Are These Artifacts Proof of Treasure? | The Curse of Oak Island

Original Media · 9m · English · YouTube · HISTORY

TLDR

The team investigates a suspected slipway on Oak Island's Lot 5, uncovering hand-forged iron artifacts (a spike and a square nail) that lab analysis dates to the mid-1600s to mid-1700s. Metallurgical testing reveals a near-identical compositional match to artifacts from the homestead of Sir William Phips, a 17th-century treasure hunter, strengthening the theory that Phips may have used the island to hide recovered Spanish treasure.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The iron artifacts from the slipway are compositionally nearly identical to those from William Phips' birthplace, a specific and unexpected link across centuries.

•

The slipway artifacts predate the commonly assumed 18th-century activity on Lot 5, pushing the site's use back to the 1600s.

•

Despite 231 years of searching, the team is still finding 'first-of-their-kind' structural evidence like a preserved slipway.

Key takeaways

•

A slipway on Lot 5 suggests heavy maritime activity and a means to transport materials ashore.

•

Excavation yielded a wrought-iron cribbing spike and a square-shanked nail, both showing extended wear.

•

CT scanning and compositional analysis date the artifacts to the mid-1600s–mid-1700s, earlier than many Lot 5 finds.

•

The iron's elemental signature closely matches artifacts from William Phips' Maine homestead, linking the site to the famed treasure salvor.

•

Phips recovered tons of silver from the Concepción wreck (1687) and had Nova Scotia connections via Captain Andrew Belcher.

•

The growing body of evidence supports the hypothesis that Phips or his associates operated on Oak Island.

•

Federal regulations limited digging to above the high-tide line, preserving submerged context for future work.

•

The team plans to continue investigating the slipway and surrounding features for more dating evidence.

Notable quotes

“I want to find the one thing, the one irrefutable piece of evidence that helps explain the mystery in its entirety and its complexity.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:11

“Oh, this is a lovely, jubbly find. I love these old iron fasteners.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:19

“really does put it in the mid-1600s to mid-1700s, comfortably.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:54

“Incredibly, they were a near-identical match.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:25

“This sort of proves that slipway's very old.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:10

“Well, add it to the pile that keeps growing and growing and growing, right?”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:37

Chapters

•

0:01 — Rick's Motivation and the Oak Island Mystery: Rick Lagina reflects on his lifelong dedication to solving the Oak Island mystery and the desire to find definitive evidence.

•

1:01 — Investigating the Lot 5 Slipway: The team discusses the discovered slipway between Lots 4 and 5, a sloped ramp for docking boats, and plans to excavate for artifacts identifying the builders of nearby stone structures.

•

3:14 — Excavating the Slipway: Iron Artifacts Found: Metal detecting and digging above the high-tide line yield a hand-forged cribbing spike and a square-shanked nail, indicating an early wooden structure.

•

6:00 — Lab Analysis: Dating the Artifacts: Archaeometallurgist Emma Culligan uses CT scanning to reveal the artifacts are wrought iron, heavily worn, and date to the mid-1600s to mid-1700s.

•

7:17 — The William Phips Connection: Compositional analysis shows a near-identical match to iron from William Phips' homestead, linking the slipway to the 1687 treasure salvor who recovered Spanish silver and had Nova Scotia ties.

•

8:52 — Conclusions and Next Steps: The team agrees the slipway is very old and the Phips connection is intriguing; they plan to continue investigating Lot 5 for more evidence.

Speakers

•

Rick — Co-lead treasure hunter, co-owner of Oak Island Tours

•

Marty — Co-lead treasure hunter, engineer, financier

•

Narrator — Series narrator

•

Alex — Team member, Marty's son

•

Gary — Metal detection expert

•

Craig — Partner, engineer, project manager

•

Laird — Archaeologist

•

Billy — Heavy equipment operator

•

Emma — Archaeometallurgist / Lab analyst

•

Jack — Team member

⋮