Two young women vanish | 20/20 'Hiding Beneath the Surface' Part 1

Original Media · 8m · English · YouTube · ABC News

TLDR

A diver has spent nearly a decade searching the flooded Tilly Foster mine for Robin Murphy, a 16-year-old punk rock fan who vanished from Carmel, New York, on April 9, 1995. Robin was last seen talking to an older laundromat attendant, Howard Gomberg, in her car before walking toward the Burger King where her boyfriend worked; her car was found parked there but she never arrived. The case remains unsolved, and coworkers at the strip mall suspect a link to another missing girl. The mine is 500 feet deep, dark, cold, and was used as a dumping ground where "whatever was thrown in there was never seen again."

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The diver has returned to the same dangerous, flooded mine 419 times over nearly ten years without finding any trace of Robin.

•

Robin's parents did not report her missing for 18 hours despite her car sitting abandoned in a parking lot overnight.

•

Strip mall workers immediately linked Robin's case to another missing girl, implying a pattern that received little attention in the coverage.

Key takeaways

•

A diver has conducted 419 dives into the 500-foot-deep Tilly Foster mine since 2014, driven by a fixation on finding Robin Murphy's remains in a site historically used as a dumping ground.

•

Robin Murphy, 16, vanished on April 9, 1995 after getting a call from Howard Gomberg, an older laundromat attendant, and was last seen walking toward the Burger King where her boyfriend Matt worked; her car remained parked at the lot.

•

Robin and her boyfriend Matt Espazito shared a tight bond — they dressed in matching goth style, wore padlock necklaces, and called each other Sid and Nancy after the infamous punk couple.

•

Robin's parents did not immediately report her missing, assuming she was with friends; it was her best friend who notified Carmel PD after 18 hours, and her sister had an immediate gut feeling something was wrong.

•

Coworkers at the strip mall connected Robin's disappearance to another young girl who went missing, suggesting a possible pattern the police did not publicly pursue.

•

The Tilly Foster mine's conditions — pitch black, near-freezing, extremely claustrophobic — make it a near-perfect concealment site and an exceptionally dangerous search environment.

•

Carmel in the 1990s was a close-knit rural community where letters arrived addressed only to a name and town, and the local weekly newspaper covered everything from birthdays to crime.

•

Robin was a bright, creative teenager who dropped out of high school, worked full-time at ShopRite, and saved money to escape to a big city, making her sudden disappearance wholly out of character.

Notable quotes

“Since 2014, I have dived the Tilly Foster mine 419 times.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:41

“The mine was used as a dumping ground. Whatever was thrown in there was never seen again.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:48

“It's 500 ft deep. It's dark. It's cold. It's very very claustrophobic. So, it's it's dangerous. But I'll never stop searching until I find her.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:55

“Robin Murphy was a kid with big ambitions in a small town. She wanted to be a writer. She wanted to be a singer. She was a born punk rocker.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:30

“They both wore matching padlock necklaces and they called each other Sid and Nancy after punk rock's most infamous couple.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:11

“When Robin disappeared, you know, us workers had talked about the fact, 'Well, hey, we remember that other young girl.' So, as it turns out, Robin Murphy wasn't the only girl that went missing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:31

Chapters

•

0:00 — The Diver's Obsession: A diver describes his nearly decade-long, 419-dive search of the flooded Tilly Foster mine, a 500-foot-deep former dumping ground, driven by a fixation on finding Robin Murphy.

•

2:00 — Carmel and the Courier: A longtime Putnam County Courier journalist paints Carmel as a tight-knit 1990s community where everyone knew each other and the weekly paper chronicled all local life.

•

2:30 — Who Robin Was: Friends, family, and coworkers describe Robin as a smart, sweet, goth-styled punk rock fan with big dreams, a boyfriend named Matt, and a plan to leave town.

•

4:00 — The Strip Mall Circle: The Burger King, laundromat, and ShopRite formed Robin's social orbit; she befriended laundromat attendant Howard Gomberg, an older man, through his girlfriend.

•

5:41 — The Night She Vanished: On April 9, 1995, Robin left work, got a call from Gomberg, met him in her car for ten minutes, then walked toward the Burger King — but never met Matt; her car stayed parked overnight.

•

7:00 — The Missing Report and a Pattern: Robin's best friend reported her missing after 18 hours; her sister knew immediately something was wrong. Coworkers revealed another young girl had also gone missing, hinting at a broader pattern.

Speakers

•

Speaker 1 — Diver / Searcher

•

Speaker 2 — Journalist

•

Speaker 3 — Robin's Sister

•

Speaker 4 — Friend / Coworker (Kevin)

•

Speaker 5 — Friend / Classmate

•

Speaker 6 — Coworker / Narrator

⋮