courtroom tactics: zeptoseconds and audience polling: Judge Reyes asks the courtroom audience if anyone knows what a zeptosecond is, then uses it as a metaphor for how fast she will impose contempt sanctions if document destruction is found; she later polls the audience by show of hands to disprove a DOJ attorney's claim that no public concern exists.
3:18 — DOJ attorneys challenged for lack of candor: Judge Reyes confronts DOJ attorneys Stanley Woodward and Adam Gustafson over whistleblower reports of document destruction and the government's false claim that safety concerns, not Trump's directive, drive the closure.
8:52 — Judge rules safety rationale is pretextual: In her 30+ page order, Reyes finds the administration's seawall repair justification is a pretext; the real reason is Trump's social media post. She rules likely violations of NEPA and the Administrative Procedure Act, which require public notice and comment before closing national parkland.
12:03 — Enforcement mechanisms and practical compliance concerns: Kirschner explains the U.S. Marshals Service has statutory authority to enforce federal court orders, but questions whether Trump will comply given his history of defying court orders on vanity projects like the White House ballroom and a planned triumphal arch.
14:09 — Trump's priorities vs. public needs: Cohen argues Trump marshals federal resources for personal vanity projects (golf course, ballroom, arch, helipad) while neglecting aviation infrastructure, healthcare, and foreign policy, and links this to Republican electoral losses in multiple states.
Speakers
Brian Tyler Cohen — Host
Glenn Kirschner — Legal analyst