My Property Isn't Normal | Creep Cast

Original Media · 3h 20m · English · YouTube · CreepCast

TLDR

Creepcast hosts Isaiah and Hunter read and react to the 9-part Reddit horror series "My Property Isn't Normal" by Murderbird17. The story follows Cole, a man living alone on a wilderness property besieged by derivative monsters (skinwalkers, Slender Man, stair anomalies, cultists) while aided by a "Lady in the Tree" and a monster-hunter named Mark who the hosts imagine as Mark Wahlberg. The hosts relentlessly mock the story's clichéd writing, inconsistent logic, "Reddit chungus" humor, and protagonist they envision as a morbidly obese fantasist, while occasionally finding unintentional comedy in its absurdity.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts explicitly imagine the protagonist as morbidly obese and socially inept based solely on textual clues like "Bear Grylls survival knife from Walmart" and losing a chase after 30 seconds.

•

A skinwalker imitates a dead soldier with "FAILURE" written on his forehead to provoke Cole, who shoots at it out of stolen-valor outrage — a moment the hosts call the story's only genuine emotional hook.

•

The monster power-level system is literally "how many unnamed adult men it could kill before being overwhelmed," making a killet (dog-sized) a Level 107 threat.

•

The Lady in the Tree's skeleton is made of painted wood, and her magic nets have runes that glow blue then red when activated by spoken "magic words" the protagonist doesn't remember learning.

•

The finale's logic puzzle — identifying the real Mark by asking how Cole made the Taliban flee — is solved because the fake Mark (Skinny) answers with the tall-man tentacle story instead of the naked-charge inside joke.

Key takeaways

•

The story stitches together well-known creepypasta tropes — skinwalkers, stairs in the woods, Slender Man, the Rake-like "pales" — without adding original mythology, making it feel like a greatest-hits compilation rather than a cohesive narrative.

•

The protagonist Cole constantly undermines tension by reacting to supernatural threats with video-game logic (cartwheeling naked man, net-fearing pales, magic-word defeats) and self-aware quips that the hosts argue reveal the author's lack of outdoor experience.

•

Mark, introduced in Part 4 as a monster-hunter from a shadowy organization, becomes a mouthpiece for exposition (level system, gnat rounds, curse mechanics) and a vehicle for the hosts' running Mark Wahlberg impression, which they find funnier than the story itself.

•

The "Lady in the Tree" is retroactively revealed as a Native American medicine woman who cursed Skinny at the cost of her life, but her earlier helpful actions (magic gun, healed eardrum, antivenom) are explained through contrived wood-skeleton and glowing-net mechanisms.

•

Skinny's defeat hinges on an inside joke — Cole stripping naked and charging him — which the hosts cite as the ultimate example of the story's refusal to take its own stakes seriously.

•

The hosts' commentary becomes the primary entertainment: they construct a detailed mental image of Cole as a 300-pound, fedora-wearing Discord moderator whose "woods" are a delusion, and they treat the reading as a endurance trial rather than horror narration.

•

Sponsor reads for Factor meals and Tushy bidets devolve into improvised scatological comedy that lasts several minutes, illustrating the podcast's loose, personality-driven format.

•

A planned prequel from Mark's perspective is teased at the end but abandoned when the hosts realize it would require disclosing classified operations, prompting them to end the episode abruptly.

Notable quotes

“I think that considering the way Harry propped this story up for us and the fact that I go to the Reddit account, this is the only story they've posted and their profile picture is a rubber duck. Um, I don't know. I don't know about a lot of things.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:00

“The quirky chungus thing where it's supposed to be like it's supposed to be kind of like cute or something, you know, because I agree. I guess that's true cuz there's stories that do it effectively where you're like, "Oh, that's kind of fun."”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:28

“I'm not a badass. And I'm not trying to sound cool or tough. But ever since something happened 3 years ago, same event that caused me to move out here, I don't respond to situations the same anymore. Maybe I'm not scared of death anymore. Maybe I'm mentally unstable. Maybe Gosh, maybe I'm weird.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:08

“One man equals level one man is equal to one level. That is so stupid. All right, we've calculated that it's 107 men. It could kill 107 men to take one down, bro.”

▸ Notable quotes · 116:18

“Go fuck yourself. In a deep voice, then as the smoke that swallowed him was blown away by a breeze, he was gone. Pretty anticlimactic, right? Go fuck yourself.”

▸ Notable quotes · 191:57

“I really just wanted Mark to believe that I was dumb enough to put his life on the line for something that Skinny could have easily heard had he been eavesdropping at the right time. Serves him right for basically calling me a dumbass earlier.”

▸ Notable quotes · 193:27

Chapters

•

0:15 — Intro & Expectations: Hosts discuss the heavily requested story, its Reddit author (Murderbird17, rubber-duck avatar), and their dread of "quirky chungus" horror tropes.

•

7:51 — Reading Part 1: Cole moves to wilderness property; encounters naked man saying "mama," stabs him, man cartwheels away crying like a baby. Hosts mock the tone immediately.

•

23:30 — Sponsor Breaks & Banter: Factor and Tushy ad reads dissolve into extended scatological improv; hosts discuss Discord-mod theory of protagonist.

•

28:30 — Reading Part 2 (Camo & Lady in Tree): Camo traps Cole with rope snare; Cole shoots him with 45. Lady in Tree revealed as helper who fixed eardrum and left magic gun. Hosts note inconsistencies.

•

44:30 — Reading Part 3 (Pales & Organization): Pales (crawling humanoids) fear nylon nets. Organization emails Cole about killet; Mark and team arrive. Hosts imagine Mark as Mark Wahlberg.

•

59:00 — Reading Part 4-5 (Mark the Monster Hunter): Mark moves in; reveals organization uses Cole as survival test subject. Magic bullets (gnat rounds) explained. Level system = men killed. Ghost preacher possesses Mark.

•

77:00 — Reading Part 6-7 (Stairs, Tall Man, Possession): Stairs in woods appear; Mark loses toenails climbing them. Tall Man (Slender Man) with tentacles attacks; Cole cuts tentacle. Ghost preacher possesses Mark, reveals hell portal, Skinny is demon amalgamation.

•

100:00 — Reading Part 8-9 (Baby Doll Spider, Finale): Cult's summoning rituals created monsters. Lady in Tree (Native American woman) died cursing Skinny. Baby Doll Spider defeated with rune net. Skinny tricked via inside-joke magic words. Drunk-driving hospital ending.

Speakers

•

Isaiah — Co-host

•

Hunter — Co-host

•

Harry — Producer/Editor

⋮