TLDR
Josh and Vee play a grocery price-guessing game to determine who cooks with premium versus budget ingredients, then prepare mashed potatoes, broccoli/broccolini, and steak with pan sauce. A taste test by crew member Lucas reveals the expensive USDA Prime steak and broccolini win, but surprisingly the cheaper russet mashed potatoes beat the Yukon Golds.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The premium Straus organic cream costs the same as the store-brand Lucerne at checkout, though the glass bottle adds a $3 deposit.
Kerrygold butter is more than three times the price per ounce of the store brand, yet both are just butter from grass-fed vs conventional cows.
Broccolini at $4.29 is far cheaper than Josh's $24 Whole Foods memory, suggesting price varies wildly by retailer.
Lucas preferred the cheaper russet mashed potatoes, contradicting the hosts' assumption that Yukon Golds are superior for mashing.
The $8.99 bone broth had no collagen body and tasted worse than the $7.99 Swanson, which at least works for chili.
Key takeaways
Yellow potatoes cost $5.69 for five pounds while russets are $3.29, yet Lucas preferred the texture of the cheaper russet mash, noting the air incorporation made them lighter.
Straus organic heavy whipping cream and the store-brand Lucerne both rang up at $5.99 per pint, though the Straus bottle carries a $3 deposit refundable only if returned.
Kerrygold butter costs $8 for eight ounces versus $2.50 for sixteen ounces of store brand — over three times the price per ounce — which Josh called 'criminal' for a domestic product.
Broccolini was only $4.29 a bunch at this market, far less than the $24 Josh used to pay at Whole Foods, while regular broccoli crowns cost $1.73.
A single lemon costs 99¢, while a bottle of Sicilian lemon juice is $1.99 — just a dollar more for the convenience of not zesting and juicing.
Domestic Sartori Parmesan (7 oz) costs $8.99, while pre-shredded domestic Parmesan is $5.99; Josh argued Trader Joe's grated Pecorino Romano is better value and flavor.
USDA Prime ribeye ran $25.25 for roughly one pound, while the alternative cut was not priced on camera but implied to be significantly cheaper.
Shallots cost just 59¢ each versus 99¢ for a red onion, making them an affordable upgrade for pan sauces despite their fancy reputation.
Bone broth ($8.99) tasted like 'butt cheeks' — flavorless and needing heavy salt — while Swanson beef broth ($7.99) is the 'official broth of stepdads' for serviceable chili.
Lucas, the blind taster, preferred Josh's entire plate: the expensive Prime steak, the broccolini, and unexpectedly the russet mashed potatoes over the Yukon Golds.
Notable quotes
“God dang it, groceries are god dang too expensive.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:00“Inflation can't make it underground. The layer of topsoil by the inflation rates go down.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:58“That's crazy that the local organic heavy whipping cream is literally the same as like the store brand.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:31“What kind of racket Kerrygold got? What's in this? Sawdust?”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:59“You're charging for a domestic product, 8.99? Criminal.”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:11“Wow, that tastes like butt cheeks.”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:51Chapters
0:00 — Intro & Game Setup: Josh and Vee complain about grocery prices and introduce a price-guessing game where the winner gets the premium ingredient for each component of a steak, mashed potato, and broccoli dinner.
0:49 — Potatoes: Yellow vs Russet: They guess prices for five-pound bags: yellow potatoes at $5.69, russets at $3.29. Vee wins with $8.99 guess, forcing Josh to use russets.
2:20 — Cream & Butter: Straus organic cream and Lucerne store brand both cost $5.99 per pint (Straus has a $3 bottle deposit). Kerrygold butter is $8 for 8 oz vs $2.50 for 16 oz store brand — a 3x+ price gap.
11:00 — Broccolini vs Broccoli: Broccolini costs $4.29 a bunch, regular broccoli crown $1.73. Josh recalls paying $24 for broccolini at Whole Foods, highlighting retailer price variance.
13:12 — Lemon & Parmesan: Fresh lemon 99¢, jarred Sicilian lemon juice $1.99. Domestic Sartori Parmesan (7 oz) $8.99 vs pre-shredded $5.99; Josh champions Trader Joe's Pecorino Romano.
21:00 — Steak, Shallot, Onion, Bone Broth: USDA Prime ribeye $25.25/lb. Shallots 59¢ each vs red onion 99¢. Bone broth $8.99 tastes flavorless; Swanson $7.99 is the 'stepdad standard' for chili.
26:00 — Cooking: Mash, Broccoli, Steak: They boil potatoes whole, mash with butter and cream. Blanch then sauté broccoli/broccolini with garlic, lemon, Parmesan. Sear steaks, finish in oven, make pan sauces with shallot/onion, Dijon, Worcestershire, bone broth/Swanson.
30:00 — Tasting & Verdict: Crew member Lucas tastes blind. He prefers Josh's Prime steak and broccolini, but surprisingly chooses Vee's russet mashed potatoes over the Yukon Golds, citing better air incorporation.
Speakers
Josh — Host/Chef
Vee — Co-host/Chef
Annaliese — Producer
James — Audio Engineer
Lucas — Crew Member/Taster