I’m Sorry Jacob Elordi

Original Media · 59m · English · YouTube · BroskiReport

TLDR

Brittany Broski discusses her obsession with Guillermo del Toro's 2022 Frankenstein film, exploring the novel's origins in Mary Shelley's 1816 Geneva ghost-story contest, the Promethean theme of science outpacing morality, and the movie's portrayal of the creature as innocence corrupted by human cruelty. She connects the story to modern reanimation research (Yale pig-brain experiments, Alvin Lucier's brain organoids composing music), reflects on literature's accessibility, and argues the true villain is generational trauma and humanity's capacity for cruelty.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A 2011 stem-cell-grown windpipe transplant (Tejlas and Beyene) already realized a concept 'beyond the creativity of Frankenstein.'

•

Alvin Lucier's post-mortem brain organoids not only generate music but receive audience sound as electrical feedback, potentially 'learning' over time.

•

The phrase 'the exception that proves the rule' originally meant an exception confirms a general rule exists (e.g., 'No parking Tuesday' implies parking is allowed other days), not that exceptions invalidate rules.

Key takeaways

•

Guillermo del Toro's Frankenstein (2022) reframes the creature as innocence personified, using color symbolism — red for Victor's lingering maternal softness, white-to-black for the creature's corruption — to explore father-son trauma and the impossibility of preserving innocence in a cruel world.

•

Mary Shelley wrote Frankenstein at 18 during a 1816 Swiss holiday with Percy Shelley, Lord Byron, and others; the novel emerged from a ghost-story contest and embodies Romantic-era anxiety about science outpacing morality, a concern Broski traces from Prometheus to Oppenheimer to AI.

•

Classic literature feels intimidating but is fundamentally human — Shelley, Byron, and Percy were messy young people who died of treatable fevers; recognizing their humanity makes works like Frankenstein accessible rather than academic.

•

Modern science approaches Frankenstein's premise: Yale's 2019 BrainEx system restored cellular function in 32 dead pig brains, and researchers grew composer Alvin Lucier's stem cells into cerebral organoids that generate music in real time, blurring lines between life, death, and creativity.

•

Broski argues creativity cannot exist outside a living human body — the Lucier organoids produce sound but lack a translating consciousness; the project is science masquerading as art, raising ethical questions about consent, authorship, and the definition of death.

•

The real villain in Frankenstein is not Victor or the creature but generational trauma and humanity's innate capacity for cruelty; we each harbor a Cerberus of ugly impulses we must constantly chain, and the story holds a mirror to that internal war.

Notable quotes

“Frankenstein is the best movie that's ever BEEN MADE IN MY OPINION.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:12

“There is no moral guidepost that teaches you what to do with these scientific discoveries.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:59

“A powerful man will find out how to use it to cause destruction and suffering. That is an inevitability.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:46

“These were just normal people who had an idea and thought to write it down and look at the lasting impact that it had.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:39

“The creature is innocence personified. That's how I saw it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:31

“Creativity doesn't exist outside of the human body in the sense that we're talking about it as in a creation, not as in nature.”

▸ Notable quotes · 47:47

Chapters

•

0:05 — Intro & Beluga Brain: Broski opens with self-deprecating humor about her 'beluga whale' forehead sensation from caffeine and cortisol, mentions her PCOS diagnosis, and sets up the episode's focus on Frankenstein.

•

5:09 — Prometheus & Science vs. Morality: Explains the Prometheus myth as Frankenstein's subtitle 'The Modern Prometheus'; connects the theft of fire to modern dilemmas where scientific breakthroughs (atomic bomb, AI, CRISPR) lack ethical frameworks.

•

11:07 — Mary Shelley's Geneva Origin Story: Recounts the 1816 Lake Geneva gathering — Mary Godwin, Percy Shelley, Lord Byron, Dr. Polidori, Claire Clairmont — where a ghost-story contest produced Frankenstein; details the group's scandalous relationships and early deaths.

•

14:43 — Literature as Human Stories: Argues classic novels are approachable because they come from flawed humans; shares personal journey from academic intimidation to seeing Shelley, Byron, and others as relatable young creatives.

•

18:42 — Del Toro's Frankenstein: Film Analysis: Deep dive into the 2022 film: Oscar Isaac's mad-genius Victor, Jacob Elordi's creature, Mia Goth's Elizabeth, Christoph Waltz as patron (no Igor); color symbolism (red maternal thread, creature's white-to-black arc); themes of generational trauma, forgiveness, and innocence corrupted.

•

39:08 — Reanimation Science Today: Covers Yale's 2019 pig-brain cellular revival via BrainEx, Alexis Carrel's early tissue culture, 2011 stem-cell windpipe transplant, and the Alvin Lucier brain-organoid art installation that composes music post-mortem.

•

44:16 — Creativity, Ethics & Rules: Debates whether creativity can exist outside a human body (says no), dissects 'exception proves the rule' via 1984 parking analogy, and links to societal need for rules with exceptions.

•

53:12 — The Real Villain & Songs of the Week: Concludes that generational trauma and humanity's internal Cerberus are the true villains; recommends 'Space Age Lounge' playlist and plugs Patreon/merch.

Speakers

•

Brittany Broski — Host

⋮