TLDR
This episode compiles ten baffling true crime and disappearance cases, ranging from the solved murder of Angela Spenshaw in Rhode Island to the Tokyo subway sarin attack by the Aum Shinrikyo cult, and multiple 'Missing 411' cases where people vanished under inexplicable circumstances in wilderness areas across North America.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Tokyo sarin attackers were not marginalized fanatics but elite professionals — a surgeon, a physicist, and other highly educated individuals — who willingly carried out mass murder for their cult leader.
In the Angela Spenshaw case, the killer's attempt to destroy evidence (hiding his shoes) is what led his own girlfriend to turn him in, and the shoe prints at the scene didn't even match his shoes.
Aaron Hedges, an expert hunter who knew the Crazy Mountains intimately, missed an obvious trail fork, walked miles the wrong way along a creek, then was found 6 miles away at a location with a clear view of safety, having left all survival gear behind.
The Pilkington family's encounter involved creatures that displayed apparent intelligence: they communicated, coordinated, attempted to breach the house via the roof, and waited patiently for the family to emerge.
Robert Winters, a 78-year-old experienced logger, allegedly climbed nearly 2,000 feet in elevation during a blizzard — contrary to all survival training — and his clothes were found neatly stacked with no remains nearby.
Key takeaways
The Angela Spenshaw murder was solved through DNA evidence after the killer, construction worker Jeremy Motyka, tried to hide his shoes, making his girlfriend suspicious.
The 1995 Tokyo subway sarin attack was carried out by highly educated members of the Aum Shinrikyo doomsday cult, including a surgeon, who believed they were triggering World War III.
Multiple 'Missing 411' cases share eerie patterns: experienced outdoorspeople making irrational decisions (like climbing elevation in storms), bodies found far from where they disappeared with missing clothing/footwear, and searches yielding no tracks or evidence.
In several cases, victims were found with clothes neatly folded or placed, suggesting deliberate removal rather than animal scavenging or hypothermia-induced paradoxical undressing.
The Eric Martin family in Maine reported a night-long siege by five 8-foot-tall wolf-like creatures that stood bipedally, communicated, and attempted coordinated entry into their home.
Connie Johnson, a 76-year-old former wilderness ranger with expert survival skills, vanished from a remote Idaho camp along with her dog, which returned 15 miles away weeks later.
Terrence Woods, a 27-year-old filmmaker, suddenly sprinted down a cliff and into dense forest during a shoot, evading a massive search with helicopters, dogs, and infrared technology.
Dr. Katherine Wong disappeared from a populated ski resort on an easy trail; her remains were found four months later in a steep, inaccessible ravine half a mile away with no tracks leading there.
Notable quotes
“It was like somebody had cut a doorway into her home, but had not fit it with a door yet. It was just like a gap on the wall of her house. You could walk right inside.”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:34“Mission accomplished.”
▸ Notable quotes · 58:58“He was sprinting down the hill, not saying a word, not looking up, running at full speed down the hill into the forest.”
▸ Notable quotes · 74:10“The creature stands on its two legs. It gets on its hind legs and looks at her. And Shelley gasps and falls over because the creature's like 8 ft tall.”
▸ Notable quotes · 90:28“It seems very unlikely that Robert, who was a skilled outdoorsman, who had hunted this particular area for 20 years, and had agreed with his sons that it was a bad idea to go up in elevation because of the storm, defied all of that and went almost 2,000 ft up in elevation, removed his clothes neatly and put them on the ground next to a tree, and then vanished without a trace.”
▸ Notable quotes · 101:35Chapters
0:00 — Angela Spenshaw Murder (Little Compton, RI, 1999): 66-year-old Angela Spenshaw is found beaten, sexually assaulted, and electrocuted in her bathtub. Investigation reveals entry via an unfinished sunroom door. Construction worker Jeremy Motyka is convicted after his girlfriend turns in his hidden shoes and his DNA matches semen evidence.
30:16 — Tokyo Subway Sarin Attack (1995): Aum Shinrikyo cult members, including a surgeon, release sarin gas on five subway trains, killing 13 and injuring 5,000. Cult leader Shoko Asahara and 123 members receive death penalties; the surgeon gets life for cooperating.
62:27 — Aaron Hedges Disappearance (Montana, 2014): Expert hunter Aaron Hedges vanishes in the Crazy Mountains after taking a wrong turn. His boots and a campfire are found miles off course; 9 months later his backpack appears 6 miles away with a view of safety; a year later his skull is found but no cause of death determined.
71:38 — Terrence Woods & Connie Johnson Disappearances (Idaho, 2018): On the same day, filmmaker Terrence Woods sprints off a cliff into wilderness and vanishes despite massive search; 56 miles away, 76-year-old wilderness expert Connie Johnson disappears from a remote camp, her dog returning 15 miles away weeks later.
77:36 — William Pilkington Disappearance (Vancouver Island, 2008): 7-year-old William vanishes from a beach in Tofino in one minute while his father's back is turned. Exhaustive search of forest and coastline finds no trace; he is never found.
80:28 — Eric Martin Family Creature Encounter (Maine, 2005-2006): Family experiences escalating strange events: lights in woods, a constructed den, silent wildlife, and finally a night-long siege by five 8-foot bipedal wolf-like creatures that communicate, attempt entry via roof, and surround the house.
98:01 — Robert Winters Disappearance (Oregon, 1969): 78-year-old experienced logger vanishes during hunting trip. Helicopter spots tracks at 7,100 ft (2,000 ft above camp) but discounted. Nine months later his neatly stacked clothes and rifle found at that elevation; dentures found a year later; no remains ever located.
102:10 — Dr. Katherine Wong Disappearance (California, 1999): Pediatrician vanishes from easy ski trail at Bear Valley. Massive search finds no tracks off trails. Four months later remains found in steep, inaccessible ravine half-mile away with bones scattered over quarter-mile; no tracks leading there.
106:18 — Corey Fay Disappearance (Oregon, 1991): 17-year-old with survival training vanishes during elk hunt. Massive 12-square-mile search with top dogs finds nothing. Ten months later his gear found 10 miles away and 3,000 ft up in waist-deep snow; only bone fragments and a tooth recovered.
Speakers
Narrator — Host