TLDR
Mike Nellis analyzes the collapse of conservative media following the 2024 midterm elections, where Fox News lost the key 25-54 demographic to CNN on election night, Trump turned on his once-favorite network, and rival Newsmax saw its own ratings plummet 33% in the same demographic. The MAGA media ecosystem is fracturing as viewers tune out in protest.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Newsmax's prime-time 25-54 demographic audience fell to only 6,000 viewers — fewer than many independent creators reach with clips
Trump called into Fox News for his first live election night reaction despite publicly trashing the network, revealing his dependence on their platform
Republican voters didn't just stay home — many actively voted for Democrats, flipping seats in Texas and Mississippi
Fox News hosts discovered the correlation between rising diesel prices and Democratic electoral gains in real-time on air
Key takeaways
Fox News lost the election night ratings battle to CNN in the advertiser-coveted 25-54 demographic despite nearly equal total viewership
Fox hosts were in visible denial throughout election night, questioning whether Trump's campaign presence helped or hurt while results showed a blue wave
Trump publicly attacked Fox News on Truth Social, blaming the network for its 27% ratings decline and accusing it of donating to Democrats
Newsmax, positioning itself as the 'true' Trump network, saw its 25-54 demographic audience plunge 33% year-over-year to just 6,000 viewers
Conservative media figures (Loomer, Daily Wire, Charlie Kirk) are also seeing audience declines as Republican voters disengage or defect
Independent progressive media creators are filling the void as audiences seek alternatives to traditional cable news
Notable quotes
“Look, losing in politics, it's always a gut punch. Losing this bad, it's a gut punch immediately followed by an uppercut and then a roundhouse kick to the head.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:55“The map is ugly. Seats Republicans had held for years, sometimes decades, and states that have been conservative stalwarts fell to Democrats. The results in Texas alone make you want to cry.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:04“It is just really unbelievable to watch Fox News dive so much. Their ratings broke basically every record in 2024.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:03“Fox News's ratings are way down 27% because they're spending too much time covering the Trump deranged Democrats. All of those people who used to watch Fox and no longer do get it. It's them, not me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:01“6,000 viewers in their most coveted demographic. Absolutely crazy.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:40“You can't gaslight people into believing that the economy is strong. You can't gaslight them into believing that we're winning a war that we're clearly not. People aren't buying it anymore.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:35Chapters
0:00 — Introduction: Fox News in Meltdown: Jack Coarella introduces Mike Nellis to discuss the conservative media collapse after the 2024 midterms, where Fox News hosts are distraught and lacking talking points amid MAGA civil war.
2:08 — Fox News Ratings Collapse on Election Night: Daily Beast reporting shows Fox lost the 25-54 demographic to CNN by wide margins on election night, with CNN more than doubling Fox in the 10 p.m. hour despite similar total viewership.
3:48 — Fox Hosts Caught in Denial During Coverage: Compilation shows Fox hosts questioning whether Trump's campaign presence helped or hurt, fixating on gas prices while early results showed a blue wave, revealing their disconnect from reality.
7:50 — Trump Turns on Fox News: Trump attacks Fox on Truth Social, blaming the network for ratings declines, claiming 99% Republican approval, and accusing Fox Corp of donating to Democrats — while still calling into Fox for his first live reaction.
9:12 — Newsmax Also Imploding: Newsmax's 25-54 demographic audience plunged 33% to just 6,000 viewers; Greg Kelly attacks Fox hosts as 'too rich to care,' revealing MAGA-on-MAGA infighting as both networks bleed viewers.
12:02 — Independent Media Rising as Alternative: Republican voters tuned out conservative media in protest, many voting for Democrats; independent progressive creators (Nellis, Coarella, Mauch, Cohen) are gaining traction as the MAGA media apparatus weakens.
Speakers
Jack Coarella — Host
Mike Nellis — Guest Host / Political Strategist
Laura Ingraham — Fox News Host (clip)
Donald Trump — Former President (clip)
Greg Kelly — Newsmax Host (clip)