“Gay for the Stay” & “Trains Run on Her”: Inside Mackenzie’s Prison Dating Life

Original Media · 1h 54m · English · YouTube · Rotten Mango

TLDR

This episode covers Mackenzie Shirilla's life in prison, her recorded jail calls with her mother Natalie, the bench trial that convicted her of murdering her boyfriend Dom and friend DaVon, and the family's failed appeals. Former inmates describe Ohio Reformatory for Women as unusually comfortable, where Shirilla wears full makeup, hair gems, and altered clothing daily, cooks commissary meals, and engages in prison relationships. Jail calls reveal Shirilla and her mother discussing Kim Kardashian advocacy, protests, and release plans while mocking prosecutors and victims' families. The judge sentenced her to 15 years to life (parole eligible in 2037), and the Ohio Supreme Court declined to hear her appeal. Victims' families are pushing for 'Dom and DaVon's Law' to prevent Shirilla from profiting via book deals or social media. Shirilla shows little remorse, focusing on her appearance, future modeling, and Instagram bio. Her parents promote conspiracy theories about judicial corruption involving the Russo family name. The host concludes Shirilla is unlikely to be paroled given 36 misconduct records and lack of genuine accountability. Part 5 will analyze 31,000 pages of text messages between Shirilla and Dom. The episode highlights the dissonance between Shirilla's prison 'influencer' lifestyle and the gravity of her crimes. The host and co-host express disbelief at the family's delusion and the prison's lax conditions. The case raises questions about bench trial strategy, POTS defense without medical experts, and parental enabling. The host supports the verdict and victims' families' pursuit of justice. The episode ends with a preview of the final installment covering the text message evidence.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Ohio Reformatory for Women offers three yard times per day (most prisons offer one), inmates can opt out of yard time due to weather, and the facility has a 'pregnancy cottage' that may supply waist trainers — former inmates compare it to summer camp or a college dorm.

•

Inmates can take selfies on prison tablets during video visits and send them to contacts — Cheyenne shared a prison selfie of Shirilla in full glam on TikTok, debunking rumors of contraband phones.

•

Shirilla's mother Natalie monitors her daughter's friends' Instagram followings from prison calls, pressures Shirilla to reconcile with a friend (Rosie) who may be associating with critics, and runs a group chat with Shirilla's friends — the host calls it 'running a mafia.'

•

Shirilla told her mother she wants to live in Italy, refuses to shower because 'I'm cute and little,' discusses her pubic hair length ('I could braid it'), and believes baby spinach is 'genetically modified' and 'bad for you' because 'it's a baby.'

•

Shirilla's father Steve claimed in an interview that if only DaVon (not Dom) had died, 'she wouldn't be in jail... it would have never left juvenile court' — explicitly valuing Dom's life over DaVon's due to the Russo family name.

•

The judge interrupted Natalie's statement: 'I'm hearing an awful lot about your daughter. I'm not hearing very much about the two dead people.' When Natalie called DaVon 'a new friend,' the judge asked: 'Does that mean his life is worthless?'

•

Shirilla's appeal was rejected; a second appeal was filed one day late (they blamed leap year confusion). The Ohio Supreme Court declined jurisdiction. Her next milestone is a 2037 parole hearing, but with 36 misconducts and no remorse, release is a 'very long shot.'

•

Shirilla journals daily with date/timestamp 'for a book when she gets out,' told inmates she had a modeling gig lined up pre-prison, and plans to be a 'social media influencer telling my story' — prompting victims' families to seek legislative protection against profiting.

Key takeaways

•

Ohio Reformatory for Women operates more like a college campus with cottages, multiple daily yard times, and extensive programs — former inmates describe it as surprisingly comfortable with TVs, microwaves, and freedom of movement.

•

Mackenzie Shirilla maintains a daily full-glam routine in prison (makeup, hair gems at $15 each, curling iron, waist trainer, altered clothing) funded by her parents, and walks around 'like she's going to the club' — former inmates say she acts like 'Regina George' and mocks others.

•

Shirilla's jail calls with her mother Natalie reveal a delusional dynamic: they discuss Kim Kardashian intervening, organizing protests, writing a book, modeling careers, and changing her Instagram bio to 'If they ain't hating you doing something wrong #freeKenzie' — while Shirilla asks 'Why would they keep me alive if they want me in jail?'

•

Shirilla chose a bench trial over a jury trial; her defense did not call a medical expert for her claimed POTS condition or amnesia, relying only on her mother's testimony. The host and legal analysts find this strategy baffling. She was convicted and sentenced to 15 years to life (concurrent).

•

Shirilla has 36 misconduct records in prison (wrong areas, contraband like altered clothes/shoes). Parole eligibility begins in 2037, but victims' families plan to attend every hearing. The host believes release is highly unlikely given her behavior and lack of remorse.

•

Shirilla's parents (Natalie and Steve) promote conspiracy theories: they claim Judge Russo is corrupt due to a non-existent blood relation to the Russo family, allege bribery, and Steve stated he would 'make everybody disappear' rather than save DaVon if he had a magic wand.

