Are Miami & Indiana CFP rankings falls JUSTIFIABLE? SVP Reacts | SVPod

Original Media · 1h 20m · English · YouTube · ESPN

TLDR

Stanford Steve and Bumpy Red break down the latest College Football Playoff rankings, debating Notre Dame's advantageous path, Alabama's high placement despite two losses, and the Big Ten's perceived weakness. They also evaluate NFL contenders, favoring Jacksonville in the AFC and debating the loaded NFC North, before previewing Steve's upcoming College GameDay trip to Boise State.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Indiana dropped five spots in the rankings on a bye week solely because their nine opponents went a combined 1-8 the previous weekend.

•

Notre Dame could play two fewer games than their quarterfinal opponent if they reach the No. 4 seed, yet Notre Dame fans would prefer a home playoff game over the bye.

•

Alabama is ranked No. 3 with two losses ahead of undefeated UCLA and one-loss Miami, largely because the committee believes in their championship capability rather than their resume.

•

Kirk Cousins looked so lost in his final start for the Raiders that Steve had 'never seen a guy who at one point was good looked like Carson Wentz looked on Monday.'

•

The Rams' remaining schedule (Chiefs, 49ers, Seahawks, Buccaneers, Seahawks) offers virtually no path to the playoffs without Puka Nacua and Cooper Kupp.

Key takeaways

•

Notre Dame sits at No. 5 and could reach the top four without playing a conference championship game or a first-round playoff game, giving them a significant rest advantage that will anger non-Notre Dame fans.

•

The committee appears to rank teams based on perceived capability rather than pure resume, keeping two-loss Alabama at No. 3 ahead of undefeated UCLA because they believe Alabama can win a national championship.

•

Indiana dropped five spots on a bye week because their opponents went 1-8, illustrating how strength of schedule fluctuations can penalize idle teams in the current ranking system.

•

Miami's loss to Georgia Tech without quarterback Cam Ward was more impressive than the result suggests, as they competed at a high level against a desperate Notre Dame team missing their best receiver.

•

The NFC North is historically deep: seven of eight teams in the NFC North and NFC South have winning records, but two of Detroit, Minnesota, Green Bay, and Chicago will miss the playoffs despite being 'awfully capable.'

•

Minnesota's trade for Kirk Cousins gives them a competent quarterback who just needs to be average for their elite defense to make them a playoff team, though his Monday night performance for Vegas was 'astounding' in how lost he looked.

•

Boise State has maintained a Group of Five standard for decades across coaching changes, and their upcoming GameDay visit is expected to draw a record crowd as they chase a playoff berth with Heisman candidate Ashton Jeanty.

•

The hosts favor Jacksonville as the AFC's most complete team, citing their dominant blowout wins, defensive additions, and Trevor Lawrence's efficiency, while expressing skepticism about Denver's unsustainable yardage differential.

Notable quotes

“They're not losing again. I don't think SMU is very dangerous. We know that. Or at least I believe that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:54

“This is great. Uh Scott, cuz this morning I woke up, I did uh Pete Samson and Matt Fortune's Notre Dame podcast. Awesome. Awesome guys. They cover Notre Dame. Uh the first question was like, "How awesome was it?" I was like, "Actually, it did live up to the hype and all that."”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:43

“They could possibly play two less games than the team that they're going to play in whatever bowl game they end up. They're automatically in the quarters if they move up one spot to the four because you get the buy.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:12

“I look at them as capability. I believe they can win a national championship. I don't think UCLA can.”

▸ Notable quotes · 24:42

“The ability to tackle in space. And I mean, first guy gets you down without assistance. You said, you mentioned Georgia. That's the team that I always think of as being as good as anybody.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:57

“Hardest thing to do. Look, hardest thing to do in the at the top of the food chain when you have every built-in advantage and millions and million tens of millions of dollars in your pocket. You got a war chest. Look at some of the power broker teams that we're talking about this year. just, you know, can't lose a game at Ohio State, man. They've lost three and they're just searching.”

▸ Notable quotes · 63:05

Chapters

•

0:04 — Dog banter and personal updates: The hosts discuss Bumpy Red's allergic reaction to groomer shampoo and debate bar soap versus body wash for travel.

•

3:04 — College Football Playoff rankings reaction: Analysis of the new rankings: Indiana's bye-week drop, Alabama at No. 3 with two losses, Miami's fall, and the committee's apparent SEC bias.

•

13:34 — Notre Dame's advantageous path: Notre Dame at No. 5 could reach the top four and get a quarterfinal bye without playing a conference title game or first-round game, creating a unique rest advantage.

•

16:54 — Miami's impressive loss and ACC perception: Miami competed well without Cam Ward against Notre Dame; the committee doesn't view the ACC as a power conference, hurting Miami and SMU.

•

9:02 — Big Ten weakness and Oregon's resume concerns: UCLA and Indiana prop up the Big Ten; Oregon's best win may be Week 1 over Boise State, and their remaining schedule offers little resume boost.

•

39:46 — NFL discussion: AFC contenders: Jacksonville favored as most complete AFC team; Buffalo's defense questioned; Cincinnati loved for Burrow; Denver's unsustainable yardage differential noted.

•

46:54 — NFC North depth and Kirk Cousins trade: Seven of eight NFC North/South teams are capable but two will miss playoffs; Minnesota's Cousins acquisition analyzed — he just needs to be average for their defense to win.

•

57:04 — Boise State GameDay preview and tangents: Steve previews College GameDay trip to Boise expecting record crowd; discussions on parachute invention, flip phones, and Lyman Orchard cider donuts.

Speakers

•

Stanford Steve — Host

•

Bumpy Red — Co-host

•

Jack — Producer

•

Swag — Colleague

⋮