Christa Pike 911 calls reveal confusion after botched execution

Original Media · 36m · English · YouTube · Brian Entin

TLDR

Newly released 911 calls reveal confusion and a 30-minute delay in emergency response after Christa Pike survived two lethal doses of pentobarbital during her Tennessee execution. Her defense attorney had to call 911 herself because prison medical staff did not. Pike was hospitalized, reportedly declared brain dead, but woke up within 24 hours and was returned to prison days later. Experts say her survival was not a miracle but predictable medical failure due to poor IV access, and legal battles will likely prevent another execution attempt. The victim's family endured 30 years of appeals only to witness a botched execution and be left without closure. Pike was the only woman on Tennessee's death row, living in more isolated conditions than male inmates. Dr. Kimberlin notes most death row inmates show no remorse, but his source indicates Pike is genuinely remorseful. The case will set unprecedented legal precedent. The episode includes audio of two 911 calls and interviews with Dr. Joel Zivot (anesthesiologist) and Dr. Bill Kimberlin (psychologist).

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The defense attorney, not prison medical staff, had to call 911 for emergency help during a state execution.

•

Dispatchers treated the emergency calls with skepticism, requiring a special "code" to verify legitimacy, delaying response by ~30 minutes.

•

Dr. Zivot (hired by defense) explicitly rejects the "miracle" narrative, calling it "the ordinariness of failure" and predictable system failure.

•

Pike was returned to prison within days of a botched execution where she received two lethal doses, suggesting her medical condition stabilized remarkably fast.

•

Most death row inmates Dr. Kimberlin has studied over 20 years show no remorse, contrary to public assumptions about redemption on death row.

Key takeaways

•

The 911 calls reveal significant confusion and delay in emergency response after Pike survived the execution, with dispatchers unsure if calls were legitimate and requiring a special code for prison emergencies, delaying help by about 30 minutes.

•

Pike's defense attorney had to call 911 herself because prison medical staff did not, raising questions about protocol and who was responsible for emergency response during executions.

•

Dr. Joel Zivot (defense expert anesthesiologist) explains Pike's survival wasn't a miracle but ordinary medical failure: the pentobarbital likely didn't enter her bloodstream properly due to poor IV access, and she woke up when the drug wore off.

•

Pike was reportedly declared "brain dead" but woke up within 24 hours; Dr. Zivot says "brain dead" is a specific medical term unlikely to have been formally diagnosed, and her recovery is consistent with intensive care treatment after drug overdose.

•

Dr. Bill Kimberlin believes Pike will never be executed again due to unprecedented legal questions; her case will set precedent and tie up courts for years through state, federal, and Supreme Court appeals.

•

The victim's family (Colleen Slemmer's mother) endured 30 years of appeals only to witness a botched execution and be left without closure; Dr. Kimberlin blames the prosecutor for pursuing the death penalty knowing it would cause decades of relived trauma.

•

Pike was the only woman on Tennessee's death row, living in more isolated conditions than male death row inmates who have more social interaction, phone access, and amenities.

•

Dr. Kimberlin notes most death row inmates he's studied over 20 years show no remorse, but his source indicates Pike is genuinely remorseful, which is rare.

Notable quotes

“There is no miracle here. This is not This is the you know, this is the consequence of of ordinary failure.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:02

“This again, this is the ordinariness of failure. That's what this is. This is a system that failed and it was predictable to fail and it did and that's what this is.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:27

“I do not ever expect her to be executed. Um I think that even if the state of Tennessee would like to, then the appeals processes that the layers of the legal system will start taking effect.”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:52

“If you're going to take the life of another human being, you better damn well make sure you have it 100% correct, in my opinion.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:16

“I don't think there's anybody I feel more sorry for than the mother of the of the victim of Colleen... people do not realize the roller coaster of emotions that that family has endured over the past, you know, three decades.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:50

“So many more people know the name Krista Pike than the victim that lost her life. Uh and that's that's horrible. That's that's a tragedy in in and of itself.”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:37

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & 911 calls overview: Brian Entin introduces the episode covering newly released 911 calls from Christa Pike's botched execution in Tennessee, where she received two lethal doses of pentobarbital but did not die.

•

1:55 — First 911 call: Defense attorney calls for help: Audio of the first 911 call from Pike's attorney Kelly Gleason, who reports Pike is still alive and breathing after completing the execution protocol, needs immediate life-saving care, and has received at least two doses of pentobarbital.

•

6:20 — Second 911 call: Prison staff calls: Audio of a second 911 call from someone at the prison requesting EMS, providing the sally port entry instructions, and coordinating with dispatchers who appear confused about the situation.

•

8:20 — Dispatch confusion & delayed response: Entin explains the AP found emergency help was delayed by confusion among first responders and prison officials; dispatchers needed a special code to verify legitimacy, and about 30 minutes passed before responders were let through the gates.

•

10:30 — Pike's medical status & "miracle" narrative: Pike was taken to Vanderbilt Medical Center, put on a ventilator, reportedly declared brain dead, but woke up the next day, was walking soon after, and released back to prison within days; attorneys and anti-death penalty advocates call it a miracle.

•

11:50 — Dr. Zivot interview: Not a miracle, ordinary failure: Dr. Joel Zivot, anesthesiologist and defense expert, rejects the miracle narrative, explaining Pike's survival is the predictable consequence of IV access failure and the drug wearing off, calling it "the ordinariness of failure."

•

15:35 — Dr. Kimberlin interview: 911 calls reaction & legal outlook: Dr. Bill Kimberlin reacts to the 911 calls, questions why the defense attorney had to call 911, and predicts Pike will never be executed again due to unprecedented legal questions that will tie up courts for years.

•

20:55 — Death row conditions & victim's family impact: Discussion of Pike's isolated conditions as the only woman on death row, the victim's family's 30-year ordeal, and Dr. Kimberlin's criticism of prosecutors for pursuing death penalty knowing it prevents healing.

Speakers

•

Brian Entin — Host/investigative journalist

•

Dr. Joel Zivot — Anesthesiologist, defense expert

•

Dr. Bill Kimberlin — Psychologist, death row researcher

•

911 Dispatcher — Emergency dispatcher

•

Kelly Gleason — Defense attorney

•

Prison staff caller — Prison employee

⋮