Bringing Extinct Species Back to Life | Dr. Beth Shapiro

Original Media · 2h 16m · English · YouTube · Andrew Huberman

TLDR

Dr. Beth Shapiro explains how Colossal Biosciences uses ancient DNA and synthetic biology to engineer extinct traits — like those of the dire wolf, woolly mammoth, and dodo — into living relatives, aiming to restore lost ecological functions and develop tools that also prevent living species from going extinct. She discusses species concepts, Neanderthal DNA in humans, the black-footed ferret genetic rescue, ethical frameworks for de-extinction and human genetic editing, and emerging technologies like artificial wombs.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Over 90% of the Neanderthal genome survives in modern humans, just distributed across different people.

•

Dire wolves were engineered using safe, known coat-color variants from living dogs and wolves rather than the exact extinct variants, to avoid health risks like albinism and deafness.

•

The black-footed ferret population was revived from a single male (Scarface) and later augmented by cloning from 40-year-old frozen tissue unrelated to the founding lineage.

•

The dodo genome came from a specimen that traveled to Europe alive in the 1600s, because DNA degrades too quickly in Mauritius' tropical climate for bones there to yield usable DNA.

•

Mammoths and Asian elephants are more closely related to each other than Asian elephants are to African elephants.

•

Channel Island foxes have almost zero genetic diversity yet are healthy, showing that long-term small populations can purge deleterious alleles.

Key takeaways

•

Species is a human conceptual tool, not a biological reality; different species concepts (biological, genetic, geographic) serve different scientific and conservation purposes.

•

Ancient DNA shows that 2–5% of modern human DNA is Neanderthal, but the specific segments differ between individuals; collectively, over 90% of the Neanderthal genome persists in living humans today.

•

De-extinction projects engineer a small number of key genetic changes (e.g., 20 edits for dire wolves) into a living relative's genome to recreate extinct phenotypes and ecological roles, not to produce exact genetic replicas.

•

The same synthetic biology toolkit — multiplex genome editing, cloning, iPS cells — developed for de-extinction is directly applied to conserve endangered species, such as cloning black-footed ferrets from 40-year-old frozen tissue to restore genetic diversity and engineering plague resistance.

•

Reintroducing large herbivores (mammoths) or apex predators (thylacines) can restabilize ecosystems by restoring lost ecological interactions, as demonstrated by wolf reintroduction in Yellowstone.

•

Human genetic selection already occurs through mate choice and IVF embryo screening; CRISPR-based therapies (e.g., curing a baby's urea cycle disorder) show therapeutic promise, but trait enhancement raises profound ethical questions about autonomy and equity.

•

Artificial wombs are being developed to gestate de-extinct animals without surrogate mothers, with potential human medical applications including preterm birth support and allowing maternal cancer treatment during pregnancy.

•

Public awe and engagement (e.g., with dire wolves) drive funding and talent toward conservation technology, but responsible deployment requires transparent dialogue with local stakeholders, regulatory oversight, and staged ecological risk assessments.

Notable quotes

“Biology doesn't care what species you are. Species is a human concept.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:51

“We are not trying to make something that is identical to a particular individual that used to be alive. Our mammoths are millions of letters of DNA code different from each other.”

▸ Notable quotes · 53:54

“If it looks like a direwolf and it's able to fill the niche of a direwolf, I'm happy to call it a direwolf.”

▸ Notable quotes · 57:02

“The answer is we are doing both. It is the same tools. It's the same technology. It's the same needs.”

▸ Notable quotes · 73:35

“Doing nothing is not not deciding. Doing nothing is saying we accept the fact that we are going to have a future that is less biodiverse than the present.”

▸ Notable quotes · 85:38

“We are facing a future that I think is really exciting and spectacular, maybe a little bit scary, but I think as long as we keep talking about it and having conversations about it way before it's possible, we can get to a place that people are comfortable with and people are excited about.”

▸ Notable quotes · 117:22

Chapters

•

0:52 — Introduction & Species Concepts: Huberman introduces Shapiro; they discuss what defines a species, the difference between taxonomy and species concepts, and the bison/buffalo naming history.

•

7:58 — Neanderthal DNA & Human Evolution: Shapiro explains Neanderthal interbreeding with modern humans, the 2–5% Neanderthal DNA in living people, and how ancient DNA narrows the search for uniquely human genetic changes.

•

56:42 — De-extinction Technology & Dire Wolves: Shapiro details the dire wolf project: 20 edits in the gray wolf genome based on fossil DNA, trait selection for size, coat color, and robustness, and safety considerations to avoid deleterious effects.

•

36:10 — Woolly Mammoths & Ecological Restoration: Discussion of mammoth de-extinction, Pleistocene Park, and how large herbivores engineer ecosystems by disturbing snow and vegetation to increase plant diversity and carbon sequestration.

•

98:24 — Black-footed Ferret Genetic Rescue: Story of the ferret's near-extinction, cloning from frozen tissue to restore genetic diversity, and engineering plague resistance using synthetic biology.

•

89:16 — Ethics, Public Perception & Human Genetic Editing: Conversation on ethical frameworks, IVF embryo screening, the CRISPR baby controversy, and the inevitability of human genetic modification for disease prevention and potential enhancement.

•

115:10 — Artificial Wombs & Future Technologies: Development of artificial wombs for mammoth gestation without elephant surrogates, with potential human medical applications like preterm birth support and maternal cancer treatment during pregnancy.

•

124:30 — Science Communication & Personal Journey: Shapiro's background from broadcast journalism to ancient DNA, the importance of public engagement and awe, and her move from academia to Colossal Biosciences to scale conservation impact.

Speakers

•

Andrew Huberman — Host

•

Beth Shapiro — Guest

⋮