TLDR
In the federal murder trial of Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell, journalist Michelle McPhee details devastating testimony from the past week. Sandra Birchmore's therapist testified she was ecstatic about her pregnancy the day before death, not suicidal. Five people contacted authorities doubting the suicide ruling, but police ignored them. Farwell's DNA was found on the ligature and Sandra's underwear. His twin brother Billy and Army Sergeant Jason Pickard also had sexual relationships with her; Pickard is the baby's father. The investigation was riddled with failures: no crime scene processing, dispatcher threw away notes, lead investigator was conflicted, and the medical examiner ruled suicide based on police claims. Farwell's own texts admit statutory rape and choking. The case exposes deep corruption in the Stoughton PD.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Matthew Farwell graduated high school with straight A's but only obtained a GED, yet was hired as a gun-carrying detective and allowed to tutor a 15-year-old girl alone in the library.
Police called Sandra's aunt and declared it a suicide before the medical examiner made any determination — a mortal sin in their Catholic faith that made the family immediately disbelieve the ruling.
Farwell was adamantly anti-mask and fought masking policies, yet wore a mask and hood only when entering Sandra's apartment building — three other women he had affairs with testified he never wore masks or acted secretively with them.
The Norfolk County DA's office claimed a 'server malfunction' in August 2024 — right when the FBI was ready to arrest Farwell — and lost all evidence; the IT director admitted he never reported the malfunction.
Lieutenant John Fanning, the lead investigator, used the dead woman's laptop to view evidence because he couldn't figure out how to open it on his own computer, compromising the chain of custody.
Sandra had no support system: her mother and grandmother were dead, her aunt gave her $10,000 and told her to live in a hotel, and the only adults in her orbit from age 13 were police officers who exploited her.
An animal control officer admitted under oath to having sex with Sandra in the animal shelter in exchange for giving her a cat.
Key takeaways
Sandra Birchmore's therapist, her emergency contact, testified Sandra was 'thrilled, ecstatic, filled with joy' about her upcoming baby the day before she died and was not suicidal, directly contradicting the defense's mental health narrative.
Five separate people — the therapist, a friend who called dispatch, three other friends, and Sandra's principal — contacted authorities saying the death was not a suicide, yet police never investigated until the FBI intervened years later.
Matthew Farwell's DNA was found on the duffel bag strap (ligature) used in Sandra's death and on her underwear; the state police never tested the ligature for DNA until the FBI took over the case years later.
Farwell's twin brother Billy Farwell, also a Stoughton officer, had sex with Sandra 10 days before her death in a parking lot despite knowing she was pregnant; he is expected to testify that Lieutenant John Fanning told him police were 'deep-sixing' the case.
Army Sergeant Jason Pickard, Sandra's recruiter, had an illegal affair with her and is the biological father of her baby; he admitted under oath he was a mandated reporter but did not report the statutory rape because he was 'afraid' of losing his family and job.
Lead investigator Lieutenant John Fanning went to high school with Farwell, played hockey with him, never should have been assigned the case, used Sandra's laptop to view evidence because he couldn't operate his own, and is now refusing to testify, likely pleading the Fifth.
Farwell's arrogance is documented in his own texts: he admitted taking Sandra's virginity at 15, referenced choking her, created a violent alter ego named 'Joey' (his son's name), and Googled 'can you revoke consent in Massachusetts' and 'can Cellebrite find deleted text messages' on his work phone the day he gave police consent to search it.
The Stoughton Police Department culture enabled corruption: multiple officers had affairs with Sandra, the dispatcher threw away notes after Farwell yelled at him, a fellow officer told a colleague to 'forget about the call,' and the chief who pushed for a real investigation was placed on administrative leave by the town manager.
Notable quotes
“She said she was very resilient. She said that she was a survivor. She said she was thrilled, ecstatic, filled with joy as a direct quote about her upcoming baby, the birth of her baby. What she wasn't, the therapist said, was suicidal.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:06“I got to put crazy back in the bag. I got to put crazy back in the bag and then everything will be all right.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:54“Me taking your virginity was the best day. I should have bleeped you when you were 14.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:48“On his work phone, he Googled, 'Can you revoke consent in Massachusetts?' Then, he said, 'Can celebrate find deleted text messages?'”
▸ Notable quotes · 34:59“We're not investigating this. This girl committed suicide. We're not investigating this. The the job, you know, the state police needs this investigation like a bleeping bullet to the head.”
▸ Notable quotes · 48:24“Sandra had nobody. Her mother was dead. Her grandmother was dead. She had no living relatives. Her aunt didn't testify... This is a girl who had nobody except for these cops who were in her orbit from the time she was 13 years old.”
▸ Notable quotes · 55:40Chapters
0:00 — Case Overview and Therapist Testimony: Brian Entin introduces the Sandra Birchmore case: a Stoughton police officer, Matthew Farwell, allegedly murdered her after a years-long sexual relationship beginning when she was 15. Michelle McPhee details the therapist's testimony — Sandra was ecstatic about her pregnancy the day before death, not suicidal.
8:00 — Five Witnesses Ignored by Police: Five people contacted authorities doubting the suicide ruling: the therapist, a friend who called dispatch, three other friends, and Sandra's principal. Police ignored all of them; the dispatcher threw away his notes after Farwell yelled at him.
18:00 — DNA Evidence and Crime Scene Failures: Farwell's DNA found on the ligature (duffel bag strap) and Sandra's underwear. Police never processed the crime scene, didn't swipe the doorknob for prints, didn't attend the autopsy, and the ME ruled suicide based solely on police claims.
24:30 — Jason Pickard and the Baby's Paternity: Army Sergeant Jason Pickard, Sandra's recruiter, had an illegal affair with her and is the biological father of her baby (confirmed by FBI in 2025). He admitted he was a mandated reporter but didn't report the statutory rape out of fear.
29:00 — The Farwell Twins and Shared Videos: Billy Farwell, Matthew's twin, also had sex with Sandra, including 10 days before her death. Videos of Sandra with Pickard were shared with the Farwell brothers. Billy is expected to testify that lead investigator Fanning told him police were burying the case.
33:30 — Farwell's Texts and Arrogance: Farwell's own texts admit statutory rape, choking, and a violent alter ego named 'Joey.' He Googled legal questions about revoking consent and recovering deleted texts on his work phone the day he gave police consent to search it.
36:00 — Police Corruption and Conflict of Interest: Lead investigator Lieutenant Fanning was Farwell's high school classmate and hockey teammate. Multiple Stoughton officers had affairs with Sandra. The chief who pushed for a real investigation was placed on leave. A fellow officer said 'forget about the call.'
49:00 — Defense Strategy and Trial Outlook: Defense may try to introduce hearsay about Sandra possibly being bipolar from a doctor who treated her mother when Sandra was 9. No witness has testified Sandra was suicidal. Judge Casper runs a tight courtroom; closing arguments expected early November.
Speakers
Brian Entin — Host
Michelle McPhee — Guest Reporter