SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME REACTION – 5 YEARS LATER... Does It STILL HOLD UP?! | ROAD TO DOOMSDAY

Original Media · 1h 39m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

Two hosts watch and comment on Spider-Man: No Way Home Extended Edition in real-time, analyzing added scenes, character arcs, and the three Spider-Men dynamic. They conclude it's a near-masterpiece that holds up on rewatch, with the Green Goblin as the standout villain, while noting some underutilized villains and forced plot mechanics. They answer patron questions about future Spider-Man appearances and casting wishes.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts reveal Kevin Feige pitched them the entire Blade trilogy plan at the No Way Home premiere afterparty, with Mahershala Ali sword-training in character.

•

The Statue of Liberty climax allegedly cost the film its Chinese release, making the landmark choice a financial sacrifice.

•

Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man was originally considered for a Venom symbiote bond, hinted by his 'rageful' characterization in this film.

•

The 'More Fun Edition' includes a deleted Harry Holland cameo as a kid dodging Spider-Man's swing, cut for tone but charming.

•

Doctor Strange's willingness to cast the memory spell makes more sense viewed as 'Episode 30 of the Marvel show' rather than a standalone film gap.

•

The hosts initially loved the film uncritically (5/5) but now rate it 4.5/5, citing Electro/Lizard weaknesses and some forced comedy beats.

Key takeaways

•

The Extended Edition adds ~11 minutes, mostly in Act One, improving pacing and emotional grounding for Peter's isolation.

•

Willem Dafoe's Green Goblin is elevated as the best Spider-Man villain across all films, with a terrifying, suitless performance that surpasses the Raimi original.

•

The three Spider-Men (Holland, Maguire, Garfield) have distinct, evolved characterizations: Maguire as a wise 'youth pastor,' Garfield as a haunted big brother, Holland as the anchor.

•

Aunt May's death scene and her delivery of the 'great power/responsibility' line (correctly quoted) is the emotional peak, retroactively justifying the trilogy's setup.

•

The film works as a character-driven story first, nostalgia vehicle second; the multiverse mechanics are messy but emotionally justified.

•

Electro and Lizard are underdeveloped compared to Doc Ock and Goblin, feeling like they only work opposite Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man.

•

The hosts prefer a future film with all three Spider-Men as co-leads (ideally directed by Destin Daniel Cretton) over cameos in Secret Wars.

•

COVID constraints are visible in separated villain scenes and missing actors (Thomas Haden Church, Rhys Ifans), limiting some character work.

Notable quotes

“This is the only one of the Watts films I like from beginning to end. It's the only one of any of the movies up until this point that I don't at one point go like 'ooh, I wouldn't have done that.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 83:02

“He's such a good villain. Not because of Spider-Man 1, because of Spider-Man No Way Home. Like, he's perfect in the first Spider-Man and then he's perfect for what this one needed him to be. And it's different.”

▸ Notable quotes · 87:00

“The movie works best when there are choices where I think they did not know what to do and they only did repetition or some nostalgia. Like that's why it's not five anymore.”

▸ Notable quotes · 85:25

“She says the actual quote. She says it in a moment to protect him and she fixes 25 years of Spider-Man misquoting.”

▸ Notable quotes · 53:07

“It's not that is not a nostalgia bait performance. But yeah, definitely Electro is probably one of the bigger letdowns because of the hype of Jamie Foxx.”

▸ Notable quotes · 87:15

“I want a movie with them. I want a movie with them, but I could see them in a Spider-Verse movie. What if they do live action? I would just want the actual movie with them.”

▸ Notable quotes · 90:32

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro & Premiere Memories: Hosts introduce the Extended Edition watch-along, recall the 2021 premiere (rain, Feige's Blade pitch, Dafoe's sword training), and set expectations.

•

3:00 — Act One: Extended Scenes & Peter's Isolation: Reaction to new footage: MJ/Ned/lawyer scenes, Betty Brant, school sequences, Happy/May dynamics. Praise for improved pacing and Holland's performance.

•

20:00 — Doctor Strange & The Spell: Analysis of Strange/Peter dynamic, the botched spell logic, multiverse setup, and how binge-watching the MCU makes Strange's choice feel earned.

•

25:00 — Villain Returns: Doc Ock, Goblin, Electro, Sandman, Lizard: Breakdown of each villain's reintroduction: Molina's Doc Ock nuance, Dafoe's Goblin duality, Foxx's Electro redesign, Church/Ifans absence felt. Praise for practical Goblin stuntwork.

•

57:00 — The Three Spider-Men Unite: Maguire and Garfield enter; discussion of their evolved portrayals (Maguire as wise mentor, Garfield as haunted brother), the rooftop bonding scene, and web-shooter chemistry talk.

•

73:00 — Climax: Statue of Liberty & May's Death: Extended fight choreography, Goblin's terror without suit, May's death and correct 'responsibility' line, Holland's grief carrying through final act.

•

78:00 — Resolution & Extended Ending: Spell reversal, character goodbyes, Peter's anonymous coffee shop scene, Betty Brant graduation sign-off. Hosts debate ending effectiveness.

•

82:00 — Final Verdict & Patron Q&A: Hosts rate film 4.5/5, discuss nostalgia vs. mastery, villain highs/lows, desire for three-Spider-Men co-lead film (Cretton), and answer patron questions on Secret Wars, Uncle Ben casting, Deadpool.

Speakers

•

Greg Alba — Co-host

•

Koi — Co-host

⋮