Canada is Turning Its Back on the West | Victor Davis Hanson

Original Media · 13m · English · YouTube · The Daily Signal

TLDR

Victor Davis Hanson argues that Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is irrationally destroying the U.S.-Canada relationship over a minor trade dispute involving 2% of bilateral trade, choosing instead to align with illiberal regimes — China, the stagnating EU, and authoritarian Turkey — while the rest of the Western Hemisphere pivots toward the U.S. Hanson contends Canada's own socialist policies have caused economic stagnation, demographic collapse, and military irrelevance, making Carney's anti-American posturing both morally incoherent and strategically suicidal. Carney's stance, Hanson says, is driven by domestic political calculation rather than national interest.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Hanson claims Canada's economy is now the worst-performing among 30 Westernized nations, worse than the crisis-ridden EU.

•

He asserts that 45% of Canada's population is first- or second-generation immigrant and that Canada fails to assimilate them — a more acute problem than the EU faces.

•

Hanson argues the Western Hemisphere is undergoing a historic pro-American, pro-market shift, with only Nicaragua, Cuba, and perhaps Venezuela remaining anti-American — making Canada the new outlier.

Key takeaways

•

The U.S.-Canada trade dispute centers on roughly 2% of $500 billion in annual trade, with Canada running a $50–60 billion surplus, yet Carney refuses simple concessions like lowering the 250% dairy tariff.

•

Carney leveraged anti-Trump sentiment to win electoral support in Quebec and Alberta, turning a manageable trade disagreement into a political crusade against the United States.

•

Carney is pursuing special relationships with three illiberal powers: China, which operates Uyghur labor camps and systematically cheats on trade; the EU, whose economy is $10 trillion smaller than America's and faces riots, stagnation, and demographic collapse; and Turkey, an authoritarian state occupying northern Cyprus and threatening neighbors with missiles.

•

Canada's economy is the weakest among 30 Westernized nations in annual GDP growth, with acute immigration assimilation failures (45% first- or second-generation), below-replacement fertility, and a military that barely meets the 2% NATO target.

•

The United States effectively subsidizes North American continental defense while Canada free-rides, unable to contribute due to its self-inflicted economic malaise from socialist regulation and resource restriction.

•

Nearly every Latin American nation — Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Bolivia, and soon Brazil and Mexico — is shifting toward open markets, democracy, and pro-U.S. alignment, leaving Canada isolated in a hemisphere-wide realignment.

•

Carney's foreign policy contradicts Canada's professed moral superiority: he embraces regimes that persecute minorities, violate sovereignty, and threaten democracies, all over a dispute resolvable for $10–20 billion.

Notable quotes

“He's not only going to be orphaned from the United States, he's soon going to be orphaned from the Western Hemisphere, and he's reaching out to the most illiberal regimes in the world.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:02

“He has 75% of his trade with the United States with almost no transportation cost.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:24

“Canada is now dealing with a special relationship with a country that put a million Uyghurs into labor camps and has the worst record in the modern era of cheating on trade by dumping product below the the cost of production, by currency manipulation, by flagrant disregard for patents or copyright.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:12

“It's like he's now reaching out to a ship that's sinking. Paris is engulfed in 5 weeks of existential rioting. It spread to Italy. Britain is a mess. The German economy is stalled.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:15

“There's roughly 33, 34 nations in the Western Hemisphere. That is North and South and Central America and the Caribbean. We are witnessing one of the most radical changes in the last 50 to 60 years where nation after nation after nation in Latin America is flipping to a open economy, a transparent society, a democratic elected president, a pro-American stance, a pro-Western stance.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:33

“Why in the world would you pick China over the United States? Why would you pick autocratic, illiberal Turkey over democratic and free Greece? And why would you look to the stagnant, ossified, calcified economy of the EU as your model rather than the United States over a mild 10 or 20 billion dollars that you could settle in trade like that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:13

Chapters

•

0:00 — Opening Thesis: Hanson previews his argument: Carney is isolating Canada from the U.S. and the Western Hemisphere to court illiberal regimes over a minor trade dispute.

•

0:40 — Trade Dispute Context: The dispute covers only 2% of $500B in trade; Canada runs a $50–60B surplus and could easily concede on dairy tariffs but refuses.

•

2:14 — Carney's Political Motivation: Carney exploited anti-Trump sentiment to win votes in Quebec and Alberta, turning a technical trade issue into a political identity campaign.

•

3:01 — Pivot to China: Carney seeks a special relationship with China despite its Uyghur labor camps, trade cheating, currency manipulation, and Maoist legacy of mass murder.

•

4:03 — Pivot to the EU: Carney courts a declining EU — $10T smaller GDP than the U.S., stalled growth, riots in Paris, demographic collapse — as an alternative to America.

•

5:47 — Pivot to Turkey: Carney embraces Erdogan's Turkey, which occupies northern Cyprus, persecutes Kurds and Christians, threatens Greece and Israel, and converts Hagia Sophia into a mosque.

•

7:45 — Canada's Structural Decline: Canada's socialist policies have produced the lowest GDP growth in the West, failed immigrant assimilation, collapsing fertility, and a hollowed-out military dependent on U.S. defense.

•

9:33 — Hemispheric Realignment: Latin America is flipping en masse to pro-U.S., pro-market democracy, leaving Canada as the hemisphere's new outlier alongside Nicaragua and Cuba.

Speakers

•

Victor Davis Hanson — Host/Commentator

⋮