British Food, Innit? | Culinary Crimes

Original Media · 45m · English · YouTube · Smosh Pit

TLDR

In this episode of Smosh's "Culinary Crimes," host Courtney Miller and guests Angela Giarratana and Tommy Pope investigate three British recipes ruined by home cooks' substitutions: Scotch eggs coated in pork rinds instead of breadcrumbs, bangers and mash made with ground turkey and green beans mixed into garlic mashed potatoes, and bread pudding soaked in a salad dressing of orange juice, Dijon, honey, ginger, and yogurt. The trio taste each culinary crime alongside the authentic versions, reacting with horror, confusion, and occasional grudging respect for the logic behind the swaps.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Pork rinds rehydrate into something resembling pig skin when fried against sausage, creating a 'meat recognizing meat' effect that the hosts find more disturbing than the substitution itself.

•

The bangers and mash crime comment from 2008 has only one upvote after nearly 20 years, suggesting even the commenter's son — who 'loved it' — didn't bother to upvote his parent's creation.

•

The bread pudding criminal made a salad dressing (OJ, Dijon, honey, ginger, yogurt) for a salad, decided it was 'perfect as a sauce,' and poured it over a sweet dessert — a leap of logic that genuinely baffles the hosts.

•

Oat milk in bread pudding contributes to the curdling disaster when combined with the acidic orange juice dressing, turning the custard into something the crew member Ollie compares to sour cream with lemon and bubbles.

Key takeaways

•

The pork rind Scotch egg substitution creates a 'meat on meat on meat' experience where the rinds rehydrate into pig skin during frying, producing a texture the hosts find deeply unsettling despite its low-carb logic.

•

The bangers and mash crime replaces beef sausage links with dry ground turkey and folds green beans into garlic mashed potatoes, resulting in a dish the hosts agree is technically edible but unrecognizable as the classic comfort food.

•

The bread pudding disaster adds an extra egg, oat milk, cinnamon, and cranraisins, then tops it with a sauce made from orange juice, Dijon mustard, honey, ginger, and plain yogurt — a combination that curdles instantly and tastes like 'milk and Windex with a shooter of Sprite.'

•

Tasting the authentic versions after the crimes highlights how British comfort food relies on simplicity: proper Scotch eggs need only breadcrumbs to highlight the sausage, bangers and mash works because of the sausage-gravy-potato trio, and bread pudding is essentially a sweet, eggy French toast casserole.

•

The hosts' sentencing humor escalates from 'every night your partner turns into a pig for 10 seconds' for the pork rind offender to an electric chair with an IV bag of ranch, Thousand Island, honey, and 'a big pile of poop' for the bread pudding criminal.

•

Despite the grotesque substitutions, the hosts acknowledge that some swaps (like pork rinds for breadcrumbs) follow a twisted internal logic — matching protein to protein — even if the result is viscerally wrong.

•

The episode reveals how recipe comment sections become archives of culinary chaos, with the bangers and mash crime dating back to a 2008 comment that earned only one upvote (likely from the commenter's son).

•

Courtney, Angela, and Tommy conclude by defending British cuisine against TikTok's mockery, encouraging viewers to seek out authentic versions at a proper English pub rather than judging by these crimes.

Notable quotes

“It's like if you got milk and Windex and a little bit Sprite.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:20

“They're like, 'Follow me down this road. Don't kill me.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:33

“This is like half-and-half but you, like, pissed 7UP into it or something.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:38

“Every night before they go to bed when they kiss their partner goodnight, their partner turns into a pig for like 10 seconds.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:49

“I had just made a light dressing for a salad and it was perfect as a sauce: OJ, Dijon, honey, ginger, and yogurt.”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:00

“It's night and it's night. And they don't even know each other exists, and it's night.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:23

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro & Guest Credentials: Courtney introduces the British foods episode of Culinary Crimes with guests Angela Giarratana and Tommy Pope, who present humorous fake credentials involving pine cones and badges.

•

3:36 — Case 1: Scotch Eggs with Pork Rinds: The first crime substitutes pork rinds for breadcrumbs on Scotch eggs to make them low-carb; the hosts taste the evidence, identify the pork rinds, and are horrified by the rehydrated pig skin texture.

•

10:16 — Verdict & Real Scotch Eggs: The verdict confirms pork rinds; the hosts taste authentic Scotch eggs with breadcrumbs and aioli, declaring them vastly superior and sentencing the offender to nightly pig transformations.

•

13:28 — Case 2: Bangers and Mash with Ground Turkey: A 2008 recipe comment reveals ground turkey replacing sausage links, green beans layered into garlic mashed potatoes; the hosts identify the dry turkey and mixed vegetables before the verdict.

•

19:28 — Verdict & Real Bangers and Mash: The verdict confirms the substitutions; the hosts taste proper bangers and mash, find it bland but inoffensive, and decide the crime and original recipe are 'ships in the night' — both unremarkable.

•

24:08 — Case 3: Bread Pudding with Salad Dressing Sauce: The most chaotic crime: extra egg, oat milk, cinnamon, cranraisins, and a sauce of orange juice, Dijon, honey, ginger, and yogurt; the hosts taste the curdled disaster and struggle to identify the sauce components.

•

39:28 — Verdict & Real Bread Pudding: The verdict reveals the full dressing recipe; the hosts taste proper bread pudding (simple, eggy, lightly sweet) and sentence the offender to an electric chair with an IV of ranch, Thousand Island, honey, and poop.

•

44:03 — Wrap-Up & Defense of British Food: The hosts defend British cuisine against TikTok mockery, encourage trying authentic versions at a pub, and sign off with calls to submit more culinary crimes via Reddit.

Speakers

•

Courtney — Host

•

Angela — Guest

•

Tommy — Guest

•

Ollie — Crew

⋮