Small town police officer never came home

Original Media · 30m · English · YouTube · MrBallen

TLDR

In 1997, Higginson, Arkansas police officer Danny Longstreet was ambushed and shot dead in his patrol car. He wrote a license plate number on his hand before dying, leading investigators to Justin Swain, who had a feud with Danny, but Swain had an alibi. A tip at a checkpoint pointed to Tim Askins, who faced felony charges due to Danny's testimony, but his work records initially confirmed his alibi. The case was solved when a friend turned in the murder weapon — a gun borrowed by Askins's sister and brother-in-law — after realizing three bullets were missing and connecting it to the widely publicized murder. Askins, his sister Christy Fulghum, and her husband Jess Fulghum were all convicted.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The license plate on Danny's hand belonged to a truck that was broken down at his sister's house, and the plates had been borrowed by Justin Swain weeks earlier — a complete red herring.

•

Tim Askins' work records showed he was at work, but no co-workers actually remembered seeing him during the murder window.

•

The murder weapon was borrowed from a friend who didn't know it would be used for murder, and the friend turned it in out of fear after realizing three bullets were missing.

•

The killer went back to work after the murder hoping no one noticed he was gone.

Key takeaways

•

Danny Longstreet wrote a license plate number on his hand before dying, which led investigators to Dale Miller and then to Justin Swain, but Swain had an alibi confirmed by a friend.

•

Tim Askins had a strong motive — facing prison for insurance fraud due to Danny's testimony — but his work records initially confirmed his alibi, though no co-workers actually remembered seeing him during the murder window.

•

The murder was committed by Tim Askins with help from his sister Christy Fulghum and her husband Jess Fulghum, who drove him to and from the scene and helped bury the gun.

•

The gun was borrowed from a friend who later turned it in after realizing three bullets were missing and connecting it to the widely publicized murder investigation.

•

The killer approached from the backseat of a car, wore gloves, and ambushed Danny while he was parked at a school bus stop in the dark.

•

The investigation relied heavily on the 'rumor mill' in the small town, with a checkpoint yielding the tip about Tim Askins.

•

Forensic evidence was limited due to no firearm registry and the killer wearing gloves, making the license plate clue and witness tips crucial.

•

The case shows how a seemingly solid alibi (work records) can be misleading when co-workers don't actually recall seeing the person.

Notable quotes

“he saw there were a whole bunch of numbers and letters written on Danny's skin. And as he looked at it, Howard realized it was a license plate number.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:01

“This does not look good for Justin.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:41

“If Danny hadn't slept with another man's wife, he'd still be alive.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:16

“this gun was the actual weapon that was used to kill Danny Longstreet.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:34

“The killer was indeed Tim Askins, the young man that Danny had seen crash his Jeep drunk and who was now facing insurance fraud charges.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:20

“Tim Askins was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:41

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Setup: The episode opens with a man holding a muddy black plastic case outside the Higginson police station in March 1997, knowing its contents will solve a local officer's murder.

•

1:20 — Danny Longstreet's Final Morning: Officer Danny Longstreet, 39, begins his early morning shift in the tiny town of Higginson, Arkansas, population just over 300, and parks at a school bus stop on Highway 11 where he is ambushed and shot three times through the passenger window.

•

4:43 — Investigation Begins, License Plate Clue: Sergeant J.R. Howard leads the investigation, finds a shell casing in the patrol car, and discovers a license plate number written on Danny's hand, which becomes the primary lead.

•

9:39 — Dale Miller and Justin Swain: The plate is traced to Dale Miller, who says his sister's friend Justin Swain borrowed the plates weeks earlier; Swain has a history of citations and an arrest by Danny, making him a prime suspect.

•

12:24 — Justin Swain Interview: Howard confronts Swain, who admits taking the plates but claims he returned them days before the murder; Swain's girlfriend Amanda cannot account for his whereabouts at 5:20 a.m., but a friend later provides an alibi.

•

19:30 — Checkpoint Yields New Suspect Tim Askins: With Swain cleared, Howard sets up a checkpoint; a nervous driver reveals Tim Askins had a grudge against Danny after Danny witnessed Askins crash drunk and file a report leading to felony insurance fraud charges.

•

23:00 — Tim Askins Interview and Alibi: Howard questions Askins, who claims he was at work from 8 p.m. to 8 a.m.; his boss confirms the timecard, but no co-workers recall seeing him during the murder window.

•

26:17 — Breakthrough and Resolution: A man delivers the murder weapon in a muddy black case; reconstruction reveals Askins left work, was driven by his sister and brother-in-law, killed Danny, buried the gun, and returned to work; the gun's owner turned it in after noticing missing bullets; all three are convicted.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Host

⋮