“THE REAL REASON THE SAUDI MILITARY CAN'T DEFEAT THE HOUTHIS” – Abdullah Alaoudh

Original Media · 10m · English · YouTube · Mario Nawfal

TLDR

Saudi Arabia has replaced the commander of its joint forces command overseeing the Yemen war, appointing General Fiad al-Rui — a figure described as having historically resisted military reform. The move signals Riyadh's priority is coup-proofing the military rather than winning in Yemen, where after 12 years the Houthis control more territory than ever and threaten Red Sea shipping.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Qatar participated in the Saudi-led coalition in Yemen before being blockaded by Saudi Arabia and the UAE.

•

Sudan contributed troops to the Yemen war under former Islamist president Omar al-Bashir.

•

The UAE bombed Saudi-backed Southern Transitional Council forces in 2023, despite being nominal coalition partners.

•

General Fiad al-Rui, now appointed to lead the joint forces, was described as having actively punished Saudi officers who tried to improve their technical skills and equipment readiness.

Key takeaways

•

Saudi King Salman reassigned Lieutenant General Fahad al-Salman from commander of the joint forces command to an advisory role, replacing him with General Fiad al-Rui, amid recent battlefield losses in Yemen.

•

A source close to General Fiad al-Rui describes him as having punished officers who attempted to train or maintain equipment, effectively implementing a policy of keeping the Saudi military weak.

•

The Saudi military's structural weakness stems from the royal family's fear that a strong, professional army could stage a coup; it functions more as a national guard to protect the regime than as an expeditionary force.

•

The leadership change indicates Riyadh's overriding priority is internal coup prevention rather than effective prosecution of the Yemen war or military modernization.

•

In 2015, the Saudi-led coalition entered Yemen from Jazan and Al-Wadiah with Gulf Cooperation Council forces (including Qatari and Emirati troops) and Sudanese contingents; Qatar was later blockaded by its own coalition partners.

•

The war, initially branded 'Decisive Storm' and expected to last weeks, was rebranded 'Restoring Hope' and has dragged on for 12 years with no decisive victory.

•

The Houthis now control significantly more territory than in 2015, including areas they previously never entered, and can threaten Bab al-Mandab shipping without even holding the strait directly.

•

After 12 years of full-spectrum effort, the military option in Yemen has been exhausted; the conflict cannot be won by force alone.

Notable quotes

“he was the one who actually punished the guys who uh try to assemble and deassemble equipments. Uh he was responsible for basically uh I would say implementing the idea of not making the army uh stronger”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:28

“the royal family is worried Saudi more than other countries is worried that if the military is strong enough they could go against the royal family the the military is less so it's more of a national guard rather than expeditionary unit”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:11

“the signal here of appointing is basically to say that their overarching objective and priority at this moment is protecting from coups than really training armies or fighting in Yemen”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:42

“if you learn any lesson from this fight, if you uh have been, you know, uh trying to understand what's going on in Yemen since 2015 and you didn't right now, I don't think you're going to understand anything or or you're even going to learn anything from the from, you know, the war”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:01

Chapters

•

0:00 — Saudi military leadership shakeup: King Salman reassigns the joint forces commander overseeing Yemen to an advisory role, replacing him with General Fiad al-Rui amid recent losses.

•

0:50 — General Fiad al-Rui's record: A source describes the new appointee as having historically resisted military reform and punished officers who attempted to improve training and equipment readiness.

•

2:03 — Structural weakness of Saudi military: The Saudi military is deliberately kept weak because the royal family fears a strong army could threaten its rule; it functions as a coup-proofed national guard rather than an expeditionary force.

•

2:52 — Signal of the appointment: The leadership change signals Riyadh's priority is internal coup prevention over winning in Yemen or building military capability.

•

3:26 — 2015 coalition entry into Yemen: The Saudi-led coalition entered Yemen from Jazan and Al-Wadiah with Gulf forces (including Qatari and Emirati troops) and Sudanese contingents; Qatar was later blockaded by its allies.

•

6:06 — War evolution and rebranding: The war, launched as 'Decisive Storm' for a month-long campaign, was rebranded 'Restoring Hope' and has continued for 12 years without decisive victory.

•

7:50 — Houthi territorial gains and strategic position: Houthis now control more territory than in 2015, including previously inaccessible areas, and can threaten Bab al-Mandab shipping without holding the strait directly.

•

9:56 — War unwinnable militarily: After 12 years of full effort, the military option in Yemen is exhausted; the conflict cannot be won by force alone.

Speakers

•

Speaker 1 — Host/Analyst

•

Speaker 2 (Abdullah) — Co-host/Expert

⋮