TLDR
The panel discusses two major NFL injuries from the same play in Munich: Patriots quarterback Drake Maye's potential ankle fracture and Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson's torn ACL. They conclude Maye's loss is more devastating for New England given the quarterback position's importance and the Patriots' lack of a viable backup, while Detroit's elite offense can survive Hutchinson's absence in the regular season but their playoff defense suffers significantly.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Hutchinson's ACL tear happened on a relatively mild celebration (just jumping up), not an excessive one like a backflip.
The Patriots were 3-0 against losing teams but only 2-5 against winning teams, revealing they are not as competitive as their overall record suggested.
AJ Brown suffered a hamstring injury on the same day as Maye's ankle injury, further crippling New England's offense.
Key takeaways
Drake Maye's potential season-ending ankle fracture is more impactful than Hutchinson's ACL tear because quarterback is the most critical position and the Patriots have no experienced backup after 43 straight starts by Maye.
The Patriots' problems extend beyond Maye's injury: they are 2-5 against winning teams, their defense has given up 35+ points in recent games, and AJ Brown's hamstring injury compounds their offensive struggles.
Detroit's offense featuring Amon-Ra St. Brown, Jahmyr Gibbs, and Jared Goff is prolific enough to withstand Hutchinson's loss through the regular season and into the playoffs.
Hutchinson's torn ACL occurred on a mild celebration — simply jumping up after a sack — illustrating how any minor movement can end a season and serving as a warning to players about celebration risks.
Without Hutchinson, the Lions lack a premier pass rusher for the playoffs where they will face elite quarterbacks, similar to how the Cowboys miss Micah Parsons' pressure.
The Patriots have not needed a backup quarterback in over two seasons (43 straight starts), leaving them unprepared with Tommy DeVito as the likely starter.
Notable quotes
“there's no way we can ever say we certainly I wouldn't say that uh uh a pass rusher is more important than the quarterback”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:49“This guy was the runner up and MVP like last year. So to act like he him missing is not going to affect this football team. It's just absolutely crazy.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:38“That offense has a triplet that was as good as the triplet we had... St. Brown and and and Gibbs, those are bad boys.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:16“Anything. I don't know why John Harbaugh allows that. I don't know why he doesn't speak up against that stuff. I don't want to see a guy that's so key to our success in Scataboo being out because he does a backflip.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:01“You know, the slightest tweak can end your season. Find a way to celebrate without endangering yourself, please.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:25“43 straight start starts. So, New England is not comfortable with a backup quarterback. They haven't had to use one in a really long time.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:05Chapters
0:00 — Both injuries announced: The episode opens with news that Patriots QB Drake Maye potentially fractured his ankle and Lions DE Aidan Hutchinson tore his ACL on the same play in Munich.
0:39 — Debate: Which injury is more impactful?: The panel debates whether Maye's or Hutchinson's absence hurts their team more, concluding quarterback loss is more devastating despite Hutchinson's elite pass-rushing value.
2:02 — Patriots' broader struggles: Discussion of New England's 2-5 record against winning teams, defensive regression, and AJ Brown's failed acquisition due to injuries.
2:35 — Lions' offense vs defense impact: Analysis of whether Detroit's elite offense can survive without Hutchinson, and how his loss affects their playoff pass rush against top quarterbacks.
3:37 — Celebration injury warning: Stephen A. Smith and Michael Irvin emphasize how Hutchinson's mild celebration caused a season-ending injury, urging players to avoid risky celebrations.
7:03 — Backup quarterback situation: The Patriots face Tommy DeVito at quarterback after 43 straight starts by Maye, leaving them unprepared for backup play.
Speakers
Stephen A. Smith — Host
Michael Irvin — Analyst
Irv — Co-host