•

Victims' families (Dom's mother Christine Russo, DaVon's sister Divine, DaVon's parents) delivered powerful impact statements. Christine Russo called Shirilla's cries 'nothing more than a lack of remorse.' DaVon's family is pushing 'Dom and DaVon's Law' to update Ohio's Son of Sam laws to include social media profits.

•

Natalie Shirilla's sentencing statement was widely criticized: she wore a tank top, spent most time defending her own character and Shirilla's post-crash Halloween/Kid Cudi concert attendance, referred to DaVon as 'a new friend' (prompting the judge to ask 'Does that mean his life is worthless?'), and did prayer hands while asking for non-consecutive sentences.

Notable quotes

“You actually have a lot of freedom in there. There's a track. You've got a volleyball court, a basketball court, a softball field, a gym, you've got school. There's a lot of buildings and you've got a lot of free reign to kind of go into.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:13

“Thank God nothing happened to my face cuz I still want to be a model when I get out of here.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:45

“I want to live in Italy.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:35

“I dropped the soap in the shower. And I was like, 'Oh no, it's only it's a one person shower. It's only a one person shower.' But I still get scared.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:08

“Well, it's baby spinach, so it's bad for you. Because it's a baby. Baby spinach. Yes, it's genetically modified.”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:19

“I wouldn't go back and help DaVon first. I'd make everybody else into the dirt. I'd click my fingers and everybody would disappear.”

▸ Notable quotes · 79:53

“I'm hearing an awful lot about your daughter. I'm not hearing very much about the two dead people.”

▸ Notable quotes · 103:19

“Does that mean his life is worthless?”

▸ Notable quotes · 103:36

“I want them to send me messages like that. Like, I don't give a fuck. Like, I know what I did. I know what I didn't do. The only thing that I'm guilty of is driving.”

▸ Notable quotes · 106:36

“But I'm surprised she only gave me like 15. Like I thought she was going to give me like 85 years. No, I really did think she was either going to be death penalty or life in prison. No parole.”

▸ Notable quotes · 107:33

Chapters

•

0:00 — Ohio Reformatory for Women: Prison or Campus?: Former inmates describe the facility as unusually comfortable: cottages instead of cells, three daily yard times, extensive programs (GED, parenting, service dog training), and amenities like TVs, microwaves, and freedom of movement. Inmates compare it to a college campus or summer camp.

•

9:00 — Mackenzie Shirilla's Prison Life: Glamour & Popularity: Shirilla wears full makeup, $15 hair gems, curling iron, waist trainer, and altered clothing daily. She cooks commissary meals, journals for a future book, and is popular among lifers. Former inmates Cheyenne and Cat describe her as 'Regina George' — mocking others, dating multiple women ('gay for the stay'), and acting like she'll be released soon.

•

26:00 — Jail Calls: Delusion, Kim Kardashian & Instagram Bios: Recorded calls between Shirilla and her mother Natalie reveal casual conversations about Harry Potter, oatmeal, pubic hair, and Italy — mixed with delusional planning: hoping Kim Kardashian sees the case, organizing protests, writing a book, changing Instagram bio to '#freeKenzie,' and believing she'll model upon release. They mock prosecutors, the judge, and victims' families.

•

44:00 — Trial Strategy: Bench Trial & Missing Experts: Shirilla chose a bench trial. Defense called no medical expert for POTS or amnesia, only her mother. Host and legal analysts find this inexplicable. The judge convicted her of murder; she received 15 years to life concurrent. Parents allege judicial corruption due to the Russo name (no blood relation proven).

•

87:00 — Victim Impact Statements & Parental Enabling: Dom's mother Christine Russo and DaVon's family delivered powerful statements. Christine called Shirilla's tears 'lack of remorse.' DaVon's sister Divine said Shirilla 'always has the easy way out.' Natalie Shirilla wore a tank top to sentencing, defended her own character, called DaVon 'a new friend,' and did prayer hands asking for leniency. The judge rebuked her: 'I'm not hearing very much about the two dead people.'

•

109:00 — Appeals, Parole & Profiting from Crime: Appeals rejected; second appeal filed one day late (blamed leap year). Ohio Supreme Court declined review. Parole eligibility in 2037, but 36 misconducts and victims' families' opposition make release unlikely. Shirilla plans a book and influencer career; victims' families push 'Dom and DaVon's Law' to update Son of Sam laws for social media era.

Speakers

•

Host — Podcast host (Rotten Mango)

•

Co-host — Co-host / commentator

•

Mackenzie Shirilla — Convicted murderer / inmate

•

Natalie Shirilla — Mackenzie's mother

•

Steve Shirilla — Mackenzie's father

•

Cheyenne — Former inmate / TikToker

•

Cat — Former inmate

•

Juice — Former inmate

•

Christine Russo — Dominic Russo's mother

•

Divine Flanigan — DaVon Flanigan's sister

•

Judge (Russo) — Presiding judge at trial

⋮