TLDR
This episode examines Alaska's ranked choice voting system and its effect on the undecided Senate race, the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact as a state-based strategy to effectively replace the Electoral College by 2028, and the Montana plan using corporate charter law to limit campaign spending. Rob Richie explains how ranked choice voting works in Alaska, why the Electoral College was originally a slavery-era compromise, and how Democratic trifectas in key states could push the popular vote compact over the 270-electoral-vote threshold.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The "decoy" candidate Dan Sullivan (a retired teacher recruited to confuse voters) actually helps Democrat Mary Peltola because his voters' second choices go to her rather than the Republican incumbent.
The Electoral College was originally designed partly to give slave states more power by counting enslaved people toward representation while denying them the vote.
States have always had the constitutional power to effectively end the Electoral College through the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact without a constitutional amendment.
Most Americans believe they directly vote for president and don't realize the Electoral College stands between them and the presidency.
Key takeaways
Alaska's ranked choice voting allows voters to rank candidates, and in the Senate race, the "decoy" Dan Sullivan's voters' second choices go more to Democrat Mary Peltola than to incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan, making the race closer but Peltola is still heavily favored to win.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is a state agreement where states pledge their electoral votes to the national popular vote winner once enough states join to reach 270 electoral votes; 18 states plus DC have already passed it, and new Democratic trifectas in swing states could push it over the threshold by 2028.
The Electoral College was a compromise to accommodate slave states that wanted their population (including enslaved people) to count for representation despite those people being disenfranchised, not a deliberate design for modern democracy.
Americans overwhelmingly support a national popular vote (65-70%), and most mistakenly believe they already directly vote for president.
The Montana plan, passed by a 2:1 margin, uses state corporate charter authority to prohibit corporations from spending money on campaigns, creating a potential state-level workaround to Citizens United.
Ranked choice voting promotes coalition-building among candidates and gives voters more freedom to support third-party or independent candidates without "spoiler" concerns.
The delay in calling Alaska's Senate race is due to the state's rural geography and mail ballot processing time, not ranked choice voting itself.
Notable quotes
“Anytime you've wanted to vote for a third party or an independent candidate um you're in that position of saying, well, if I vote for that person and they can't win, am I just throwing my vote away?”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:19“The constitution gives states certain powers and one is that they can go into a binding agreement with other states.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:48“Every state gets the number of electoral votes equal to their members of Congress regardless of their voter turnout, suffrage rules, or in the case of the uh 18th century, slavery.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:36“States have actually always have the power to make this change.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:59“What's fascinating, I'm sure if you pled Americans and asked them, do you directly vote for president in the United States? Overwhelmingly, they would say yes.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:48“The corporate charters can say corporations do not have the power to give money to campaigns.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:36Chapters
0:00 — Alaska Senate Race and Ranked Choice Voting: Discussion of Alaska's undecided Senate race, how ranked choice voting works, and its impact on the Peltola vs. Sullivan race including the "decoy" candidate effect.
4:57 — National Popular Vote Interstate Compact Explained: Explanation of the compact as a state agreement to award electoral votes to the national popular vote winner once 270 electoral votes are secured, with 18 states plus DC already joined.
7:31 — History of the Electoral College and Slavery Compromise: The Electoral College originated as a compromise to give slave states representation based on total population including enslaved people, not as a deliberate design for modern democracy.
9:10 — Path to 270 and Democratic Trifectas: New Democratic trifectas in swing states like Arizona, Michigan, Wisconsin, Nevada, and Pennsylvania could push the compact over 270 electoral votes by 2028.
12:48 — Public Opinion and the Montana Plan: Americans overwhelmingly support a national popular vote but mistakenly think they already have one; the Montana plan uses corporate charter authority to ban corporate campaign spending.
Speakers
Amy Goodman — Host
Rob Richie — Guest