TLDR
Four progressive commentators discuss key Senate races on election day, expressing nervous optimism about Democratic chances in Maine, South Carolina, Michigan, Texas, Kansas, Iowa, Ohio, and Alaska. They frame several races as referendums on corporate Democrats and MAGA extremism, highlight the impact of anti-trans fear-mongering funded by Elon Musk and big oil, and emphasize women's reproductive rights as central to the election.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Elon Musk funds massive anti-trans advertising campaigns despite having a trans daughter, Vivian, whom he publicly declares "dead" rather than maintaining a relationship with her.
Ken Paxton's wife divorced him on "biblical grounds," and even Donald Trump — his chief supporter — publicly calls Paxton ugly.
The "secret voter" phenomenon may have reversed: instead of secret Trump voters, there may now be secret Democratic voters offsetting them.
Iowa farmers who bought into Trump are now openly saying on camera that his tariffs are costing them money and "he just ain't doing it."
When MSNBC interviewed actual Alaska voters about the two-Dan-Sullivan ballot, every single one said it was not confusing because party labels and incumbent status are clearly marked.
Key takeaways
In Maine, Troy Jackson leads Susan Collins by six points in recent polling despite questions about integrating the previous candidate Graham Platner's grassroots infrastructure, and Collins' votes for Kavanaugh and Trump have harmed women in red states while Maine's blue state government protects its own residents.
South Carolina Republicans have spent $300 million on anti-trans advertisements against Annie Andrews, which the hosts call a completely manufactured non-issue funded by Elon Musk and big oil executives to distract from policy failures.
The Michigan Democratic primary between Abdul El-Sayed and Haley Stevens represents a battle for the party's future, with $55 million from pro-Israel super PACs spent against El-Sayed, and corporate Democrats refusing to endorse him despite his competitive position.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton is described as perhaps the worst candidate of the cycle — facing fraud allegations, infidelity, and even Trump calling him ugly — yet Trump and Elon Musk backed him over establishment Republicans to protect their business interests.
Kansas pastor Adam Hamilton, founder of the largest United Methodist Church, is competitive in a deep red state, demonstrating that progressive candidates with authentic rural connections can challenge Republican dominance in the heartland.
Iowa farmers who previously supported Trump are turning against him due to tariffs destroying their livelihoods, with interviewed farmers stating plainly "he just ain't doing it," potentially boosting Democratic Senate chances.
The Alaska controversy over two Dan Sullivans on the ballot is dismissed as minor ("one out of 10" on the big deal scale) compared to documented Republican corruption, and actual voters tested found the ballot not confusing.
White women have voted Republican in every election since 2004, and men must actively check in with women in their lives to vote for reproductive rights, which are on the ballot in at least four states and intersect with every other issue.
Notable quotes
“The trans issue is 100% made up, just like the litter boxes and all of that”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:44“Elon Musk is a major backer of that. There's a lot of that is his money.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:03“If we can win that race, then we can shut down these Democratic leaders next time they say they say things like Schumer and others have said where they won't embrace these candidates.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:58“Centrism is a death march to losing elections, and we have to stop with these candidates that placate to their donors before they placate to their people.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:38“The generation right under me... Gen Z, like they have only existed in a politics of Donald Trump. They have never actually witnessed the Obama era.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:31“White women historically since 2004 as as uncomfortable as it is, have voted Republican, have voted for Trump.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:41Chapters
0:00 — Opening & Fox News youth clip: Hosts introduce the election day show with nervous energy, play a clip of young voters laughing at Fox News when asked about Trump, and review Fox's own power rankings showing several red states as toss-ups.
1:14 — Maine: Susan Collins vs Troy Jackson: Discussion of Troy Jackson's six-point lead over Susan Collins, the challenge of integrating Graham Platner's grassroots infrastructure, and how Collins' votes harm women in red states while Maine's blue government protects its own residents.
5:07 — South Carolina: Darlene Graham vs Annie Andrews: Analysis of the race where Lindsey Graham's sister Darlene faces Annie Andrews, with $300 million in anti-trans ads funded by Elon Musk and big oil, and the importance of Black voter turnout as an early indicator.
10:05 — Michigan: Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens: The Democratic primary framed as a referendum on corporate Democrats, with $55 million from pro-Israel super PACs against El-Sayed, and the hosts arguing his win would provide a template for progressive candidates nationwide.
15:36 — Texas: Ken Paxton race: Ken Paxton described as potentially the worst candidate of the cycle, backed by Trump and Elon Musk despite fraud allegations and ethical issues, with a win potentially triggering a 50-state Democratic strategy.
19:33 — Kansas & Iowa heartland races: Pastor Adam Hamilton's competitive race in Kansas shows progressive potential in rural areas, while Iowa farmers are turning on Trump due to tariff damage, and the Iowa governor's race could create down-ballot momentum.
21:38 — Ohio & Alaska races: Sherrod Brown favored in Ohio against Trump-endorsed John Husted, while the Alaska two-Dan-Sullivan ballot controversy is dismissed as minor compared to Republican corruption, with voters finding the ballot clear.
28:38 — Final thoughts & announcements: Charlie emphasizes women's reproductive rights on the ballot in four states and the historical pattern of white women voting Republican, hosts announce Friday show rebranding and upcoming live stream with Don Lemon.
Speakers
Jennifer — Main host
Josh Welch — Co-host
Angie "Pumps" Sullivan — Co-host
Charlie Goldenson — Co-host