Burden of Proof: Monday, November 9, 2026

Original Media · 23m · English · YouTube · ABC News

TLDR

This episode of Burden of Proof covers three high-profile criminal cases: the trial date set for Tyler Robinson accused of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk (June 2028, death penalty sought); the Naresh Bhat murder trial where the defendant admitted dismembering his wife's body but claims she died by suicide; and the Lindsay Clancy case where a judge denied a motion to dismiss, paving the way for a retrial after an 11-1 hung jury on postpartum psychosis defense. Legal analysts Brian Buckmire and Bernardo Villalona break down jury selection challenges, defense strategies, and the impact of pretrial publicity.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The defense in a "no-body" homicide case may put the defendant on the stand to admit dismemberment, gambling that the prosecution cannot prove murder beyond reasonable doubt.

•

A single holdout juror in Clancy's first trial (11-1 for acquittal by reason of insanity) may not be the defense's target for retrial; they want more jurors like the 11 who voted to acquit.

•

The internet's permanent record (preliminary hearings on YouTube) makes juror impartiality harder over time, not easier, because potential jurors can access evidence independently.

Key takeaways

•

Trial for Charlie Kirk's alleged killer set for June 21, 2028, with 3,500 juror questionnaires due to extensive pretrial publicity and death penalty considerations.

•

In Naresh Bhat's trial, the defense took the unusual step of having the defendant testify to admit dismemberment but deny murder, arguing the prosecution cannot prove cause of death beyond reasonable doubt.

•

Waterfall jury instructions allow jurors to consider lesser included offenses (second-degree murder) but not manslaughter, creating potential for compromise verdicts.

•

Lindsay Clancy's retrial on triple murder charges is likely; the defense must maintain postpartum psychosis argument but change presentation to avoid prosecution anticipation.

•

Jury selection in high-profile cases now requires extensive vetting of social media and prior knowledge due to internet accessibility of evidence.

•

Victims' rights in Utah allow family input on scheduling but not veto power over trial dates.

•

Death penalty cases require two-phase trials (guilt and penalty), significantly extending preparation time.

Notable quotes

“WHEN YOU'RE DEALING WITH A CASE WHERE THE DEATH PENALTY IS ON THE TABLE, YOU'RE DOING TWO TRIALS, AND THOSE TWO TRIALS ARE, NUMBER ONE, AS TO WHETHER HE'S GUILTY... BUT ALSO IF HE IS RESPONSIBLE, THEN IT'S THE SECOND STAGE AND THE SECOND STAGE HAVING TO DEAL WITH WHETHER THE AGGRAVATING FACTORS OUTWEIGH THE MITIGATING FACTORS AND WHETHER HE SHOULD FACE THE DEATH PENALTY.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:42

“IT'S LIKE GOING THROUGH A NEEDLE IN A HAYSTACK. AND THE HOPE IS FOR THE DEFENSE OF THAT NEEDLE IS EITHER DOING 1 OR 2 THINGS. IT'S EITHER CARRYING YOUR ENTIRE CASE OR YOU'RE SAYING, LOOK AT THIS ONE PIECE OF THE INVESTIGATION BECAUSE OF THIS ONE PIECE OF INVESTIGATION BEING FLAWED, YOU CANNOT TRUST THE WHOLE OR IT'S THE IT'S THE, THE GLOVE DON'T FIT. RIGHT.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:52

“THE JOKE GOES ALONG THE LINES OF A DEFENSE ATTORNEY MAKING THIS BRILLIANT CLOSING ARGUMENT AND SAYING, GUYS, IF THERE'S ANY REASONABLE DOUBT, IF YOU TURN TO THE DOOR AND YOU BELIEVE THAT THAT VICTIM IS ABOUT TO WALK THROUGH, THAT'S REASONABLE DOUBT. AND THE DEFENSE ATTORNEY, AMAZINGLY, DOES IT. EVERYONE PAUSES. EVERYONE LOOKS. THREE MINUTES LATER, THEY CONVICT THE GUY.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:45

“I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE IN TERMS OF JURY SELECTION IN THIS CASE, I THINK THERE HAS TO BE AN INDIVIDUAL ANALYSIS AS TO EACH POTENTIAL JUROR, BECAUSE I THINK YOU EXACTLY HAVE TO DO THAT. FURTHER INQUIRY, LIKE, WERE YOU WATCHING THE NEWS? WERE YOU AWARE ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED IN A PREVIOUS PROCEEDING? CAN YOU HONESTLY SIT HERE BEFORE US, BEFORE THIS JUDGE, AND TELL US THAT DESPITE OF WHAT YOU HEARD, YOU ARE WILLING TO BE ABLE TO FOLLOW THE JUDGE'S INSTRUCTIONS AND JUDGE THE FACTS AND EVALUATE THE FACTS AS YOU HEAR IT IN THIS TRIAL AND NOTHING ELSE.”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:02

“WHEN I TALK ON ON NEWS LIVE, I OFTEN MAKE THE COMPARISON OF LIKE, WHEN I WAS IN HIGH SCHOOL, I PLAYED BOTH SOCCER AND BASKETBALL AND SOCCER. I WAS THE TALLEST PERSON ON THE FIELD. BASKETBALL WAS THE SMALLEST. MY HEIGHT DIDN'T CHANGE, BUT IT'S THE ENVIRONMENT IN WHICH I'M IN. IT'S THE PEOPLE RECEIVING THE INFORMATION.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:09

Chapters

•

0:45 — Charlie Kirk Murder Trial Date Set: A Utah judge sets trial for June 21, 2028, for Tyler Robinson, accused of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk. The prosecution seeks the death penalty. Jury selection will involve 3,500 questionnaires, monthly status conferences, and a potential change-of-venue motion. The date splits the difference between defense (late 2029), prosecution (January 2028), and family (fall 2027) requests.

•

10:58 — Naresh Bhat Murder Trial Analysis: Defendant Naresh Bhat testified he found his wife dead, then dismembered her body with a saw. Defense attorneys discuss why putting a client on the stand to admit dismemberment but deny murder can be a viable strategy in a "no-body" homicide where cause of death is unproven. Waterfall jury instructions down to second-degree murder (but not manslaughter) are explained.

•

16:23 — Lindsay Clancy Case Update & Docket: A judge denies Lindsay Clancy's motion to dismiss her triple murder case, clearing the way for a retrial after an 11-1 hung jury. Analysts debate whether prosecutors will retry, how the postpartum psychosis defense must evolve, and the challenge of seating an impartial jury after worldwide coverage. Other docket items include Russell Brand's sentencing and a NYC stabbing case.

Speakers

•

Micah Jackie — Host

•

Brian Buckmire — Criminal Defense Attorney

•

Bernardo Villalona — Criminal Defense Attorney & Former Prosecutor

•

Alex Stone — Reporter

⋮