The $170 Million Baby Reindeer Lawsuit. Alec Baldwin Objects to Gutierrez’s Immunity. TES Ep 284

Original Media · 58m · English · YouTube · Emily D. Baker

TLDR

Emily D. Baker covers two major legal stories: Alec Baldwin's defense team opposes the prosecution's late motion to grant use immunity to Hannah Gutierrez-Reed so she can testify at Baldwin's July trial, arguing it's untimely and prejudicial. Separately, Fiona Harvey has filed a $170M+ lawsuit against Netflix over 'Baby Reindeer,' claiming the show's 'this is a true story' label falsely portrays her as a twice-convicted stalker who sexually assaulted creator Richard Gadd, when she has never been convicted of any crime. Netflix executives repeated the 'convicted stalker' claim under oath to the UK House of Commons. Internet sleuths identified Harvey within days via a 2014 tweet, leading to death threats and severe emotional distress. Richard Gadd is not named as a defendant.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Netflix did not verify whether Fiona Harvey had any criminal convictions before labeling the series 'this is a true story' and depicting her as a twice-convicted stalker who served prison time.

•

Richard Gadd, the show's creator and star who wrote the autobiographical one-man show, is not a defendant in the lawsuit — only Netflix is sued, despite the allegations originating from his material.

•

A 2014 tweet from Harvey ('my curtains need hung badly') was publicly searchable on X when the show premiered, allowing internet sleuths to identify her within days, yet Netflix's 'reasonable precautions' to disguise her identity failed to account for this.

•

Netflix's own CEO Ted Sarandos attributed the show's success to the algorithm ('Baby Reindeer got picked up in the algorithm'), which the lawsuit argues may be an attempt to distance Netflix from editorial responsibility for promoting the 'true story' claim.

Key takeaways

•

Baldwin's defense argues the state's motion to grant use immunity to Hannah Gutierrez-Reed is untimely because the prosecution knew since March she would invoke her Fifth Amendment right due to her pending appeal, yet waited until weeks before trial to seek immunity, prejudicing the defense's ability to prepare.

•

The defense highlights a double standard: prosecutors previously claimed the defense's timely witness disclosures were 'sandbagging' with 30 days to prepare, but now the state wants to add a witness with hundreds of undisclosed statements (likely jail calls) with only two weeks until trial.

•

Fiona Harvey's lawsuit centers on Netflix's explicit on-screen claim 'this is a true story' — not 'based on' or 'inspired by' — which the complaint calls 'the biggest lie in television history' because Harvey has never been convicted of any crime, a fact supported by an official certificate from Scottish authorities.

•

Netflix executive Benjamin King testified to the UK House of Commons that 'Baby Reindeer is obviously a true story of the horrific abuse that Richard Gad suffered at the hands of a convicted stalker,' a statement the lawsuit argues is defamation per se since it accuses Harvey of a crime she didn't commit.

•

Internet users identified Harvey as the real-life 'Martha' within days of the show's release by finding a 2014 tweet ('my curtains need hung badly') matching a distinctive phrase from the series, leading to widespread harassment, death threats, and Harvey becoming housebound with severe anxiety and physical symptoms.

•

The lawsuit seeks over $170 million in damages across six causes of action including defamation, intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligence, and right of publicity violations, and notably does not name Richard Gadd as a defendant despite the show being his autobiographical one-man show adapted for Netflix.

Notable quotes

“welcome to the Emily show I'm Emily D Baker the internet's go-to legal analyst and big fan of the cursy words I've been a licensed attorney for over 17 years I'm a former prosecutor and I break down the legal side of pop culture and entertainment Stories We Can't Stop talking about”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:12

“the states late filed always a dig we always start with a dig the state's late filed motion for use immunity to secure live testimony from Hannah Gutierrez Reed should be denied”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:12

“The Beginning of baby reindeer on the screen in text says this is a true story it doesn't say this is based on a true story it doesn't say this is inspired by a true story it says this is a true story”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:42

“preliminary statement the above quote from the first episode of the Netflix series baby reindeer is the biggest lie in television history”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:38

“baby reindeer is obviously a true story of the horrific abuse that Richard Gad suffered at the hands of a convicted stalker we did take every reasonable precaution in disguising the real life identities of the people whilst striking a balance with the veracity and authenticity of the story”

▸ Notable quotes · 44:51

“so that is the $170 million lawsuit against Netflix over the show baby reindeer brought from Fiona Harvey who has identified herself and says she was identified by the internet as the real life Martha”

▸ Notable quotes · 52:10

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Sponsor: Emily D. Baker introduces the episode, covering two stories: Alec Baldwin's trial litigation and the Baby Reindeer Netflix lawsuit, with a PolicyGenius sponsorship.

•

3:00 — Alec Baldwin Trial & Use Immunity Motion: Baldwin's July trial approaches; prosecution seeks use immunity for Hannah Gutierrez-Reed to testify. Defense opposes as untimely, prejudicial, and a double standard given prior prosecution arguments about witness disclosure deadlines.

•

13:40 — Baby Reindeer Lawsuit Overview: Fiona Harvey sues Netflix in federal court over 'Baby Reindeer,' claiming the show's 'this is a true story' label falsely depicts her as a convicted stalker. She was identified within days via a 2014 tweet matching dialogue from the show.

•

17:47 — Lawsuit Details & Key Allegations: The complaint alleges defamation per se (accusing Harvey of crimes she didn't commit), intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligence, and right of publicity violations. Harvey has an official certificate showing zero convictions.

•

44:53 — Netflix's Statements & House of Commons Testimony: Netflix executive Benjamin King testified under oath to UK Parliament that the show is 'obviously a true story' about a 'convicted stalker,' which the lawsuit cites as a defamatory statement made in an official capacity.

•

52:15 — Damages & Broader Implications: Harvey seeks $170M+ in damages. The case raises questions about streaming platforms' duty to verify 'true story' claims, the impact of internet sleuths on real people, and whether 'based on true events' disclaimers would provide legal protection.

Speakers

•

Emily D. Baker — Host

⋮